News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by jbooth on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @04:45PM (#5560770)
It's not just 'more time to kick the can', which still implies that not trimming debt immediately is irresponsible.

If you trim debt by a little and hurt GDP growth by a little, you wind up with the same ratio you had before. If you trim debt in a way that really hurts GDP, you'll likely increase the debt:GDP ratio.

The original paper implied that we'd wind up in a spiral of shrinking GDP, increasing that ratio, shrinking the GDP more, and so on. But it turns out it was complete bullshit.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by crusso on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @05:01PM (#5560868)
which still implies that not trimming debt immediately is irresponsible

I don't get it. I was in sync with the Left when they decried George W. Bush's no-veto policy and ballooning of the debt. Now that "their guy" is in the WhiteHouse, they no longer agree that it's irresponsible to set the deficit meter on 11 and walk away like we have been.

Can't we all agree that this guy was totally correct? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1kuTG19Cu_Q

I guess I wouldn't be so against some amount of debt if it looked like we had it under control. It's funny that we're dissecting the results of a study on what 90% debt:GDP would do. Well that was back in 2010, we've blown way past 90%. We're at 107% as of 2012 and climbing.

It's not just about the debt's exact impact at a certain percentage. If it were just that, we could debate it and fine tune it. It's about our Government's complete inability to get it under control.

Maybe 90% Debt:GDP won't hurt too badly, but sooner or later as it rises, it will crater even our economy.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by bencpeters on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @05:30PM (#5561042)
This is a common argument, but it's fundamentally flawed. We're in a very different economic regime right now than we were under GWB, and that makes all the difference.

I think you'd be hard pressed to find anyone on the left who understands the issues who is seriously arguing that deficits are never a problem, or never have to be dealt with. What a lot of us ARE arguing is that as long as we have an aggregate demand shortfall (everyone in the economy trying to save at once), paying attention to the debt is exactly the wrong thing to do, since the government is the only actor in the economy that has the freedom to act counter-cyclically and make up for the shortfall in private sector demand. The ultimate goal is to start a virtuous cycle of spending that gets us back toward full employment (and increases GDP). Then and only then does it make sense for the government to try to reduce debt through cuts.

There's decent evidence (see Delong & Summers 2012: http://delong.typepad.com/20120320-conference-draft-final-ca...) that trying to reduce debt through cuts in an economy like we have right now is counter-productive even on it's own terms (reducing the debt-gdb ratio) because any cuts you make further reduce aggregate demand and thus reduce the GDB side of that ratio even further.

It's not a democrat in the white house vs. republican in the white house thing that is causing people who were complaining about deficits under GWB to advocate against cutting short term spending now. It's all about the underlying economic conditions.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by crusso on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @05:41PM (#5561098)
The ultimate goal is to start a virtuous cycle of spending

And where is that evidence? Included in that evidence, I'd like to see a model that predicted what actually DID happen when we tried the "stimulus" that Obama's economic advisers predicted would lower unemployment to <6% or better.

If you don't have a model that predicts things before they happened consistently, then it isn't Science. It's just guessing.

If we're going to guess, then we should fall back on models that we do understand and have a lot of data for, like how businesses and households manage debt. Common sense should be trumping guessing based upon esoteric economic models that haven't yet yielded reproducible results.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by bencpeters on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @06:51PM (#5561468)
I agree with you that it's necessary to look at evidence. But the evidence actually pretty overwhelmingly supports the general Keynesian framework for a financial crisis like this. Look at the data on austerity measures/spending vs. growth worldwide in this crisis (http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/02/18/austerity-and-gr...), or any data on similar circumstances (the US "double-dip" in 1937 during the Great Depression, before WWII deficit spending brought us out of it, Japan in the 90s, etc.). The real question is, where is there ANY evidence/what is the model for the opposing view? Does it in any way match up with what really happened over the past 4 years? (because the AD-deficit/Keynesian view does)

Responding to the complaint about Obama's economic advisors being wrong is easy - they were wildly optimistic. However, plenty of economists including Paul Krugman were saying this at the time (http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/09/opinion/09krugman.html?par... - note the date Jan 9, 2009, before Obama was even sworn in). The math is pretty basic - according to the aggregate demand view of the crisis you have a combined housing/financial shock that totaled at least 6% of GDB. The stimulus was MAYBE 1.5% of GDB, and that's being generous with assuming that high end tax cuts are just as effective as outright spending money (I would argue that they are not, since in a saver's economy, much of that money is just saved straight away). The Obama stimulus package was 4+ times too small to address the magnitude of the problem by this model; no one who has this view of the world is surprised that unemployment is still high (the only surprise was that Obama's advisors had such a rosy-eyed, not data-driven view of the world. They deserve a LOT of criticism for that).

Your "fall back on models that we do understand and have a lot of data for, like how businesses and households manage debt" is completely at odds with reality for two reasons. One is that it doesn't really imply what you say it does; most rational, not capitally constrained businesses/households (and the US is emphatically not capital constrained - bond yields are as low as they've ever been) invest when they have absurdly low interest rates - you're basically getting free money from the market, it's not a rational response to cut back in a situation like that. The second, and arguably more important, argument, however, is that the government occupies a fairly special position in the economy, since it alone among economic actors will never run out of money. Therefore, the government has the unique ability to act in a counter cyclical manner - it can counteract the collective saving of businesses/households to stimulate demand during recessions, and pull back when the private sector is roaring. (You give me 5% unemployment and 4-5%/yr GDP growth and I will be all for govt deficit reduction)

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by andrewflnr on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @09:45PM (#5562141)

  The government... will never run out of money.
Um, isn't that because it collapses first? Or at least prints money and causes huge inflation? We'd like to avoid that.
Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by stevenwei on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @12:20AM (#5562667)
QE1 ran from Nov 25, 2008 to Mar 31, 2010. QE2 ran from Nov 30, 2010 to June 30, 2011. QE3 started Sep 13, 2012 and hasn't ended yet.

(Honest question here) I'm curious when we should expect to see the huge inflation created by the QE program, and why we haven't seen it yet if it began nearly 5 years ago...

Am I missing something?

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by nl on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @02:53AM (#5563086)
Hasn't the US government been printing vast amount of money over the last 3-4 years, with little appreciable increase in inflation?

Keyesians argue that money supply doesn't cause inflation on its own. Probably worth looking into that, since the predictions it provides seems to match reality pretty closely..

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by brg on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @10:00PM (#5568540)
One reason for the current benign inflation may be that there is no alternative currency with which to trade for US derived goods. Neither the rmb, euro, ruble nor even Canadian dollar are valid mediums of exchange within the US.

Meanwhile hyper-inflation in Russia in the 90's used the dollar as a stable currency with which rubles were exchanged for dollars. Hyper-inflation in Poland, Yugoslavia, and Bulgaria occurred in part due to easily exchange and convertibility of the Deutschmark.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by pfraze on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @06:56PM (#5561486)
Most economics isn't science- we lack the data. That doesn't mean that the best model is derived from families or businesses; the characteristics and objectives deviate too dramatically to support that claim.

The government is a facilitator of commerce. It's not built to make a profit. It doesn't have the trust circle of a family. It is fundamentally political by mandate and by nature. It couldn't be less common!

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by anigbrowl on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @07:35PM (#5561633)
I don't get it. I was in sync with the Left when they decried George W. Bush's no-veto policy and ballooning of the debt. Now that "their guy" is in the WhiteHouse, they no longer agree that it's irresponsible to set the deficit meter on 11 and walk away like we have been.

Let me offer a crude analogy:

Before: 'Don't press down so hard on the accelerator (debt finance), or you will drive this car (economy) into the ditch (recession).'

(crash)

After: 'You need to push down on the accelerator to get out of the ditch and back onto the road.'

That's Keynesianism in a nutshell. If/when the economy is again growing at a decent clip, then government spending should be reduced (as a % of GDP and revenue, not necessarily in absolute terms) and debt service increased. Of course, that doesn't always happen.

Maybe 90% Debt:GDP won't hurt too badly, but sooner or later as it rises, it will crater even our economy.

But the reality is taht the debt probably won't rise that much as time goes on, because it'll be offset by increased revenues from increased growth. The 2010 R-R paper argued (incorrectly) that such growth would never happen due to the high debt load.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by tdg on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @05:26PM (#5561011)
A lot of Keynesian economists are arguing that now is not the time for austerity. The government's current mission should be to lower employment even if it means higher deficits (and debt) _for now_. Once we are out of this slump, the argument is that most of the deficit will take care of itself (since some of the deficit is lower tax revenue because of unemployment + cost of automatic stabilizers such as unemployment benefits). We still need to fix the rest of the deficit/debt problem after the crisis, though.

The second important argument is that (again, right now), this emphasis on austerity is actively making things worse.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by crusso on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @05:36PM (#5561065)
government's current mission should be to lower employment

Well since we've exploded our debt to supposedly lower unemployment and the meter has barely moved, maybe we're doing it wrong? We've indulged the Keynesians quite enough over the last $6+ TRILLION dollars, tyvm.

I see people in this thread demanding evidence that more debt is bad for the country. Well where the hell is the evidence that shows that staggering debt is good for the country?

Maybe we should fall back on common sense "household" or "business" models until that evidence appears, huh?

this emphasis on austerity is actively making things worse.

What austerity? I've heard some talking about it, but we're not practicing it anywhere. Don't you dare use the word "sequester", because that was a joke.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by scott_s on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @05:59PM (#5561218)
The sequester is not a joke. A friend of mine knows postdocs whose NIH funded projects were cut 20%, immediately, when the sequester went into effect. Another friend of mine will be in next class to start with the FBI, but they've been put off until 2014. To be clear, the FBI is not training new agents right now.

The sequester is real, but it may take more time for the effects to reverberate throughout the country.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by crusso on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @06:09PM (#5561266)
The sequestration has only been painful because the Administration wants to make an example of any efforts to reduce the size of the government. Funny how NIH projects could have a 20% cut when the $44 Billion reduction this year as a result of sequestration is 1% of the actual budget. Where did that other 19% come from? Further, the sequestration only reduced the increase on the baseline budget. We're still going to be spending more this year than we did last year.

http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2013/02/27/sequest...

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by scott_s on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @12:27AM (#5562689)
Funny how NIH projects could have a 20% cut when the $44 Billion reduction this year as a result of sequestration is 1% of the actual budget. Where did that other 19% come from?

That is a complete non-sequitur. The amount a grant from one federal entity is reduced is not limited to the same percentage as the total federal budget.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by etherael on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @08:22AM (#5564002)
Totally true, if as a politician you want to manipulate your power base into believing that a small reduction in your power is a really bad move, you should make every possible administrative move to maximise the direct pain they will feel from that reduction.

Keep the fat and cut the muscle makes great sense when you are commanded to drop 1.5% of mass and you want to make the case you're going to lose a ton of strength.

That really doesn't help your case.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by TheCowboy on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @08:20PM (#5561787)
The idea that this pain is a joke is pretty unfounded. It is based upon the idea that there is waste and waste and waste everywhere. If that is the case, then it should be pretty easy to target such wasteful spending, but that isn't exactly the case at all.

Also, these cuts aren't even close to what are desired by a certain segment of law makers. If that desired austerity were to be put in place, and you think agencies at trying to make an examples now, their current examples would pale in comparison to what we would see.

If it is so easy to say an agency doesn't need to cut X when they can cut Y, then pass a bill cutting Y.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by crusso on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @09:22PM (#5562025)
It is based upon the idea that there is waste and waste and waste everywhere

I don't know how educated people concerned about politics and the economic health of this country could not read these kinds of stories that come over the wire and know that there's an extraordinary amount of waste in the Federal government that could easily be cut.

http://articles.sun-sentinel.com/2011-02-19/news/fl-federal-...

Unfortunately, so many voters have their heads in the sand and don't know what's going on - or worse yet, they're doing like you are here and propagating misinformation.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by simonh on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @04:37AM (#5563381)
If only there had been a few Republican presidents in power some time in the last couple of decades to do something about all this waste.
Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by crusso on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @07:50AM (#5563868)
And there's a large part of the problem - your team, my team politics. Democrat, Republican, doesn't really matter. What matters is people who not only understand economics but have our best interests in mind and don't create a mess.
Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by encoderer on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @06:43PM (#5561443)
Right. We blow a crater in our economy, and begin to listen to Keynes when he says that government dirt should be shoveled in as a land-filler of last resort. We shovel-in a fraction of what was lost and then freak out when the hole is not refilled and ready for pavement.

First, most of the debt racked up was not even remotely related to stimulus. So it's not like we have $6tn in stimulus. But mostly, even if it was, the hole we blew in our economy was much larger than even that $6tn.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by dragonwriter on Friday April 19, 2013 @06:21PM (#5578989)
> Well since we've exploded our debt to supposedly lower unemployment and the meter has barely moved, maybe we're doing it wrong?

Many, if not most, Keynesians agree with this -- that the current US policy has been all wrong, even while it some elements were correct in very broad outline. And they were saying that when the policies were proposed, not just when they failed to work.

> We've indulged the Keynesians quite enough over the last $6+ TRILLION dollars, tyvm.

No, what we've done is adopted incoherent policies that are driven by some impulse toward Keynesian with some directly contrary impulses (in part, this is a consequence of different branches of government having different preferences.)

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by Hario on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @06:10PM (#5561270)
What Keynesian 6 trillion dollars are you talking about?
Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by argonaut on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:15PM (#5562247)
You speak of a "meter [that] has barely moved," yet the economic consensus is that were it not for the stimulus, unemployment would be even worse than it is now.
Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by crusso on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @08:00AM (#5563911)
Well since it's mostly the people who spent the money as well as the people who advised us to spend the money who are telling us this - are you surprised? When the press tends to not ask the masterminds of that spending uncomfortable questions, then why should we be confident in our knowledge based upon what they have told us so far?

Shouldn't we be instead be giving more credence to those who said that the stimulus wouldn't accomplish what the Administration was selling? Since those contrarians were right?

You say that it would have been "worse", but how much worse? The justification for adding such a huge amount to our debt was the big return. If the stimulus got us to 7.7% unemployment right now, but without it we'd be at 7.9%... then maybe we should have not incurred so much more debt?

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by ZachPruckowski on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:02PM (#5562414)
I think the issue (or at least my issue as a card-carrying member of The Left) was that (a) at the time, we had a very different economic situation, and (b) objections to what the money was spent on. A lot of that debt came about because of things like not negotiating prescription drug prices in Medicare D and spending hundreds of billions and trillions in Iraq and cutting taxes in a way that disproportionately benefitted the well-off. If we were in a deep situation like we're in now or Bush was proposing spending that money differently, I think there would have been fewer Democratic comments about the debt.

>Maybe 90% Debt:GDP won't hurt too badly, but sooner or later as it rises, it will crater even our economy.

Nobody's suggesting that an infinitely high Debt:GDP is a good thing, but a lot of people were using R-R to argue that we had to prioritize debt reduction now as an emergency even at the expense of stimulating the economy or else we'd wind up as some sort of hybrid Greece/Zimbabwe mess within 5 years.

>It's about our Government's complete inability to get it under control.

I don't really know that that's clear. We've had a period of time where the budget deficits were run up to pay for a major (Cold) war and the tax reforms, and then we ran very low deficits and surpluses in the 1990s. We were basically set such that we'd run a surplus during strong economic years (as the Tech Bubble was) and a slight deficit in weaker ones. We made a series of policy decisions that harmed the budget balance (Iraq, tax cuts, bad policy in Medicare D) but even then, our deficits were still in the neighborhood of nominal GDP growth. So we're actually doing kinda OK, though obviously not great. Then we have the mini-depression, which (a) reduced GDP well below potential, (b) reduced tax revenues due to people making less money, and (c) caused automatic stabilizer payouts (food stamps, unemployment, disability) to rise. It's not like we've been pushing through un-offset new annual spending this last half-decade, beyond the original TARP and ARRA. So if the economy recovers, we'll probably start to level off back into 2005-era deficits, where the deficit/GDP < nominal GDP growth, causing the debt/GDP to shrink.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by vec on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @05:53PM (#5561176)
Going into debt to pay your medical bills is very different than going into debt to buy a yacht.

No one thinks a ballooning deficit is good, some of us just think it's less bad than cutting social security and medicaid in the middle of a recession.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by twoodfin on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @06:13PM (#5561280)
We're in the middle of a recession?
Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by TheCowboy on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @08:25PM (#5561805)
Going by one technical definition, no.

If you look at the whole picture you have to either say that this extended period of higher unemployment is the new 'natural rate of unemployment' or admit that something might be off.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by dragonwriter on Friday April 19, 2013 @06:26PM (#5579001)
> I was in sync with the Left when they decried George W. Bush's no-veto policy and ballooning of the debt.

The Left never decried Bush ballooning the debt, the Left decried Bush ballooning the debt by cutting taxes in a manner which disproportionately favored the rich and focussing massive additional spending on unnecessary war -- that is, he was decried by the left for the <i>distribution</i> of taxation and spending as the debt was being ballooned, not for the balance of taxes vs. spending.

(Secondarily, the Republican Party as a whole was decried by the Left at that time for ballooning the debt to advance those policies after having recently previously taken the position that budget balance was a pre-eminent government priority, a position which Republicans surprisingly returned to embracing once they no longer controlled the White House.)

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by jbooth on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @09:06AM (#5564209)
I didn't say we shouldn't get the deficit under control. I said that we should calibrate our responses to avoid hurting the economy while doing so. In 2009, debt was not the problem, economic collapse was. In 2013, we should start working on the debt but be careful not to hurt the economy while doing so.

Regardless of 'who's guy' is in the White House I maintain there's a difference between inheriting a surplus and turning it into a deficit (during the dotcom bust), and inheriting a trillion dollar deficit and not fixing it right away (during the worst crash since 1929).

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by specialist on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @08:28PM (#5561822)
Now that "their guy" is in the WhiteHouse, they no longer agree that it's irresponsible to set the deficit meter...

Um, no.

Speaking as a proud member of The Left, we objected to blowing the Clinton era surplus by slashing revenue, starting one (or two) unnecessary war(s), and huge wet sloppy kisses to corporations (eg scripts under Medicare Plan-D).

If Bush The Lesser had maintained full employment, deficit or not, The Left would have loved him.

Re:Researchers Finally Replicated Reinhart-Rogoff, and There... by spot on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @08:46PM (#5561893)
you are wrong in every way. 1) you only need deficit spending during a recession. during good times, like pre-crash bush, that's when you pay down debt. 2) it depends on what you spend the money on. if you invest in infrastructure, research, etc that's great. if you invest in bombing iraq and graft to your cronies, no so much.