On not releasing full-length tracks: if there is demand, someone will do it for you. You get to choose if interested listeners get it from piratebay or your own website.
As for piracy, it's a good question. Keep in mind I'm pretty small-potatoes. The question is, for a largely anonymous indie-artist, is the piracy risk of releasing physically-only greater than or less than the piracy risk of releasing digitally? My hypothesis is that it's less. But I'd have to find a way to measure availability and popularity of my tracks on pirate sites. If there's a way to measure a spike of demand, and ascertain that it's from people that would buy the digital tracks if they were available, then yeah, it would make sense to speed up the time frame of the digital release. But I don't really have any thoughts yet on how to measure that kind of thing.
I agree, I think that expecting fans to buy your album twice is unrealistic. But there is a middle ground in the approach that mp3.com pioneered (and was mortally wounded in court for) -- sell the physical disc and include an immediately available digital download as part of the package.
I expect that you could put both options up on your website - $10 for CD only or $13 for combo CD+MP3 and you'd probably sell just as many of the combo as you would have sold of just CDs if that were the only choice. There's been a few studies of the psychology of pricing and marketing on HN that would probably help inform your decision.
1) If you aren't selling digitally, piracy can hurt your album sales (if your music becomes well-known enough).
2) If you are selling digitally, piracy doesn't really hurt your digital sales, as the piracy will generally be from people who wouldn't otherwise sell your music.
3) Making your music available on streaming sites has a measurable but very small positive effect on digital sales. However, it's unclear if they're trying to measure the people that would buy digitally if they weren't streaming, but don't since they can stream. (This my reason for being interested in jango/pandora but not spotify - on jango/pandora, the stream is presented to the consumer but not on-demand, so if the consumer wants to hear it again, they can't just stream it again like on spotify. So they'll still have an incentive to buy.)
4) Streaming might not have a positive impact on physical sales, although this might be because they're assuming that songs are digitally available.
Even if you were able to make $10 per cd, you're still in the hole. Maybe better to chalk the whole recording thing up to marketing expense and use it to give you better leverage in the future.
I know it's common for people to believe that these days the secret is to use the recording as a marketing expense for touring ("where the real money is") but it is a myth. Yes, there exist groups that make good money touring, but even among groups with good music and good recordings, they are the exception more than the rule. The musicians that I know that are paying their way as a musician are invariably also doing things like pit musician work in theatrical productions, or teaching... or a bit of graphic design work for other musicians, while convincing themselves they're earning that money as a musician... - and they're generally not saving for retirement or paying for health insurance.
Also, I think there's this common belief that if musicians give their music away for free, they will get this massive visibility bonus that will translate into significant monetization. I think that's a myth, too. From a consumer's perspective, if a musician is giving away their music for free, it's not valued. And there are a lot of musicians trying to give their music away for free. In that approach, you have a hard enough time getting people to listen in the first place, let alone come to a determination of whether it's good or not.
Anyway, I don't have music career goals. (In my case, it'd be silly, since I have a successful programming freelance career.) What would be great, over time, is if my music habit paid for itself largely from recordings, maybe $10k a year and enough time to release a cd every year. Not in the cards for this release unless I sell out, reprint, and make good money on the digital side. Maybe a few cds from now things will snowball a bit.
Pfff, you can buy that for $50 and the labels know it.
Even if you were able to make $10 per cd, you're still in the hole. Maybe better to chalk the whole recording thing up to marketing expense and use it to give you better leverage in the future.
Something tells me you're not a musician,
It's amazing what kind of culture has sprung up in the selling/delivery sphere. All these companies spring up to "empower" the indie musician and they invest in all sorts of signaling to make sure we know we had better sign up for their services or else we're not taking our career seriously. Examples:
CDBaby: keeps $4 of every cd sale, even though you've already spent $1-$3 per every cd you manufacture. As opposed to just setting up a paypal link or merchant account on your website, and shipping it yourself. 2.9% + $0.30 sounds a lot better than $4. (Shipping costs are additional either way and passed on to the user.) I have trouble imagining at what point I'd want to spend $3.41 per cd to save myself the effort of just sticking a mailing label to a padded envelope and dropping it in my mailbox.
Bandcamp: keeps 10% (by way of keeping every 10th chunk of revenue for itself). It's based around the belief that people will pay more if it's freely available, or will tend to pay more than the "suggested" price. I haven't really dived into their studies but I just cannot believe there isn't a flaw in them. A lot of it seems based off of the logic that if it worked for Radiohead or NIN (with their already built-in audiences) then it should also work for small indie musicians. (And Radiohead and NIN have also since stepped away from the free/pay-what-you-want model.) At any rate, 2.9% + $0.30 sounds better than 10%, since I have to do fulfillment on my end either way.
iTunes/digital media: $0.99 no matter what. $6.93 for a seven-song album, and you can't set your own price. If you have a major label you can apparently set your album price higher but smaller indies don't seem to have access to that privilege. Plus, if your digital album costs $6.93, then you've basically destroyed your options of selling your hard-copy.
And everyone knows the common complaints about spotify and pandora.
At any rate, I'm considering going through a lengthy staged release process, in an effort to measure all sorts of conversion and gather data along the way.
1) Release physical cd only, with no music previews. At this point, the few hundred people on my mailing list are already interested in the cd anyway, so we'll see how far that goes, along with recommendations to friends. Maintain a list of addresses for people who indicate they won't buy until it's released digitally.
2) Marketing music previews of each song and on an album level, through promoted Facebook posts (friends-of-friends) and advertising. The general principle here is to still not ever release the entire full-length tracks, and funnel people to buying the physical cd.
3) Release digitally to services that are not on-demand and can't be downloaded. This means Jango and Pandora. Jango also allows me to buy paid plays and get a bunch of demographic data points to see which tracks are popular with which groups. I can then use that to do more targeted ads over at facebook or maybe through google.
4) When things are really dying down physically, finally release through iTunes and bandcamp (allow full previews) and other sites where you can actually buy the tracks digitally, and see what happens with "discovery"
5) When I'm finally ready to just trash the whole project, release it on Spotify and forget about it to start working on the next cd.