News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Glowing Plants: Natural Lighting with no Electricity or CO2 by jacquesm on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @02:00PM (#5596808)
This is one along the lines of 'wouldn't it be nice if'. Yes, it would be. You can get an idea of how effective this will be if you paint a good sized chunk of wall with http://glonation.com/ glow in the dark paint. The paint will likely have a much higher density than any plant based set-up will be.

This may be useful as emergency lighting in a jungle but I highly doubt that we'll be replacing LEDs, fluorescent or even incandescents with this technique.

Apologies for being terribly pessimistic but even if the project gets funded and the goal is successfully achieved I can't see the utility.

Has there been any work done on an estimate of efficiency, some sort of modelling about what reasonable expectations are with respect to output?

It's a super presentation complete with HN voting ring, congratulations on successfully gaming the system. If they are just as good at the execution then this can't fail.

edit: after reading the risks and challenges section:

"We hope to have a plant which you can visibly see in the dark (like glow in the dark paint) but don't expect to replace your light bulbs with version 1.0."

So that was pretty much spot on. Then:

"The more money we raise, the more we can refine our designs and the stronger the effect we will get so please tell all your friends about the project."

That's not very honest, there is no way there is a direct relationship between the money they raise and the effect produced, these things typically follow a saturation curve with the upper limit being pretty hard and rather low compared to other ways of generating light.

Re:Glowing Plants: Natural Lighting with no Electricity or CO2 by lucasvo on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @02:05PM (#5596850)
I think you don't get the humour behind it. They're making glowing plants because, come on, who doesn't like to have a glowing plant?!

I know some of the guys behind it. And making growing plants is only a way to show off, what they're working on that is much bigger. Creating custom dna sequences is a pretty tough challenge.

Re:Glowing Plants: Natural Lighting with no Electricity or CO2 by jacquesm on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @02:15PM (#5596920)
> I think you don't get the humour behind it.

Sorry, no. When asking for people to back a project with cash to a maximum of $10K my sense of humour rapidly diminishes.

I do technical due diligence for a living and this raises a ton of red flags. So many promises made for a project that amounts to basic research is a bit much.

> Creating custom dna sequences is a pretty tough challenge.

My point exactly.

Re:Glowing Plants: Natural Lighting with no Electricity or CO2 by technotony on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @02:06PM (#5596860)
There is an assessment of the energy efficiency here: http://2010.igem.org/Team:Cambridge/Tools/Lighting
Re:Glowing Plants: Natural Lighting with no Electricity or CO2 by ars on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @03:02PM (#5597236)
In this article they assume plants can use about 3% to 6% of the light, but actually they can use about 0.1% - 0.2%. So instead of 60 W/m^2 you have 1 W/m^2.

Meaning you need to dedicate 1% of the tree's energy to light, not 0.02%.

They also use a 210 lumen bulb to compare with - but 210 lumens is very very dim. Assuming each tree is planted 20 meters apart, each tree needs to illuminate 400 m^2 of area, which would be 0.5 lux.

For comparison that's about as much light as the full moon provides.

For normal street lighting you want about 18 lux, meaning you actually need a 7000 lumen bulb.

So, now we need 35% of the trees energy delivered as light. But of course half of the light will be emitted upward, so we really need 70% of the trees energy.

Good luck with that.

And we haven't even touched on the fact that the light is not created on the surface of the plant, but rather throughout the tissue, so a lot of it will be lost internally.

Re:Glowing Plants: Natural Lighting with no Electricity or CO2 by jacquesm on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @02:13PM (#5596905)
It seems to me that you're entirely missing the fall-off over time but are just looking at the optimum case right after illumination or am I missing something?

The effective output level would have to be sized in such a way that even at the maximum time from the last illumination you're still above some minimum acceptable level which would mean that you'd have to be putting out a much larger amount of light than required early on.

Here is a similar (concept as far as I know) based on a hollow wall with a bacterial soup:

http://www.design.philips.com/philips/sites/philipsdesign/ab...