News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What-aboutery by te_platt on Saturday April 11, 2009 @05:50PM (#557869)
I disagree with the author. Bringing up "what about x" has many valid uses. For example:

"Look at my perpetual motion machine!" "What about the cable plugged into the outlet?" "Don't change the subject!"

"You are a murderer because you killed Mr. Jones." "What about the fact that Mr. Jones broke into my house and was trying to rape my wife?" "Two wrongs don't make a right!"

Certainly it can be abused but very often the "what about x" argument can be a valid way of introducing new and relevant information.

Re:What-aboutery by phugoid on Saturday April 11, 2009 @06:22PM (#557893)
Not all all. In both cases, your "what about" stayed on topic.
Re:What-aboutery by te_platt on Saturday April 11, 2009 @07:43PM (#557954)
That was exactly the point I was trying to make. "What about" arguments can be valid.
Re:What-aboutery by potatolicious on Saturday April 11, 2009 @09:28PM (#558036)
Splitting hairs, he was specifically referring to the deflection-style "what about" argument, as if the sins of others justifies one's own.
Re:What-aboutery by ecommercematt on Sunday April 12, 2009 @01:39AM (#558207)
How does one differentiate "deflection-style 'what about' arguments" from valid "what about" arguments free from bias?
Re:What-aboutery by berntb on Sunday April 12, 2009 @02:36AM (#558235)
If that was a serious question and not a troll, check philosophy courses; should be some online. They have a bit of history in that discipline of logic and analyzing arguments...
Re:What-aboutery by ecommercematt on Sunday April 12, 2009 @03:07PM (#558763)
I wasn't trolling. I was just pointing out that it seems like a subjective distinction as a practical matter and asking if there was a way to make it less subjective in the context of online comments, argument rebuttals, etc.