I enabled it on my old Mac--because I am a huge freaking nerd. I never once needed it, but it made me happy. However, I think it's definitely a bad default. Make it easy to enable, and the people who need it will enable it. But we should design and build for the normal case first.
And BTW, I'm a big fan of printing output of init scripts to console, provided that it's nice and concise (as it used to be in most distros few years ago) because it greatly aids debugging when (not if) stuff breaks. It's one of the reasons I left Windows, actually.