News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask PG: Has HN ever received a DMCA Takedown Notice? by late2part on Saturday April 20, 2013 @06:09PM (#5583019)
False.

The DMCA act is readable; read it.

Effectively, all it does is offer safe harbor for an ISP, with ISP loosely defined.

Congress attempts to offers a pseudo mediation framework to limit/remove liability from the ISP for the acts of its users.

If the ISP complies with the DMCA, the ISP is immune from liability for copyright infringement.

Here's the part the ignorant ignore:

If the target of a DMCA notice sends a COUNTER-NOTICE, the ISP will/must/should put their stuff , else the ISP can be liable for taking it down without case.

Read the DMCA, it's fairly short as these things go.

http://www.copyright.gov/legislation/dmca.pdf

Disclosure: I spent $80k on attorneys defending against a nuisance lawsuit and used the DMCA as a shield.

Re:Ask PG: Has HN ever received a DMCA Takedown Notice? by rdp on Saturday April 20, 2013 @10:19PM (#5583616)
Actually, if the target of a DMCA notice files a counter-notice, the ISP has to reinstate the content within 10 days unless the person/entity filing the DMCA notice alerts the ISP that an injunction has been filed within a specified period of time. See 17 USC § 512(g)(2)(A)-(C).