News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by OGinparadise on Sunday April 28, 2013 @08:16AM (#5620958)
Reason #12 why I will not use Google Glass or talk (beyond "hi" and "Yeah, nice weather") to one that has them on. I don't care how much they keep pushing them, they have their agenda, I have mine.

Stuff like this has the potential of ruining lives and relationships.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by ditojim on Sunday April 28, 2013 @02:37PM (#5622211)
your mobile phone has the exact same capabilities as glass. it just isn't mounted on your face.
Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by corresation on Sunday April 28, 2013 @08:48AM (#5621049)
Unwanted sharing is not cool, however when you say-

Stuff like this has the potential of ruining lives and relationships.

Do you mean that truth has the potential of ruining lives and relationships?

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by kevingadd on Sunday April 28, 2013 @09:08AM (#5621107)
The idea that context-free photos uploaded to the internet (and potentially shared with the public) without the subject's permission somehow represent 'truth' is hilarious.

If they say a picture's worth a thousand words, then it's not much of a leap to apply this quote:

"If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him."

How many pictures out of context do you think it would take to ruin the average person's marriage? Destroy their career? Make them a public laughingstock? Not many pictures, if you choose the right ones.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by corresation on Sunday April 28, 2013 @11:00AM (#5621438)
The idea that you can misphrase what I actually said so grotesquely is itself "hilarious".

The GP opined that photos ruin lives and relationships. I've yet to hear a scenario where a unwantedly shared photo ruined either a life or relationship where it wasn't that it actually revealed a hidden truth.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by sesqu on Sunday April 28, 2013 @11:15AM (#5621494)
You're awfully close to a No true Scotsman argument, there. However, if you're interested in damaging photos that aren't secret, you need but take a look at the history of social news. There have been a number of high-profile false allegations with associated vigilantism.
Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by pessimizer on Sunday April 28, 2013 @12:39PM (#5621783)
>You're awfully close to a No true Scotsman argument, there.

Not really. More an argument that all Scotsmen are men.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by corresation on Sunday April 28, 2013 @12:24PM (#5621737)
I'm nowhere near that fallacy. I am specifically looking for examples to the claim that I questioned (the single example provided to me thus far actually supports exactly what I said).

That the crowd can be stupid (as in the recent Reddit Boston bombing nonsense) has absolutely no relevance to this.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by sesqu on Sunday April 28, 2013 @05:01PM (#5622752)
So what you're looking for is 1) a photo 2) not depicting a secret 3) publicized unintentionally 4) that ruined a life or relationship 5) without involving mass misunderstanding

Sorry, I can't provide one for you. The documentation on such events is typically kept to a small circulation.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by a3n on Sunday April 28, 2013 @09:27AM (#5621164)
Yes, truth does have that potential, or even more accurately, the mistakes made that truth reveals.

Humans make mistakes in judgment. Sometimes not revealing those mistakes (lying, if you will) let you grow through it. Someone might conceal a mistake for life, or reveal it after time has passed, or confess immediately. Unless there's a law enforcement agency trying to get at the truth, I think it's best left up to an individual how to deal with everyday mistakes.

And they are everyday mistakes, because that's our nature.

We're dealing with this issue already in our schools. It used to be if two kids fought in the halls, a teacher or principle would deal with it. Suspension at most, rarely expulsion. The school would almost never bring the matter to the attention of law enforcement except in rare cases. But it's against the law to fight, and they concealed it from law enforcement.

Now police are often stationed in schools. My kid's high school, and the middle school before that, has a dedicated officer. And he has said if he sees you breaking the law he'll arrest you. Do we need more kids contacting the justice system, for doing what kids do as they outgrow being kids? It's the truth, but is it right?

Do you ever spell check or read over what you've written before you submit writing? Shouldn't the computer stream everything as written, so everyone would know the truth about your spelling, grammar and judgment?

I look out the window and I see a lot of color. I'm really glad it's not all black and white.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by sesqu on Sunday April 28, 2013 @11:20AM (#5621506)
There's more to it than mistakes. I'm reminded of an advice column from a few weeks back where someone had found out that their recently dead grandmother had been homosexual and was wondering whether to share this with her homophobic family.
Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by a3n on Sunday April 28, 2013 @11:44AM (#5621603)
Excellent point. Sometimes things are nobody's business simply because we decide so. That's a good thing.
Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by rayiner on Sunday April 28, 2013 @02:21PM (#5622161)
People who aren't socially disabled recognize that you don't always tell all the people all that is true. I'd never deny say surfing for porn, but that doesn't mean I want my mom to know my porn viewing tastes.
Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by claudius on Sunday April 28, 2013 @08:57AM (#5621071)
> Do you mean that truth has the potential of ruining lives and relationships?

Yes, if context is missing. And context will most likely be missing from ‘leaked’ information – and if the subject is sufficiently emotional, people will have little reason left to wait for/inquire about said context.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by vidarh on Sunday April 28, 2013 @09:02AM (#5621086)
> Do you mean that truth has the potential of ruining lives and relationships?

Of course it has.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by jebeng on Sunday April 28, 2013 @09:21AM (#5621142)
Sometimes the information portrayed does not represent the truth and lacks context.

Truth is not what most people fear. It's absence of truth and the assumption that something is true that can do the most damage.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by corresation on Sunday April 28, 2013 @10:52AM (#5621404)
Give some examples, please. In the overwhelming majority of unwanted picture releases, it is actually the truth that caught people out, not anything "out of context" (which is the ultimate weasel phrase. "Sure I said that racist jokes..but you have to understand that I'm being taken out of context: There weren't any black people in hearing range!").

The teacher that actually has a night life, outside of the lie that everyone sits knitting sweaters for kittens at night. Etc. It is the individual and social lies that get unfurled.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by SoftwareMaven on Sunday April 28, 2013 @03:39PM (#5622440)
the overwhelming majority of cases...

So you recognize there are cases? Why isn't it "In all cases..."?

Answer that and you'll have your answer.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by lazyjones on Monday April 29, 2013 @04:04AM (#5624678)
> Give some examples, please

You connect to an old friend of the opposite sex on fb. He/she is a silly git and the first thing he/she does is post an old photo with you and him/her visibly drunk on your fb wall. Your current partner sees it and assumes it's a relatively current photo and thus thinks you're cheating on him/her.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by gnud on Sunday April 28, 2013 @02:46PM (#5622241)
Well - if that social lie is nessescary for that teacher to keep her job, it seems pretty harsh to sit on your high horse and say 'lies are the reason - not unintended sharing'.

The customary examples in this discussion are battered wives hiding from their abusive husbands, and homosexuals in the UaE.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by corresation on Monday April 29, 2013 @12:21PM (#5627100)
Is it a high horse? Quite a few people seemed to knee-jerk to that assumption, yet it was absolutely nothing of the sort.

Much of society lives a lie (such as the nonsense that teachers live puritanical lives). Those lies are unsustainable with the continued impact of technology on our lives.

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by Evbn on Sunday April 28, 2013 @11:41AM (#5621588)
Teachers get fired for drinking alcohol outside of work, because their employers force them to lie.
Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by threeseed on Sunday April 28, 2013 @09:19AM (#5621136)
Are you arguing that truth doesn't have the potential ?

If so. Care to upload photos of your passport, credit card and social security documentation ?

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by corresation on Sunday April 28, 2013 @09:41AM (#5621191)
It is a sad day on Hacker News when the majority of replies to my basic question are these nonsensical, defensive, attack replies, as if everyone needs to pick a side and wave a flag. Rar rar!
Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by bdunbar on Sunday April 28, 2013 @11:30AM (#5621539)
> Do you mean that truth has the potential of ruining lives and relationships?

Of course it can.

If you don't believe me, please do answer honestly when your wife asks 'does this outfit make my bum look big?'

Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by qu4z-2 on Sunday April 28, 2013 @08:08PM (#5623422)
Truth is a little more than a random smattering of facts.
Re:Girl unaware all her pictures are sent to journalist by ditojim on Sunday April 28, 2013 @02:36PM (#5622210)
you're mobile phone has the exact same capabilities as glass. it just isn't mounted on your face.