If you think the real meaning of the bill has nothing to do with the text of the bill, that the text of the bill doesn't matter, just give up. CISPA is tiny compared to ECPA; if you think CISPA has holes a truck could drive through, give a close read to SCA. If you believe the government is going to use milk safety regulations to prosecute movie pirates, just let them pass whatever, and skip the arguments.
No, I couldn't. There are unfortunately a lot of bills I could have said that about (and I mentioned some of them), but not literally any bill ever.
In fact, most bills are not about granting more power to intelligence agencies at the cost of privacy protections.
But thanks for sticking to your role as mindless CISPA defender. You play it well.
EDIT:
> If you think the real meaning of the bill has nothing to do with the text of the bill, that the text of the bill doesn't matter, just give up.
I didn't say that and obviously didn't mean that.
I also couldn't give a shit about movie pirates. I buy my entertainment. That's the bonus of being a full grown adult with a career.
But I do care about the erosion of privacy law for no benefit whatsoever, and in fact, what I see as a detriment; continuing to grow the intelligence industry which has no public oversight. That's a Bad Idea(tm).
I called him "mindless CISPA defender" because based on his comments on the subject, that seems like an accurate description.
And in my specific case he seemed to pay no attention whatsoever to what I brought up and replied with a handful of boilerplate responses that didn't really apply to what I was saying. So, that seemed pretty much like a mindless automaton to me.
So is asking about unintended consequences of legislation that's touted as accomplishing one thing but will be far broader. CISPA's sponsors say it's necessary to respond to the real threat of Chinese military hackers, but of course the legislation isn't limited to that.
If there are a series of related and bad bills, offering the same general criticisms of them is reasonable. If you're pro-choice and are upset by state efforts to ban abortion, then you can use similar language ("fully against..." "we shouldn't be putting more power in the hands...") to talk about bills in Arkansas, Colorado, Mississippi, North Dakota, Kansas, etc.
Of course a more detailed discussion involves going into more depth and talking about the differences between each state's anti-abortion proposals.
Why not just have the Feds or whoever call up Google and say "Look, this is really important information, as I'm sure you agree, so let's solve the problem, and if any technicalities were violated along the way, we'll get them excused by the overwhelming benefit of your actions" ?
You generally need to read it side-by-side with the law it's amending. You need to read any amendments, and the rejected amendments. You need to read caselaw on point so you're aware of how courts have interpreted certain terms. You need to read existing laws in the same area. To the extent that courts will consider it, you need to read the legislative history, floor debate, and committee reports. Ideally you'd want to talk to a lawyer specializing in this area. Obviously the shorter the law, the less all this is necessary, but the text of the law tends to be merely a starting point.
The problem with CISPA is we don't need it. I'm not a libertarian (I want single payer universal health care, for example), but I am fully against the PATRIOT Act, FISA abuse and the numerous other things done in the name of security since 9/11.
The reason 9/11 happened was not a lack of security or intelligence; we had those. It was failure to act on the information we had.
We shouldn't be putting more power in the hands of intelligence agencies which have no public oversight. I understand the need for those agencies, but I think they should be as small as possible. Things like CISPA seem to be based on an opposite view; giving them as much power as possible.
EDIT:
Also the notion that you can learn everything you need to know about these bills by reading the bill itself is so myopic as to be comical.