News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by mpyne on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:31AM (#5577163)
I'm honestly surprised to see this opinion on HN, the defender of the free Internet.

Should the family also take legal action against the ISPs of the Reddit users involved, simply for "facilitating" this garbage?

Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by onemorepassword on Friday April 19, 2013 @12:24PM (#5577422)
I'm not surprised at all.

I see a clear trend, on HN and elsewhere, of technologically clued-in people who simply do not share what we wrongfully assumed were common values amongst techies.

This includes the notion that services should be punished for things their users do, something that we used to attribute to people who simply didn't understand what something like Reddit is, or how the internet works.

I would suggest that assumption was based on underestimating how much of those values were not just informed by technological insight but Western cultural values, but I'm probably on thin ice there.

Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by sirobviouspoint on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:46AM (#5577234)
I'd file a suit against the people who libelous comments, such as asserting that he factually was the bomber, and ask reddit to disclose such information about the posters as they possess as part of disclosure.

The internet does not give you the right to spread untrue statements about people which you were negligent in discovering the truth of before repeating - such as that they committed a specific act of terrorism.

Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by mpyne on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:53AM (#5577268)
> and ask reddit to disclose such information about the posters as they possess as part of disclosure.

Too bad Reddit will surely be too busy not collecting such information just in case the evil government happens to ask for it, eh? You can never be too cautious about that government, you know.

Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by yew on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:56AM (#5577286)
Funny how this stops being true as soon as it involves people you don't like. (Not accusing you personally. Just tired of "it's okay if they're politicians on the other side!")
Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by k-mcgrady on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:37AM (#5577189)
It's nothing to do with the free internet. Accusing someone of murder with absolutely no proof could be considered libel.

Edi: I wasn't accusing Reddit of libel. It's just a platform. The individuals who posted the comments would be the ones committing libel.

Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by onemorepassword on Friday April 19, 2013 @12:05PM (#5577329)
Except that accusation has not been made by the entity "Reddit" but by individual people.

Making that distinction may be hard for fossilized media and politicians, but it should come natural to anybody on HN.

Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by mpyne on Friday April 19, 2013 @11:54AM (#5577277)
It might be libel in the U.K., but the standard for such is a bit higher in the U.S. Which is probably a good thing, on the whole, as otherwise we'd have had to destroy the Internet ten years ago based on its usage as a libel-launching platform.
Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by k-mcgrady on Friday April 19, 2013 @12:01PM (#5577310)
Is releasing photos of someone and accusing them of murder really not considered libel in the US? It seems like quite an extreme case of libel to me (although IANAL).
Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by mpyne on Friday April 19, 2013 @12:15PM (#5577370)
Freedom of speech is kind of a big thing around here, yes.

You have to remember the context: Some nearly anonymous asshole points a finger and says that so-and-so is the bomber, with no real concrete evidence. It's practically a farce at that stage, only idiots could fall for that.

Unfortunately for Sunil, there are a lot of idiots online (and in the media, apparently).

On the other hand, entities like the NY Post should have known better. They presumably pay "journalists" to fact-check (so there's a higher standard of quality expected), and they understand that it imparts a higher expectation on what they do print, which means it's more likely that people would believe such an accusation.

So Sunil might even have a case against professional outfits like these, especially since he wasn't previously a public figure. But against random people from the Internet there's not really any hope of a libel charge sticking.

Maybe some states would have "cyber-bullying" legislation that would apply though (assuming it's not struck down as unconstitutional).

Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by 286c8cb04bda on Friday April 19, 2013 @12:17PM (#5577387)
> Is releasing photos of someone and accusing them of murder really not considered libel in the US?

It depends on the particulars of the accusation, but probably not.

Saying "I think you killed her" is a statement of opinion. If that is an opinion the speaker legitimately holds, then it would probably not be considered libel. Generally libel needs to be both false and malicious.

Proving malice is hard, so libel/slander is usually a difficult case to win. That's one of the things that makes it different than other venues, where intent (and sometimes even falsity) are not required.

Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by johnward on Friday April 19, 2013 @12:05PM (#5577330)
Giving someone a medium for free speech is NOT the same as committing the act of libel. If they did want to sue it should be against the OP/commentors, not the site.
Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by kaze on Friday April 19, 2013 @01:02PM (#5577604)
I was wrong in my opinion. If legal reports show Tripathi wasn't involved, the family should take legal action against the Reddit users who participated in this garbage, AND Reddit itself. The former for libel, and the latter for having failed to apply effective moderation. Freedom of speech is very important, but this was a public lynching. Granted that it is difficult for a website to moderate each and every thing, but an honest effort should be made. This can be achieved by steps such as having traffic based or user flagging based triggers leading to an informed policy driven review. And the policy can definitely be good enough to help recognize damaging accusations of this kind.

Any organisation, be a website, news organization, or Government, should be punished if it tolerates a Kangaroo court culture. Else we risk exposing just about any innocent person (us and our families included) to permanent damage.

Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by mpyne on Friday April 19, 2013 @01:20PM (#5577701)
So by your same logic then we should expect large file hosts such as Dropbox and MegaUpload to take active moderation measures to ensure that they are not used as springboards for minor crimes... such as copyright infringement?
Re:Reddit, Boston and the missing student by tzs on Friday April 19, 2013 @01:34PM (#5577779)
The law is capable of taking into account both intent and predictability of outcomes. Dropbox does not intend their site to be used for copyright infringement, whereas MegaUpload encouraged it.