Empirically, copyright law is not effective. That is to say, copyright is massively violated for non-commercial use.
Enforcing laws which are empirically not obeyed is a bad idea, regardless of the philosophical merits of pro-copyright or anti-copyright arguments.
The most popular P2P protocols will advance to the point where enforcing copyright law means enforcing an absurd policy: if your computer shares copyrighted information even without your knowledge, you're guilty of infringement. The only way to avoid it is not to participate in such advanced P2P swarms (where nodes cache content for delivery to other nodes), since nobody knows the copyright status of a particular hash-addressable piece of content.
Enforcing laws in a way that bans a neutral computer technology (P2P sharing of arbitrary content) is untenable [1], regardless of the ethical, moral, and economic arguments surrounding copyright violation.
I see those arguments often. If you agree that those are not fallacies, I don't understand why you think copyright discussions degenerate into fallacies.
[1] What Colour are your bits? http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/lawpoli/colour/2004061001.php
In all of those cases, people routinely flout the law. It's not just that it's hard to enforce the law; it's that people routinely violate it.
The ineffectiveness of laws is not a logical argument that the goals of those laws are bad. It's an argument either that the laws haven't been tuned properly, or that our enforcement priorities need to be changed --- in the case of copyright, probably in a direction you're not happy with.
Long story short: if you believe that this is a powerful argument against copyright, you forfeit a pretty big chunk of any of your arguments against Wall Street.
Building the kind of surveillance that ensures individuals will observe all terms of service they unknowingly agreed to and can bring felony charges and large statutory damages against them reliably and efficiently does violate all kinds of individual privacy. It also institutionalizes a privileged place for publishers in the legal system, and brings Big Brother into our homes. None or that can be said for financial regulation.
We don't owe banks or publishers or buggy-whip vendors the ability to continue to do business in any particular way. We do owe people their privacy. There is a fundamental difference here you no doubt see, but ignore.
Oh it isn't? So then why is the MPAA and RIAA suing the parents of Timmy's all over the country?
This is possibly the least nuanced way to express this.
Good law isn't good if it isn't understood or if it's misunderstood. It may be either or both if people don't learn its history, purpose, and meaning. That isn't the law's fault; it's the people's. But it doesn't make the people bad, either.
Accusing people of moral failings is not how you start a rational discussion.
Just get involved in one of the many CopyrightX discussion groups that are all based on Harvard Law School's CopyrightX course at http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/people/tfisher/CopyrightX_Homep...
Last night there was a live webcast of a superb rational discussion on copyright involving several experts. Recording will be up soon, and I'll post it when available.
Perhaps also consider following the StackExchange.com community proposal for same at http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/51342/copyrightx?r...
Also, in case anyone here is not yet aware of this, the US Register of Copyrights testified before congress last month about how desperately US copyright legislation needs radical reform: "...if one needs an army of lawyers to understand the basic precepts of the law, then it is time for a new law. " and other very strong statements.
http://www.copyright.gov/regstat/2013/regstat03202013.html
For more details, see http://copyrightx.org/ and https://copyrightactof1790.wordpress.com/about/
This is of course not always the case. Different business models have different economic trade-offs. The ethical and even practical arguments against our strict system of copyrights are many and varied, however, and many of them are quite compelling, including arguments related to artist obscurity vs. profits (see any number of authors and recording artists who point out that the major threat to an artist's livelihood is obscurity, not copyright infringement), imperialistic dominance of international markets (Information Feudalism is a well-researched book by academic experts spanning close to two decades' worth of intensive work), and even the overall benefit to humanity of free reuse of works (see Advancement Through License Simplicity -- http://univacc.net/?page=license_simplicity_1 -- for one such argument).
I don't want to waste too much of my time on an Internet Argument, but I figured I'd throw this stuff out there. Rational and compelling arguments against copyright, or at least against strict copyright with any resemblance to what currently applies, do exist.
that's a static analysis. isn't it more likely that society is changing in various ways, that law naturally lags the changes, and that the result is a mess as society negotiates with itself to find an appropriate adjustment?
In some respects, I think that some copyright denialists behave similarly to those who try to argue that the U.S. has no power to tax incomes because of various technicalities in the ratification of the appropriate constitutional amendment [1]. These people do not hold their to their positions because they are lawyers. They hold to them because they don't want to pay income tax.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_protester_Sixteenth_Amendme...
However, I've never seen cognitive dissonance on such as scale as when people discuss copying and copyright, which makes most discussions useless. Rarely are arguments supported by scholarly evidence or appeals to utilitarianism, and the political statements on the above site are no exception.
Fundamentally, people like copying things, and some forms of copying are restricted by law. So either the law is bad, or they are a bad person. Nobody thinks they are a bad person (an pillar of ego which will never be shaken), and people hate being lectured, so it's the law that breaks, often with the flimsiest of excuses and fallacies ranging from the moral to the theoretical.
- In some cases, copying is beneficial to the copyright holder (usually through advertising, network effects, or market segmentation), ergo, all copying must be beneficial
- Some authors are against copyright, ergo all authors are against copyright
- It's copying is okay if one's motives are pure (end justifies the means)
- If something is easy to do, and preventing it hard, then it must be right (naturalistic fallacy)
- Copying is the natural state of the universe, so it must be right (moralistic fallacy)
- A copyright holder doesn't deserve protection because they're evil ("behaved in a selfish way") stupid ("doesn't understand technology") or stubborn ("won't change business models")
- Copyrights restrict personal freedom, which is a natural and inalienable right of man, even though personal freedoms are always restricted at conflict points to ensure societal harmony ("thou shall not kill")
- Copyrights are based on property rights, but information is not property for reason "x", ergo copyrights are invalid on a technicality. In reality, many laws are enacted because of utilitarian value and need only require group consensus ("always stop at a stop sign; person on right goes first.")
- I paid money in return for "x", therefore I can do whatever I want with "x" (refusal to honor contractual agreements and/or acknowledge exceptions to property rights, which are ubiquitous)
- Copying is good for society because information sharing has no marginal cost (sophomoric application of economics)
- Because some people create without expectation of monetary reward, all people or corporations will still invest in creative works even when the return on investment decreases, or is non-existent
- Some people or corporations could, and thus all should, make money in secondary markets (personal appearances, product endorsements) rather than by selling copyrighted works directly
I would give my right arm for a rational discussion on this topic.