Re:Strikingly, BuildZoom and Bitnami Lead Hottest Y Combinat...
by anateus on Thursday April 25, 2013 @02:47PM
(#5609103)
I've finally put my finger on what's been rubbing me the wrong about these. Although these are mostly factual and non-sensational, they smack of cable-news disease. The sort of preoccupation with a continuous update that has people glued to news and stock tickers.
For some things, a stream of information is useful. But for this sort of stuff I feel it fosters a climate of more short term thinking and concentrating on the wrong things in the community at large.
In a year, releasing and examining these numbers is going to be really valuable. But right now, I feel like it's CNBC for Startups (hint: that's not a good thing).
Re:Strikingly, BuildZoom and Bitnami Lead Hottest Y Combinat...
by ivankirigin on Thursday April 25, 2013 @03:44PM
(#5609417)
Without a mapping of a company's score to its value, these ratings are non-sensical. Considering probably only public data is the input and the actual function isn't open, there is great reason to doubt the rating.
I've made a similar exploration of W13. My scoring is my personal biased judgement. The whole effort isn't to get a US News Top 100 list, but to better understand the rating system itself.
http://blog.kirigin.com/angel
A simple thought experiment: how is this different from a random ranking? How would you know?
Re:Strikingly, BuildZoom and Bitnami Lead Hottest Y Combinat...
by benologist on Thursday April 25, 2013 @04:49PM
(#5609762)
This dataset you're compiling gets less interesting with every new lens we look at it through. You're YC and you're 500S and there must be a way to get data nobody else has access to that really indicates growth and success - like headcount, who's hiring, the 'true' positions they're filling (vp of nobody?).
Re:Strikingly, BuildZoom and Bitnami Lead Hottest Y Combinat...
by tomasien on Thursday April 25, 2013 @09:34PM
(#5611007)
Danielle, have you heard about what Paul Singh is doing with dashboard.io? He basically has made a product out of diagnosing this shit realllllly in depth.
For some things, a stream of information is useful. But for this sort of stuff I feel it fosters a climate of more short term thinking and concentrating on the wrong things in the community at large.
In a year, releasing and examining these numbers is going to be really valuable. But right now, I feel like it's CNBC for Startups (hint: that's not a good thing).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serial_comma
I've made a similar exploration of W13. My scoring is my personal biased judgement. The whole effort isn't to get a US News Top 100 list, but to better understand the rating system itself. http://blog.kirigin.com/angel
A simple thought experiment: how is this different from a random ranking? How would you know?