Re:Glowing Plants: Natural Lighting with no Electricity or CO2
by ars on Tuesday April 23, 2013 @03:02PM
(#5597236)
In this article they assume plants can use about 3% to 6% of the light, but actually they can use about 0.1% - 0.2%. So instead of 60 W/m^2 you have 1 W/m^2.
Meaning you need to dedicate 1% of the tree's energy to light, not 0.02%.
They also use a 210 lumen bulb to compare with - but 210 lumens is very very dim. Assuming each tree is planted 20 meters apart, each tree needs to illuminate 400 m^2 of area, which would be 0.5 lux.
For comparison that's about as much light as the full moon provides.
For normal street lighting you want about 18 lux, meaning you actually need a 7000 lumen bulb.
So, now we need 35% of the trees energy delivered as light. But of course half of the light will be emitted upward, so we really need 70% of the trees energy.
Good luck with that.
And we haven't even touched on the fact that the light is not created on the surface of the plant, but rather throughout the tissue, so a lot of it will be lost internally.
Meaning you need to dedicate 1% of the tree's energy to light, not 0.02%.
They also use a 210 lumen bulb to compare with - but 210 lumens is very very dim. Assuming each tree is planted 20 meters apart, each tree needs to illuminate 400 m^2 of area, which would be 0.5 lux.
For comparison that's about as much light as the full moon provides.
For normal street lighting you want about 18 lux, meaning you actually need a 7000 lumen bulb.
So, now we need 35% of the trees energy delivered as light. But of course half of the light will be emitted upward, so we really need 70% of the trees energy.
Good luck with that.
And we haven't even touched on the fact that the light is not created on the surface of the plant, but rather throughout the tissue, so a lot of it will be lost internally.