2: It might just be because I don't understand it completely, but as I understand it, every single transaction in Bitcoin is public and traceable - so if you compromise the identity of a wallet (from computer seizures, wiretap etc) you can monitor a target's transactions. A more perfect (or malevolent, depending on your POV) system would not have this traceability.
Obviously I don't speak for rdl, but what impresses me is the level of anticipation of future developments.
All these goodies just waiting in there to come out and play.
There is a lot I hate about BTC but mainly due to it having wrong design goals, vs a wrong implementation.
The essential thing they got wrong was lack of using the market to price risk, and trying to be all or nothing.
I bet the NSA and NASA both write code that's orders of magnitude better than anything Yahoo does, just to pick two counterexamples.
And this wouldn't have been their A team.
The motivations are very similar to startups working outside of larger companies. You get more freedom in work choices and pay scale.
Government also discourages small side projects, especially in the classified world, and particularly discourages them from becoming production. They would far prefer to run a program of record, or pay for (well defined) innovation by third parties.
99% of code written by Government is subpar, the other 1% is like Stuxnet
So yeah, I am going to call that "great code."
So bitcoin was probably not released by a tiny .gov. Most likely by a big player like .us, .ru, .cn, .uk, .jp, .de. Probably not the .us because its hard to encourage a replacement if you're the reserve currency see above. So it could be from the .gov of one of the five countries above, maybe a couple others.
1. You haven't worked in government. Their code is worse than Yahoo! or virtually any startup. Bitcoin isn't.
2. Bitcoin is far from the most malevolent possible form for governments. Chaumian blinded money, what I want to build next, with open, non monopolistic exchanges, and protocols designed to be hidden, instant, etc., is the most powerful possible form of anonymous cash.
3. No clue, but probably not, since the concept of a reserve currency is irrelevant. With electronic exchanges, you can separate out the different roles of money.
4. A subset of 3.