News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by axod on Thursday April 09, 2009 @11:11AM (#554482)
>> "Photoshop through a browser? DO NOT WANT."

What you seem to fail to see is that you're an outlier.

Most people want photoshop through a browser. Most people already do most of their stuff through a browser. It's funny to even debate, because it's happening/happened for large amounts of people out there already. Ask your parents what they do on the computer, and it's likely to be 90%+ web, with perhaps a couple of desktop apps. If that.

Ironically, it's the techie usually early adopters that are lagging here, preferring to stick with desktop software. The people leading the webapp charge are people who don't want the fuss of downloading desktop software, with potential spyware etc, and just go to google and find a webapp instead.

The same phenomenon exists when some people discuss advertising. "No one clicks on ads anymore" - it's easy to say, if you install adblock, or just don't click on ads, but this is a total minority. The majority do click on ads. Just like the majority want, and use webapps over desktop apps.

>> "Gmail became popular not because it employed AJAX or was based online, but because it solved a hair-on-fire problem: tiny inbox sizes."

I think actually the reason it succeeded was because it had ridiculously fast searching, and unlike a desktop app, you don't have to worry about your storage. I don't think the majority of people really cared about inbox size. The fact you could easily search for things in a simple and blazingly fast webapp was key. For most people, it is better than a desktop app.

>> "This statement I also find ridiculous. If anything, increased broadband availability has made computers even more of a must-have product."

The fact that broadband access has increased etc means there's less need to have a thick client. Where previously you needed to download a video, click on it, watch it, we all now just watch videos streamed to us by a webapp. When we all have 1Gbps connections, why would we need a full powerful computer each? Why would it not be in most persons better interest to just have a very thin power conserving client that connects up to the big servers doing the grunt work.

The fact is, it's happening, and will continue to happen. You can't stop it. It's inevitable. You might prefer to stick with your computer and desktop apps, but you'll be a small minority, like the people who still buy records on vinyl.

>> "The revolution in web apps was making them behave more like desktop apps."

I disagree with that. The revolution in webapps is making them work BETTER than desktop apps. Gmail can search my mail much faster than my computer can. Mibbit can do things impossible with desktop IRC clients. etc etc

The reason Microsoft are 'dead' is that they don't get it. They're dead in a similar sense to the music industry IMHO - the market changed around them and they completely failed to adapt.

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by neilc on Thursday April 09, 2009 @12:38PM (#554651)
What you seem to fail to see is that you're an outlier.

When PG says stuff like "I'm now surprised when I come across a computer running Windows", I think he's more of an outlier than the parent poster.

Gmail can search my mail much faster than my computer can.

There's no technological reason for this to be true. Gmail takes a second or two to answer search queries over my mail; that is plenty of time for a typical desktop machine to process full-text search queries over a few GB of indexed and largely static data.

The reason Microsoft are 'dead' is that they don't get it.

I think most of my objection to the original PG article is the shameless hyperbole it engages in. Microsoft isn't "dead" by any stretch of the imagination -- they are poorly positioned for cloud computing, but the game is certainly not over yet. Claiming that Microsoft is "no longer a factor one has to consider when doing something in technology" is simply wrong -- even if you narrow your focus to consumer-facing web apps, Microsoft still provides the dominant client platform (IE), and a very popular backend infrastructure (SQL + ASP.NET + CLR + ...).

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by pg on Thursday April 09, 2009 @06:02PM (#555253)
When PG says stuff like "I'm now surprised when I come across a computer running Windows", I think he's more of an outlier than the parent poster.

Different kind of outlier though: when you're an outlier because you spend an inordinate amount of time among people creating new technology, then your anomalous experience makes you better at predicting the future, not worse.

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by neilc on Thursday April 09, 2009 @07:37PM (#555384)
when you're an outlier because you spend an inordinate amount of time among people creating new technology, then your anomalous experience makes you better at predicting the future, not worse.

Sometimes, but not always. If you spent all your time hanging out with people creating new technology in the mid 1980s, you might have been convinced that Lisp machines would soon become the dominant computing platform.

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by brlewis on Thursday April 09, 2009 @10:22PM (#555580)
Mid 1980s one would have predicted Unix/C and distributed computing using Internet protocols would soon dominate, and would have been wrong...about the "soon" part.
Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by axod on Thursday April 09, 2009 @05:11PM (#555175)
>> " still provides the dominant client platform (IE), and a very popular backend infrastructure (SQL + ASP.NET + CLR + ...)."

For most startups I don't think they give ms backend a second thought. It's a no brainer to use free open source.

Also, amongst webapps, IE is no longer the dominant client platform at all in my experience.

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by brk on Thursday April 09, 2009 @11:26AM (#554508)
The Photoshop example is a little bit unique...

I too do not want Photoshop in a browser. I shoot Canon 5D and 5DMkII. My RAW images are HUGE. I'd either have to upload them to the server to "edit", or download a fairly hefty app to run locally. Photoshop (true photoshop) is processor and bandwidth intensive when used as intended. It won't live in the cloud for a very long time.

Now, what my parents and similar folks want is a way to reduce red-eye, crop and convert photos and apply some simple effects. Sure, THAT can be a web-app. But, the cloud is not killing photoshop.

I also personally do a lot of business travel. Until planes have free, good wifi, then "cloud apps" suck for me. I want to be able to read emails and queue responses while in-flight. I want to be able to edit and organize docs and presentations. I want to be able to look up an address or phone number from my inbox QUICKLY, without having to establish a wifi connection, accept some TOS for the free access, go to gmail, find the message, etc. Just pop open my MBP, give it 8 seconds to "wakeup", go to mail.app and pull the message I want.

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by axod on Thursday April 09, 2009 @11:39AM (#554534)
>> "My RAW images are HUGE"

In a few years time those will likely take less than a second to upload though.

I agree, video editing, large photo editing will take longer to move over.

>> "Until planes have free, good wifi"

It'll certainly happen, it's just a matter of how quickly. I'd bet maybe 5 years :/

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by brk on Thursday April 09, 2009 @12:06PM (#554591)
In a few years I will likely be shooting .RAWs that are 50MB...

Some things are simply not meant to be done in the cloud. I think the right answer is to not fight the cloud OR the desktop appropriate applications. Developers should realize that for many markets, they may have to support both models to gain significant market share. Most companies have gained marketshare by customers what they want instead of forcing a particular model upon them...

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by Tamerlin on Thursday April 09, 2009 @02:32PM (#554884)
Mine are already over 500MB. An online Photoshop wouldn't be at all feasible for me :)
Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by bemmu on Thursday April 09, 2009 @03:50PM (#555012)
Except there will be wireless internet everywhere, and by the time you get home your camera will have uploaded your images.
Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by Tamerlin on Friday April 10, 2009 @01:09PM (#556332)
That's going to be a long time in coming; I shoot film, and what ends up in Photoshop is Silverfast raw in TIFF format.
Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by krakensden on Thursday April 09, 2009 @01:19PM (#554726)
Are you sure? At least in the US, hasn't broadband speed and cost been fairly static for the past five years. I'm not sure I would bet on super fat pipes solving all the problems with web applications.

Thin clients too- I don't think you can honestly expect that. The difference between using google docs and a native application is night and day. Docs is slow, prone to pauses, and has lots of bugs related to the poor mapping between html and page layout. Either the browser is going to get a lot faster, we're going to need /thicker/ clients, or people will stay with the status quo:

writing their documents in word, copying and pasting them into google docs only when they need an easy wiki.

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by old-gregg on Thursday April 09, 2009 @10:41PM (#555599)
In a few years time those will likely take less than a second to upload though.

If anything, Internet has been getting slower and slower due to congestion and server overloads. Upload speeds still haven't reached 100Kb/sec for 90% of the population after 10 years of affordable broadband arrival.

Pushing everything into a centralized location makes absolutely no sense. Not every byte on my hard drive needs to be shared with other people.

Instead we'll be moving towards rich browser runtimes, to allow on-the-fly downloaded&installed code to effectively work with local data.

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by heyadayo on Thursday April 09, 2009 @02:49PM (#554913)
Wasn't there a YC startup around that time which had the goal of putting photoshop in the browser?
Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by pg on Thursday April 09, 2009 @04:00PM (#555032)
Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by dbul on Thursday April 09, 2009 @04:15PM (#555062)
Why isn't this in faq.html? It appears to be launched.
Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by pg on Thursday April 09, 2009 @04:19PM (#555074)
Oops, fixed.
Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by mattmaroon on Thursday April 09, 2009 @03:05PM (#554946)
Most people do not want Photoshop in a browser. Most people do not want Photoshop at all. They just want something simple to crop, resize, remove red-eye, fix color and brightness levels, etc. They want Picassa in a browser maybe but not Photoshop.

Anybody who does want Photoshop does not want it in a browser.

The reason Microsoft is in much less of a leadership position is that there are a lot more people who want Picassa than Photoshop. That doesn't mean desktop software is dead (the people who want Photoshop pay handily for it) but it does mean they're no longer as important as they were.

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by old-gregg on Thursday April 09, 2009 @11:36AM (#554526)
Most people already do most of their stuff through a browser

We merely settled on a standardized approach to networked GUIs. Instead of proliferation of 3rd party networking apps like usenet/email clients, ftp clients, various VB/Oracle business forms apps, people simply use HTTP-based UI stack. Frankly, not that big of a deal. People _feel_ like that's a big deal because this opened networking to the masses, presented a lot of business opportunities, but fundamentally, this hasn't changed anything.

The type of applications people are running hasn't changed. If your data needs to be shared with others, you need an application with a network access and it means a web site. If not - why does it need to be in a browser?

Yes, people waste time online a lot, that only means they aren't really using their computers. It's like watching TV: most of them have CPUs and RAM and stuff,yet you aren't seeing "TV evangelists" screaming that new era of computing has arrived: with 50" screens and remotes instead of keyboards. That, however, is happening with the iPhone: look how excited everybody is about "desktop apps" you can run on it.

Paul is right: new website founders have no reason to fear Microsoft because they aren't competing with them. But that's not new: it is exactly like starting a landscaping or dog walking business in the 90s: Microsoft couldn't care less.

If anything, they have won. They have such a strong grip on Windows platform that it takes big balls to start a company in that space. My deepest respect to Xobni for taking on the challenge.

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by axod on Thursday April 09, 2009 @11:42AM (#554540)
>> "If anything, they have won. They have such a strong grip on Windows platform that it takes big balls to start a company in that space."

I disagree though, the 'windows platform' is irrelevant for most people for the reasons in the article. Most people don't care what OS it is, as long as it has a web browser.

The 'windows platform' is about as relevant as the computers BIOS is - it's there to allow them to start a web browser.

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by old-gregg on Thursday April 09, 2009 @03:18PM (#554968)
This is just childish and you know it. There are insane trillions of dollars worth of data trapped in various Microsoft-owned formats behind Microsoft-controlled APIs, from SQL Server databases to Office documents and Exchange servers. The code doesn't matter, data does, and Microsoft controls a lot of it, so I don't buy your BIOS comparison.

I work at a web startup myself, we sell SaaS to businesses and, unfortunately, they deeply care about their Windows-dependent data,

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by axod on Thursday April 09, 2009 @05:15PM (#555180)
Selling SaaS to businesses is a whole different ball game. I'm talking about consumer facing apps.

Companies move ridiculously slowly - one of the reasons for there still being IE6 usage out there. So obviously they are going to stick with Microsoft/desktop apps etc, but the general population won't.

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by ratsbane on Thursday April 09, 2009 @01:10PM (#554708)
It's a mistake to assume that "apps in the browser" and "apps in the cloud" are the same thing. HTML in the future will allow much more in-browser data storage. The cloud does offer a big advantage in access to data but the other big advantage of browser apps is that you can run the same code whether it's Mac, PC, Android phone, etc.

The advantages of browser apps - standard and ubiquitous deployment target, potential use of cloud - are all improving over time.

The disadvantages of browser apps are all in factors like bandwidth and connectivity - factors which are steadily giving way to the advance of technology.

I'm betting on the future of browser-based apps. PG was right.

http://dev.w3.org/html5/spec/Overview.html

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by qeorge on Thursday April 09, 2009 @01:13PM (#554712)
The other responderer's covered most everything I would have said in response to this, but this cracked me up:

>> you'll be a small minority, like the people who still buy records on vinyl.

You got me there, I totally do buy my records on vinyl.

Cheers!

Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by mattmaroon on Thursday April 09, 2009 @03:06PM (#554949)
I buy CDs on vinyl.
Re:Paul Graham revisits "Microsoft is Dead" by axod on Thursday April 09, 2009 @05:18PM (#555186)
That'd be cool actually, a dual format... CD on one side, vinyl on the other. Might be some optical challenges to get around to compensate for the grooves etc :/