Not all all. In both cases, your "what about" stayed on topic.
That was exactly the point I was trying to make. "What about" arguments can be valid.
Re:What-aboutery
by potatolicious on Saturday April 11, 2009 @09:28PM
(#558036)
Splitting hairs, he was specifically referring to the deflection-style "what about" argument, as if the sins of others justifies one's own.
Re:What-aboutery
by ecommercematt on Sunday April 12, 2009 @01:39AM
(#558207)
How does one differentiate "deflection-style 'what about' arguments" from valid "what about" arguments free from bias?
If that was a serious question and not a troll, check philosophy courses; should be some online. They have a bit of history in that discipline of logic and analyzing arguments...
Re:What-aboutery
by ecommercematt on Sunday April 12, 2009 @03:07PM
(#558763)
I wasn't trolling. I was just pointing out that it seems like a subjective distinction as a practical matter and asking if there was a way to make it less subjective in the context of online comments, argument rebuttals, etc.
"Look at my perpetual motion machine!" "What about the cable plugged into the outlet?" "Don't change the subject!"
"You are a murderer because you killed Mr. Jones." "What about the fact that Mr. Jones broke into my house and was trying to rape my wife?" "Two wrongs don't make a right!"
Certainly it can be abused but very often the "what about x" argument can be a valid way of introducing new and relevant information.