Here's some good (possibly more "fair" than I've been above) discussion if anyone wants to read/think about this more:
http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/22/bayesian-and-fre...
http://www.quora.com/What-is-the-difference-between-Bayesian...
It seems to me, and the commenters on stats.stackexchange [1] that this comic both misinterprets frequentist statistics and misrepresents Bayesian statistics. I realize that XKCD is a nerdy comic meant to be entertaining - I just wanted to leave this discussion here in case anyone else is confused; I think this is an important distinction and one most people interested in statistics should spend some time thinking about.
[1] http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/43339/whats-wrong-w...
Edit: I can't edit my first comment now, but gweinberg's post (sibling to the grandparent of this) words the problem perfectly.
I don't know the particular DNA test used in this case, but lets assume it gave a certainty of 92% that the DNA isolated was from AK. This means that the particular sequences of DNA identified could have come from another person with a probably of 0.08 (i.e. a one-in-12.5 chance, which is not particularly low in a case like this). It does not mean that the DNA is correctly characterized with a probability of 92%.
For a repeated test to give a different probability, the identity of one or more of the sequences isolated from the sample would have to have been incorrect in one of the assays, i.e. there is a procedural error.
It is not at all like tossing coins. An analogy would be getting someone's eye color as blue the first time and brown the second.
P(H0|observation) = P(observation|H0) * P(H0) / P(observation)
P(observation) = P(observation|H0) * P(H0) + P(observation|!H0) * P(!H0)
A normal significance test tells you P(observation|H0). [Though I'm not sure about P(observation|!H0)]. To apply Bayes' Rule you need P(H0), where P(H0)=???
I'm not a statistician, but if you toss a fair coin 20 times, there is about 0.1% chance of getting 17 heads, but to figure out the probability that the coin is fair given this data, it seems you need Bayes' theorem, which requires a prior probability on the coin being fair.