There's a difference between a knife drenched in blood and a tiny bit of blood from a cut, certainly, but as far as forensics goes that may not matter - they may want to find any evidence of blood, like some blood caught in the space between the handle and the blade, on the assumption that a killer may have tried to clean blood off a weapon.
Surely cleaning blood off the knife makes just as much sense if it was a cooking accident as if you've killed someone with it?
That's a strong claim.
I'm not a professional chef but I like to use a chef's knife, and I cut rather fast. Yet I don't remember ever cutting myself to the point of bleeding. I only remember scraping off nails and skin.
> like some blood caught in the space between the handle and the blade
I reckon that if it gets stuck between the handle and the blade then we're talking about more than a little blood.
I rarely cook, but I work on cars a lot. Cutting my hands and fingers is part of the routine. Oddly, such cuts have never gotten infected, even when the dirt gets embedded below the skin. I think car grease is an effective bacteriacide!
(I find wearing gloves while working on a car uncomfortable, though I'll do it when cracking a rusted nut loose - when it finally gives way you'll always bang your hand against something.)
It'd seem a retest would only matter if there's a new test or the previous test was suspected to be improperly done. In any case, you'd need a reason to believe a different outcome is possible.
In this case, a quick search finds[1]. It says evidence and sample procedures were not properly followed, and there wasn't even evidence of blood on the knife.
I'm all for being corrected on statistics, but this doesn't seem like a case of bad math, does it?
1: http://www.westseattleherald.com/2011/06/29/news/update-dna-...