News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cooper Union Ends a Longtime Custom: The Free Degree by roel_v on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @06:50AM (#5600773)
No, it isn't. People across the world make billions (combined) every week doing just that. From Fortune 500 LBO's over leveraging assets to finance real estate portfolio expansion (despite what you read in the papers, there are still many profitable ways of doing this) to bank loans for starting small businesses - it's all about risk management and entrepreneurs having better access to information on profitable opportunities than those with capital (often, banks, but also angel investors). I'm a bit fed up with the 'finance = gambling' fallacy - there is a spectrum of risk profiles, and money can be made in arbitraging this risk, without it being 'gambling' (which is, by definition, risking money on a 100% or near 100% stochastic process. Yes I realize one can argue that poker wouldn't fall under gambling under that definition, but I'm not talking about the margin).
Re:Cooper Union Ends a Longtime Custom: The Free Degree by fusiongyro on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @10:27AM (#5601603)
Do you truly not see a difference between a company leveraging their own assets and a college taking out a loan to play the stock market? Your argument is solid, but simply doesn't apply in this scenario. No college is in a good position to do this. If they were, they'd be a hedge fund instead.
Re:Cooper Union Ends a Longtime Custom: The Free Degree by roel_v on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @04:57PM (#5603916)
The GP said:

"I find the whole idea of borrowing money for investment purposes a little strange. Isn't that basically just gambling?"

which is exactly what my comment addressed. One can debate what investment strategies colleges should use, or how much risk they should take on - probably less than these people did, I don't know and I don't really care either. The GP was throwing around populist blanket 'debt = bad' rhetoric, that's the point I was agitating against.

Re:Cooper Union Ends a Longtime Custom: The Free Degree by fusiongyro on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @06:31PM (#5604415)
Is it so hard to actually look at the username?

I think you're reading "invest" more broadly than I am, and it's not unlikely that I am misusing a technical term, but I certainly do not want to be taken as arguing that debt is intrinsically bad.

Re:Cooper Union Ends a Longtime Custom: The Free Degree by roel_v on Friday April 26, 2013 @09:03AM (#5612640)
Oh I don't look at usernames on purpose - I want to avoid falling into the traps of 'upvote/downvote because I usually like/dislike this guy's answers' and 'I have a mental image of such and of this guy because of previous posts, therefore this post must be correct/wrong too'.

Anyway I did read your post (and I'd argue, I read that reasonably) as saying 'debt = bad'. So if you're not saying that and only meant this particular investment, then I guess we're resolved our differences.