News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by rayiner on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:11PM (#5623208)
Wildly inaccurate. What the article is doing is comparing the 40 year return at 7% to a 40 year return at 7% minus 2% management fees, and noting that your total return in the second case is about half as much as your total return in the second case.

Of course all that tells you is that it's stupid to pay 2% management fees if you can get the same return with lower management fees. That's obvious. Whether you can get the same return by yourself is a separate issue. Now, in the long run, your typical investor is going to get the same return (pre-fees) with active management with 2% fees as he does with an index fund at 0.1% fees, hence he's going to come out ahead using an index fund. But at least in theory what Wall Street is selling you here is better return than what you could make on an index fund.

In a way, it's the same as every other product that drives the modern economy. They're selling you an idea (in this case, that active management will yield higher returns). In reality, its the same cheap Chinese crap everyone else is selling.

Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by aliston on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:22PM (#5623257)
"in the long run, your typical investor is going to get the same return with active management with 2% fees as he does with an index fund at 0.1% fees."

This point is extremely contentious. Particularly in the long run, there is a lot of data to show that actively managed funds do not beat market indexes. With fees, they come out considerably behind.

Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by ams6110 on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:30PM (#5623296)
True, but one thing a financial advisor can do is counsel you through market volatility. Absent this, many unskilled investors will fall into a "buy high, sell low" pattern and end up FAR worse off.
Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by Matt_Cutts on Sunday April 28, 2013 @10:09PM (#5623722)
Vanguard does an excellent job of reminding their investors to stay the course, invest for the long haul, and not try to time the market.
Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by sootzoo on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:30PM (#5623292)
> But at least in theory what Wall Street is selling you here is better return than what you could make on an index fund.

Often, 401k's offer few, if any, index funds and at drastically higher fees, even if the fees are lower than actively-managed funds.

To take a personal example, I have retirement accounts with Vanguard (Roth IRA), T. Rowe Price (solo 401k) and, through my employer, with MassMutual. All offer an S&P 500 index fund, but Vanguard's fee is 5 basis points (.05%), TRP's is 30 basis points, and MM's is 90(!). Why am I paying almost 20 times as much in fees through my employer?

Sure, you could put this back on my employer and say, "well, they should offer you a 401k with better options/lower fees/with a better vendor," and though I'd agree, it's not as though I have any say in the matter, which is the point that Bogle and Frontline are making.

Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by bradleyjg on Sunday April 28, 2013 @09:12PM (#5623591)
If you can't pick a winning stock portfolio, what makes you think you can pick a winning stock manager? (And vice-versa)

Actively management mutual funds are pure snake oil. Anyone with a whiff of the ability to generate alpha goes to the hedge funds, where you get the pleasure of paying 2 and 20 for it. Even there, there are no guarantees (though SAC with it's all insider trading, all the time, comes close.)

Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by SapphireSun on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:28PM (#5623281)
So I ran this program:

p = 100000 w = 0 for i in range(50): p = p * 1.07 w = w * 1.07 w = w + (p * 0.02) p = 0.98 * p

print "Year: " + str(i+1) print "\t You: {:.2f}".format(p) print "\tWall St.: {:.2f}".format(w)

And what is remarkable is that around year 35, wall street starts making more money than you do even though you're the one putting the money into it (assuming wall street is earning the same interest you are. If you account for (reasonable) salaries and overhead, It changes the numbers quite a bit.)

Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by rayiner on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:31PM (#5623298)
This is assuming you can get the same return, pre-fees, as Wall Street can. This is generally true, but what they're selling you is the idea that this isn't true.

Which is my point. It's not some evil Wall Street thing, it's like every other sector of the economy. Ralph Lauren sells jeans made in the same Chinese sweatshop as Levis, but you pay a premium for the illusion that it's different.

Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by antiterra on Sunday April 28, 2013 @08:15PM (#5623446)
I get your point but paying more for financial services is very different than paying more for a retail product.

If you pay more, you can buy jeans made in the USA from both Ralph Lauren and Levi. The fabric may be from a Cone Denim factory in China instead of the White Oak Cone Denim factory in the US, but my impression of the denim mills is that it's far from your stereotypical sweatshop.

Further, there are brands that are entirely made in the US from mill to assembly, from the affordable brands like Gusset to high end like Raleigh Denim.

Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by chubot on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:25PM (#5623271)
Now, in the long run, your typical investor is going to get the same return with active management with 2% fees as he does with an index fund at 0.1% fees.

How? Are you claiming that active management actually works?

You might be able to beat an index fund with active management, but you also might lose big. It's an illusion. Without foresight, you're just as likely to have chosen Warren Buffet as Bernie Madoff to manage your money :)

Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by rayiner on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:28PM (#5623280)
Corrected. I meant you'll get the same return before paying management fees.
Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by greedo on Monday April 29, 2013 @09:14AM (#5625884)
Okay, since we're not linking to any studies backing up our statements, I decided to look at the historical performance of the funds offered by my company. There are currently 40 funds available. The best performing index fund is returning around 11%, with a 0.15% expense ratio. This 11% return is beating 37 of the 40 funds. When you factor in expense ratios, it's beating all of the competing 39 funds, many by a wide, wide margin.

Now obviously, this is a small sample. There are many funds out there that might be doing better. And yes, my timeframe is short; evaluating returns on a single year (especially a bull year like 2013) is foolish. But so is making generalizations about fund performance.

And here are some links to support the notion that relying on actively managed funds is counterproductive:

http://money.usnews.com/money/personal-finance/mutual-funds/...

http://business.time.com/2012/02/24/index-funds-win-again-th...

http://us.spindices.com/resource-center/thought-leadership/s...

Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by rayiner on Monday April 29, 2013 @10:02AM (#5626157)
I'm not disagreeing with you. I'm saying that for the typical investor, the actively managed funds don't outperform the indices above the line, so they lose substantially after you take out management fees.
Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by NoPiece on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:22PM (#5623260)
And these days, .1% is even a bit high for an index fund. I think Vanguard recently lowered total stock fund to .05%
Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by ChuckMcM on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:17PM (#5623232)
"Of course all that tells you is that it's stupid to pay 2% management fees if you can get the same return with lower management fees."

It is a bit more nuanced than that, basically it's saying you don't have any control over what sort of fee structure your 401k has in place, and goes on to suggest that banks abuse that lack of control. So yes, if you can, you need to reduce your management fees.

Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by rayiner on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:18PM (#5623240)
Who doesn't have the option to invest in low fee funds? That's really your employers fault.
Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by ChuckMcM on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:23PM (#5623266)
agree 100%, and that mitigates 'dip 2' as it were, but few rank and file employees get to tell the bank managing the company's 401K which funds to use, they also don't get to negotiate the fees that the managing bank is charging either.
Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by joe_bleau on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:37PM (#5623317)
Any recommendations for who my employer should be using that would allow us to invest in low fee funds? We're really small, so most people have told me we just don't have the leverage to negotiate a better plan.
Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by cdjk on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:42PM (#5623340)
The company I worked use to use ADP's 401k, which wasn't very good. We've switched to The Hartford, which is decent, but I've only heard good things about Vanguard.
Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by danielweber on Monday April 29, 2013 @10:25AM (#5626324)
There are options for small employers. I think SIMPLE is one of them, but that's off the top of my head.
Re:Wall Street Is Gobbling Up Two-Thirds of Your 401(k) by greenyoda on Sunday April 28, 2013 @07:19PM (#5623243)
"Of course all that tells you is that it's stupid to pay 2% management fees if you can get the same return with lower management fees."

Even if I have to pay 2% to the management company, I'm still coming out ahead by putting money into my 401(k) because:

1. I can't put nearly as much money into a tax-deferred account on my own (the yearly limits on IRAs are much lower than on 401(k)s).

2. My employer doesn't match a percentage of my contribution if I invest the money on my own.