Re:How You Can Help Save Upcoming.org, Posterous, and More
by evanmoran on Saturday April 20, 2013 @06:33PM
(#5583085)
"While companies like Yahoo work to destroy as much human history as possible, Archive Team is the only group actively trying to save it."
What kind of article is this? It is cool they are trying to save some of our virtual history, but these kind of statements aren't helpful. Clearly Yahoo's main intension isn't destruction.
Re:How You Can Help Save Upcoming.org, Posterous, and More
by lubujackson on Saturday April 20, 2013 @08:36PM
(#5583368)
Destruction is exactly what "sunsetting" is all about. Or to be more accurate, its like saying you're going to stop watering your fern. No, you're not destroying the fern you're just... not keeping it alive anymore.
The problem with people using online services is that their data is stored there and can't be recovered ever again. You can say the data is pointless crud or everyone should know better, but I don't see how you can argue that the data isn't being lost against some people's wishes.
Re:How You Can Help Save Upcoming.org, Posterous, and More
by lhl on Sunday April 21, 2013 @01:44AM
(#5584005)
I agree that Yahoo's intent isn't the destruction of historical data, and that the phrasing is hyperbolic, but the end result is more accurate than not.
Internet companies and service providers like Yahoo have collected huge amounts of human communications, intent, and intellectual output ("UGC") that continues to have historical significance even if the commercial interest is no longer there.
Maybe these companies don't make any implicit promises for archiving this data, but as a society, we're a lot poorer for its wholesale destruction and we should be thinking a lot more about the social contract/implications...
Re:How You Can Help Save Upcoming.org, Posterous, and More
by brk on Saturday April 20, 2013 @09:55PM
(#5583548)
I had never heard of Upcoming.org until a day ago. I had heard of Posterous, but never really used it.
Why do these sites need to be saved? It appears that they have been shutdown due to lack of widespread traction or apparent value.
Sure, they are someone's "baby", and it's natural for some people to take this personal. But is there really truly anything of value in saving these sites?
Re:How You Can Help Save Upcoming.org, Posterous, and More
by gcr on Saturday April 20, 2013 @05:43PM
(#5582921)
I don't understand. If this virtual machine:
- Downloads dying web pages, and
- Uploads them to the Wayback Machine at the Internet Archive,
That means I'm not saving the Internet Archive any bandwidth at all, and this is no more efficient than them just downloading the site themselves.
The virtual machine itself is 174MB. This times however many volunteers means distributing the virtual machine is probably more stressful than the actual archiving operation.
Re:How You Can Help Save Upcoming.org, Posterous, and More
by mark_olson on Saturday April 20, 2013 @05:55PM
(#5582962)
Yahoo and others either rate limit or do temporary IP bans if you access too many pages too quickly. Distributing the tools through a VM distributes the workload in a pretty easy-to-setup way.
Re:How You Can Help Save Upcoming.org, Posterous, and More
by nwh on Saturday April 20, 2013 @08:01PM
(#5583293)
It does actually save quite a lot of bandwidth in the process. The giles are gzipped as they are uploaded to the Archive Teams server, so your virtual machine will do a lot more download than it does upload.
What kind of article is this? It is cool they are trying to save some of our virtual history, but these kind of statements aren't helpful. Clearly Yahoo's main intension isn't destruction.
The problem with people using online services is that their data is stored there and can't be recovered ever again. You can say the data is pointless crud or everyone should know better, but I don't see how you can argue that the data isn't being lost against some people's wishes.
Internet companies and service providers like Yahoo have collected huge amounts of human communications, intent, and intellectual output ("UGC") that continues to have historical significance even if the commercial interest is no longer there.
Maybe these companies don't make any implicit promises for archiving this data, but as a society, we're a lot poorer for its wholesale destruction and we should be thinking a lot more about the social contract/implications...
Why do these sites need to be saved? It appears that they have been shutdown due to lack of widespread traction or apparent value.
Sure, they are someone's "baby", and it's natural for some people to take this personal. But is there really truly anything of value in saving these sites?
- Downloads dying web pages, and
- Uploads them to the Wayback Machine at the Internet Archive,
That means I'm not saving the Internet Archive any bandwidth at all, and this is no more efficient than them just downloading the site themselves.
The virtual machine itself is 174MB. This times however many volunteers means distributing the virtual machine is probably more stressful than the actual archiving operation.
If you have proper boxen, you don't need the VM. Here's how to get it up and running on a clean Ubuntu setup for example:
With a deadline looming so soon, a more aggressive effort is called for.