For example the Patriot Act was sold as a thing that would only be used to catch terrorists. It's total terrorist-catching prosecutions to date is trivial, zero to a few. But it's still getting used quite a bit.
http://www.nytimes.com/2003/09/28/us/us-uses-terror-law-to-p...
http://www.cbsnews.com/2100-201_162-573155.html
I'm not saying that the people who got caught in many of those cases didn't do something wrong, nor am I saying that they should get away with no consequences. But I don't see how you can charge people with "terrorism" for doing decidedly non-terrorist things.
My fear is that, like the PATRIOT act, CISPA will grant overly-broad powers to intelligence agencies that will be employed for general surveillance. My view is that any law that curtails liberty should do so minimally. I don't oppose fighting cybersecurity threats, but the bill needs work still.
For anyone curious, the ACLU has several blog posts breaking down the problems with CISPA: http://www.aclu.org/search/cispa?show_aff=1
‘(B) EXCLUSION.— Such term does not
23 include information pertaining to efforts to gain
24 unauthorized access to a system or network of
25 a government or private entity that solely in
1 volve violations of consumer terms of service or
2 consumer licensing agreements and do not oth-
3 erwise constitute unauthorized access.Mind you, I'm not saying the previous poster's claim is the best argument against CISPA, but that your claim of "directly contradicted" is false.
From our point of view it's disgusting but for upper management it's a no-brainer.