News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by sillysaurus on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @08:32PM (#5598897)
I think we should relax about the idea that most people post inaccurate facts when they're cheering science.

What they're doing is cheering for the idea of science. It's similar to people cheering at a basketball game. They're not basketball players, so most of what they have to say about the topic is going to be wrong. But they're still rooting for you, and this is a good and powerful thing.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by saraid216 on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @08:50PM (#5598962)
> I think we should relax about the idea that most people post inaccurate facts when they're cheering science.

The absolute only good thing about this is that it fights fire with fire: that is, it uses tribalism to fight tribalism.

But that's all it is. Atheistic religiosity is still religiosity, and it's a problem whether or not magical woo is involved. It's the same kind of thing when people think that calling out a fallacy is some kind of argumentative coup d'etat.

Or let's bring this back to software and business. How exactly do you feel when your sales team drastically overpromises your engineering capabilities?

That's how I feel.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by thisrod on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @01:31AM (#5600024)
I agree: fanatics of magic woo are indistinguishable from sufficiently advanced fanatics of technological woo.
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by derleth on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @11:12PM (#5599498)
> Atheistic religiosity is still religiosity

Right. Replacing one form of blind adherence with another is not an improvement.

There are people who have no blind adherence to anything. It is possible, and we need more of them. That isn't something IFLS can help with.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by illuminate on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @11:10PM (#5599489)
"Atheistic religiosity is still religiosity"

A lack of belief in God is not a belief in a God. Your example is ignorant.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by omegant on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @11:49PM (#5599660)
Are you so sure? A person that is conditioned to follow an idea will behave in a conditioned way, I doesn't matter the topic. When you are conditioned to beleave and cheer a "scientific" fact, it is improbable that you'll allow new facts to replace your beleave. You have made a new religion wit a new "Idol".
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by illuminate on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @01:31AM (#5600028)
"When you are conditioned to beleave and cheer a "scientific" fact, it is improbable that you'll allow new facts to replace your beleave. You have made a new religion wit a new "Idol"."

Religion is the belief in an absence of evidence. Science is the whole of objective reality. You don't seem to understand what "science" and "religion" actually mean, but you really don't like persons who don't believe in anything, so you assign bizarrely negative qualifiers for someone who knows things.

No one on earth worships "SCIENCE". It's a tool we use daily, whether you understand why things work or not.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by omegant on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @02:49AM (#5600223)
All that you say is true, but at the same time I don't think you are getting my point. Atthe human level religion is nothing more than emotion, social and group dinamics and conditioning. Then there are the folcloric items, like gods, prayers, popes, books... But as humans we are always susceptible of falling in all the conditioning, emotion and tribalism present in religion. Even in cience, even cientifics are able to take a useful and teorically neutral tool and make it into a "religion". Obviously thanks to the properties of science, a behaviour like that has a limited life span, and will fal under evidence. It doesn't mean it can not happen, and that is not going to create problems. Not just because someone thinks in himself as scientist, is automatically free of the burden of being human. In this matter is interesting, "The structure of scientific revolutions" by Thomas S Kuhn. On how old scientists resist to the new evidences(that eventually replace the old ones), because it will change everything their career is based on.
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by illuminate on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @01:15PM (#5602661)
"Even in cience, even cientifics are able to take a useful and teorically neutral tool and make it into a "religion"."

Outside of parapsychology, cold fusion, and free energy devices, how are you stating that this occurs as a regular practice? I criticize scientists from within the framework of poor evidence, biases, systemic issues, but calling it a "religion" misses the point. Personal biases don't make a religion. Watered down pop-science isn't a religion either.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by malkarouri on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @02:29AM (#5600179)
"Religion is the belief in an absence of evidence." Quoi?

May be you have some particular religion in mind, but many beliefs coexist happily with science.

There is a domain where atheists and many religious people agree on. Which is the domain that is not covered by the particular religion and that is covered by the scientific method (do an experiment, analyse data, get conclusions, rinse, repeat). Choice of medicine is one such area. True, some religions believe in voodoo or other "alternative medicine" but that is not part of the definition of religion.

The critical question is what to do with things we have no physical evidence of, things which we have no data of, are uncertain of. Things that science has not reached a verdict on. Religions typically have loads of these. The existence of god/gods for example. Having such a belief does not contradict the available science at the time, so we can have a scientist who believes in gods carrying on his research cheerfully. Atheists don't believe in gods unless there is physical proof. That also does not contradict doing some scientific research. The issue comes when you mistake "SCIENCE", the tool we use daily, with "science", the set of propositions, heuristics, conjectures and half-baked theories that will always exist at the frontiers of research. That effectively means you choose to place your trust in the set of current researchers and if they get it wrong, you get it wrong.

In short, science is not and has never been the whole of objective reality. This assigns mythical powers to scientists, which some would certainly call a "religion".

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by illuminate on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @10:31AM (#5601624)
"May be you have some particular religion in mind, but many beliefs coexist happily with science. There is a domain where atheists and many religious people agree on."

Totally! Perfectly faithful Christians can be Evolutionary Biologists without falling victim to fundamentalist anti-science idiocy.

"The critical question is what to do with things we have no physical evidence of, things which we have no data of, are uncertain of. Things that science has not reached a verdict on. Religions typically have loads of these. The existence of god/gods for example."

That's the realm of social science, not hard science, seeing as there is always going to be zero physical evidence of "God"/gods.

"In short, science is not and has never been the whole of objective reality. This assigns mythical powers to scientists, which some would certainly call a "religion"."

Again, "Science" is reality. Scientists do not have mythical powers. They are human. They are however the best we have to understand objective reality, through our feeble and failing minds. We do quite a good job, and conflating priests with scientists shows how little persons understand what facts and objective evidence versus subjectivity, belief, and perspective. Priests are "infallible". Science is not. And that is a very good thing.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by saraid216 on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @01:14PM (#5602653)
> Religion is the belief in an absence of evidence. Science is the whole of objective reality.

Both of these claims are 100% false.

Religion does have significant evidence; the problematic part of religion is in its interpretation of that evidence, rather than the evidence itself. This ranges from the metaphysical "X exists, therefore God" to the specific incidences of revival tents and miracle workers. This is evidence. Just because you have a different interpretation does not automatically invalidate theirs.

Science is a fucking method, not some "whole". There is and possibly always will be parts of reality that we do not know. We cannot stand outside reality, by definition, and we will always have non-objective biases coloring our perspective. Pretending to be objective is self-delusion. Trying to be objective is worthy and good, but recognize that you can't be.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by illuminate on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @05:43PM (#5604190)
"Religion does have significant evidence"

Faith does not have empirical evidence. It has philosophical arguments backing it. Religion would cease becoming supernatural otherwise. There's a reason why theology is a soft social science and not a physical science (no matter what the Discovery Institute may tell you.)

"Science is a fucking method, not some "whole". "

Science is both a reflection of our current understanding of reality and the method of how we refine our understanding of it.

"Pretending to be objective is self-delusion" We are not objective creatures there is a vast difference between nature and those who ~practice~ science.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by saraid216 on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @06:26PM (#5604394)
I'm just going to note that you're claiming that theology is a science and say that you're wrong.

Here's a write-up on the problematic nature of the methodology you use:

http://www.wideopenground.com/fundamentalism-and-foundationa...

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by jimzvz on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @02:09AM (#5600130)
> No one on earth worships "SCIENCE".

The problem with ifls and equivalents is that that is actually what they are encouraging. They misrepresent "science" completely.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by illuminate on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @10:32AM (#5601629)
Eh, they're dumb cheerleaders (no offense to smart cheerleaders intended.) They're meme consumers, and looking to be entertained and awed, regardless of the veracity of the source material. I agree, even if I find it unnecessary to portray it as "worship".
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by scotty79 on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @01:09AM (#5599945)
What if you are conditioned to believe and cheer replacing the facts you believed in with new ones that have no evidence against them and many clues for them?

Can reason an scientific method itself be an Idol? And if you do not cherish those things do you think it's better since you are truly not a believer in anything? Even the method that verifiebly gives humanity models of predictive utility that gave us almost all we enjoy today?

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by johnchristopher on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @07:23AM (#5600873)
I think you misunderstood parent. He didn't imply atheism is a religion but that atheists who behaves like religous/zealots are as dangerous as their couter-parts on the religious side.
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by illuminate on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @01:17PM (#5602671)
I can understand the dig on zealotry, but the direct comparisons to "atheism as a religion" remain a pretty good sign that someone doesn't really understand what either term means. It's as unfair to religion as it is to those who lack belief in any God(s).
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by johnchristopher on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @02:45PM (#5603211)
I disagree.

I think the comparison is valid. Some hardline atheists can be as vindicative, presumptuous and arrogant as religious people and that attitude is a problem (

Parent isn't implying atheism is a religion by the layman definition (sthg along the lines of'a belief in sthg unprovable') but that its proponents behave like they were a part of sthg that looks like a religion.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by illuminate on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @05:36PM (#5604145)
"Some hardline atheists can be as vindicative, presumptuous and arrogant as religious people and that attitude is a problem"

Atheists can be assholes? Why does that even need to be said? Atheists are people and run the same set of qualities that any human can possess.

"Parent isn't implying atheism is a religion by the layman definition (sthg along the lines of'a belief in sthg unprovable') but that its proponents behave like they were a part of sthg that looks like a religion."

Religion or lack thereof has nothing to do with being an asshole. Software "zealots" promote their fanatical opinions but they don't worship "software".

It's a crappy analogy when "asshole" would suffice.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by saraid216 on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @06:39PM (#5604443)
> Software "zealots" promote their fanatical opinions but they don't worship "software".

Indeed. But software zealots exhibit the same behavioral properties as normal zealots. "Normal zealots" is understood to be "religious zealots", because those behavioral properties are derived primarily from analyses of religious behavior.

Worship, at the end of the day, has absolutely nothing to do with anything.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by saraid216 on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @03:48PM (#5603542)
FYI, I wrote a thing up there ^ about how you don't understand what either term means.
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by illuminate on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @05:45PM (#5604211)
And your response indicates that you seem to not understand what the burden for "evidence" for faith is.
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by jacoblyles on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @08:44PM (#5598942)
>this is a good and powerful thing.

... until they have a gross misunderstanding of an issue relevant to public policy and spread that misunderstanding to others.

There is no "good ignorance".

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by iamdave on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @08:51PM (#5598966)
>There is no "good ignorance".

This can't be stated enough; (the following is anecdotal) the amount of blatantly incorrect information being spread through the use of what I dub 'feel good infographics' across the internet is astonishing. The viewer looks at something, feels good about what they've read and then shares it because it passed their own personal sentiment analysis.

It's kind of frightening because it sets the stage for all sorts of astroturfing and conditioning to spread; if anything we should look at the Boston Bomber/Reddit incident as evidence of this feel good propaganda. People were so eager to attach to the notion that they had 'caught the bastard' only for the truth to come out later that they had completely fingered the wrong guy.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by janardanyri on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @08:54PM (#5598976)
We're all ignorant of the vast majority of facts relevant to almost anything. Comprehension is expensive and scarce. That being the case, simple extensions of good faith count for a lot.
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by jckt on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @09:05PM (#5599020)
Ignorance is fine -- it is an unfortunate fact that nobody can learn it all. But to think that one is "engaging" in science -- I suppose most fans of the Page think they're somehow engaging in it (anecdotal) -- is, well, wrong.

As much as I'd like it to be true, looking at a bunch of .gifs about quantum mechanics and astrophysics plastered with white majuscules does little for one's understanding of science. In other words, IFLS is to the scientific community as r/atheism is to the religious-sceptics community (not the best analogy...).

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by illuminate on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @10:51AM (#5601764)
The problem here is willful ignorance, what a person does when confronted by fact. There's probably a lot of antivaxers new-age woo believers and homeopaths who enjoy the fashionable "quantum" quips but have zero interest in doing anything but republishing the images. They ape the language, but don't understand the mindset.
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by potatolicious on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @09:05PM (#5599016)
These aren't simple extensions of good faith though - that would be more like wearing a pin "I believe in science!", which is a-ok.

The problem arises when people share untrue information out of the notion that they're spreading science. Comprehension is indeed expensive and scarce, which means recognizing the borders of your own knowledge and the start of your own ignorance is extremely important. Pseudoscientific drivel has no place anywhere.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by vacri on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @09:35PM (#5599127)
It reminds me of the criticisms of Mythbusters. They do bad science a lot of the time, with shoddy understandings of underlying mechanisms. It's fair to criticise them as bad science for this. But on the other hand, they very much promote the idea of "think of something, suggest what might happen if you do it, then do it and see what you find (, and then publish it)". So while they may not do good science themselves, they do promote the fundamental ideals of science, and are open to having their suggestions found wrong.

Whereas the facebook page does nothing like this at all - it's just funny pictures with a theme. It doesn't encourage any way of thinking or promote figuring out the world.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by TeMPOraL on Wednesday April 24, 2013 @03:40AM (#5600330)
Your point was very nicely expressed in this xkcd: http://xkcd.com/397/.
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by qu4z-2 on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @09:22PM (#5599083)
I agree. It seems like supporting science through ignorance is missing the point.
Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by illuminate on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @11:08PM (#5599474)
"I think we should relax about the idea that most people post inaccurate facts when they're cheering science. What they're doing is cheering for the idea of science."

This is how What the Bleep, Dr. Oz, and all manner of pseudoscience subverts actual science.

Fairweather friends like that make it more difficult because they're repeating a meme or sort of cargo cult understanding of how reality works.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by statictype on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @09:12PM (#5599048)
I think we should relax about the idea that most people post inaccurate facts when they're cheering science.

Seems to me that a lot of the point of 'cheering science' is lost when you're posting inaccurate facts.

Can you even call it science any more?

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by aaron695 on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @08:49PM (#5598956)
I think the problem is within the supposed science field sudo science is getting more traction.

People who have done science degrees are coming out and still believing in forms of magic like organic, chiropractics, chemical free, anthropomorphizing animals etc.

It's a fine line, should we appease the masses and try and get more scientists or try and at least get the supposed scientists practising and believing in actual science.

Re:Facebook’s “I F*cking Love Science” does not love artists by drakaal on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @09:59PM (#5599207)
Oh, do the cheerleader mine the data of the audience, and use it to create spam?

If the cheerleaders were sleeping with the fans and spreading venereal disease your analogy would be nearly perfect.