News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why would a government have created bitcoin? by mseebach on Sunday April 14, 2013 @02:35PM (#5547712)
1: There are absolutely pockets of absolute brilliance in government. Not big one, not a lot of them, but they are there. Also, Bitcoin primarily a crypto research project, not a software engineering one. The government absolutely has a lot of brilliant crypto researchers on staff.

2: It might just be because I don't understand it completely, but as I understand it, every single transaction in Bitcoin is public and traceable - so if you compromise the identity of a wallet (from computer seizures, wiretap etc) you can monitor a target's transactions. A more perfect (or malevolent, depending on your POV) system would not have this traceability.

Re:Ask HN: Why would a government have created bitcoin? by rdl on Sunday April 14, 2013 @02:44PM (#5547765)
I agree there are good cryptographers, but the bitcoin implementation is surprisingly good as well. On point 2 I think you restated what I said.
Re:Ask HN: Why would a government have created bitcoin? by mooneater on Sunday April 14, 2013 @03:15PM (#5547889)
This is very interesting, could you comment on what impresses you about bitcoin implementation?
Re:Ask HN: Why would a government have created bitcoin? by jacquesm on Sunday April 14, 2013 @03:24PM (#5547921)
> could you comment on what impresses you about bitcoin implementation?

Obviously I don't speak for rdl, but what impresses me is the level of anticipation of future developments.

Re:Ask HN: Why would a government have created bitcoin? by tjaerv on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:12PM (#5548085)
Indeed. Mike Hearn's talk at Bitcoin 2012 is a great overview of all that: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mD4L7xDNCmA

All these goodies just waiting in there to come out and play.

Re:Ask HN: Why would a government have created bitcoin? by rdl on Sunday April 14, 2013 @03:34PM (#5547958)
Same reasons as Kaminsky, if nothing else.

There is a lot I hate about BTC but mainly due to it having wrong design goals, vs a wrong implementation.

The essential thing they got wrong was lack of using the market to price risk, and trying to be all or nothing.