News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by masonhensley on Thursday April 11, 2013 @05:12PM (#5534846)
Girl Talk and other DJ's, remixers, samplers, whatever you want to call them make their money from performances. I was kinda hoping the article talked more about that aspect of their business. Basically all their mix tapes are promotion for the live events.

When I was a Junior/Senior (2009-2010) at Vanderbilt, I was VP of the programming board that arranged speakers, concerts, homecoming, comedians and other campus events and activities. We had Girl Talk come and while the price was not 6-figure crazy like what Acivii[1] charges these days, I was hit with sticker shock big time.

[1] http://www.gq.com/entertainment/music/201304/avicii-tim-berg...

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by _delirium on Thursday April 11, 2013 @05:19PM (#5534889)
It's also easier, at least in the U.S., to do more liberal sampling when live than on recordings, since you don't have to clear the samples individually. Most music venues have a blanket license for performance rights with the main rights organizations, which clears the rights for live use of just about anything: stuff like the venue playing a CD as background music during intermission, a band playing a cover song on stage, or a DJ playing tracks or remixing samples.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by hello_newman on Thursday April 11, 2013 @05:33PM (#5534948)
"Basically all their mixtapes are promotion for the live events."

I think that is a great model, personally. I want artists to not care about getting rich off of downloads. I think it's great when artists ranging from Deadmau5, Lil Wayne or Wiz Khalifa, release mixtapes for free. That seems to be the "artist" mentality, fuck getting paid; I'm doing this (making music) because I love doing this. It shows passion, commitment to their craft, and a true level of artistry. You could even argue the same thing for developers who release their apps for free because they want everyone to enjoy it regardless of price.

I obviously want artists to make as much money as possible, so releasing great mixtapes does make me, personally, want to go see their concerts. It seems to be a great way to market yourself and with labels taking so much from artists anyway, the place where most new artists make money is touring and live shows. I don't want to go to a concert wear essentially the artist is just playing their latest CD to a crowd of people.

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by tptacek on Thursday April 11, 2013 @06:16PM (#5535140)
No, it's a model that works only for the very most popular acts. Independent artists who compose original music and tour clubs make McDonalds wages (or often less) doing that.

Which is to say nothing about the idea of creating a structural requirement that professional musicians have to live an itinerant lifestyle.

You can want artists not to care about their recording rights as much as you like, but wanting recording rights not to matter is not the same thing as them actually not mattering.

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by hello_newman on Thursday April 11, 2013 @06:44PM (#5535322)
It does and it doesn't. I see a lot of similarities with the recording industry and the current start up "scene". In the music business, you get noticed by labels for having an awesome mixtape, much like developers getting noticed by VC's for having a popular website/app. Touring clubs makes a couple bucks, probably on par with a "McJob", but more often then not even small acts have a sponsor or some backing so they don't have to work full time and can fully commit to performing. My cousin got popular the same way; performing in small clubs, his record got noticed, hacked is way into a radio Christmas Show which got him noticed again, got a couple acting gigs, a movie roll, and now he's actually pretty big in the Midwest and overseas. Here he is; Tylerhilton.com

"You can want artists not to care about their recording rights as much as you like, but wanting recording rights not to matter is not the same thing as them actually not mattering."

I do agree with that. I want them to be compensated for their creative efforts, which means the artist, not necessarily their label, holds those rights. I wish they didn't matter as much as they did so everyone could enjoy their music much easier, but you cannot have your cake and eat it too I suppose.

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by tptacek on Thursday April 11, 2013 @07:00PM (#5535402)
Even that last sentiment oversimplifies the economics. The C.W. is that rapacious labels took an undue share of the proceeds from artists, so that buying a CD was essentially just subsidizing a middleman.

But it turns out, most major-label albums never recouped, and the artists kept the advance regardless. Labels served a similar function in commercial music as VCs serve in startups: they'd subsidize near-market wages for 9 money-losing bets in exchange for large proceeds from one breakout success.

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by anigbrowl on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:10PM (#5535728)
This article is worth reading; I posted it here when it came out but (perhaps unsurprisingly) it sank like a stone: http://www.theverge.com/2013/3/4/4054634/musics-pay-what-you...
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by Retric on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:46PM (#5535857)
I don't think reducing the number of small acts out there is a bad thing. Let's face it the overwhelming majority of bands suck, and plenty of people are going to do it for free as a hobby or just to get laid. So, IMO convincing the vast majority of starving artists to move on with there lives is probably a good thing.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by tptacek on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:53PM (#5535882)
You know what sucks even more overwhelmingly than the majority of indie acts? The mainstream successes.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by hello_newman on Thursday April 11, 2013 @09:21PM (#5535971)
Continuing the music industry to start-up scene analogy as used above, the same could be said for start ups.

I do have to agree with what you said, though. Most mainstream successes really are puppets of the big labels. If you notice, all the songs sound (about) the same sound, same shitty lyrics about whatever, ego-stroking, and bits of flamboyance to flaunt how much money they are making. They all even have the same career trajectory of talk shows, scandals, dating habits etc. Makes me wonder if the labels are, indeed, behind this or if these new "artists" are all just really damn similar.

Lots of good Indie Music out there (in every genre), but too much of it sucks. Surprisingly in the last year or so, T.V commercials have been a decent source for finding good Indie Music. Sam Adams, Sprint, and Cigna commercials all turned me on to great artists that I would have otherwise had no idea existed.

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by derleth on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:56PM (#5535889)
> it's a model that works only for the very most popular acts.

Isn't that true of every single model out there?

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by tptacek on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:56PM (#5535890)
No, it's not.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by anigbrowl on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:07PM (#5535721)
It's a terrible model for musicians that aren't famous or who don't make music that's fashionable enough to attract a large crowd.

That seems to be the "artist" mentality, fuck getting paid; I'm doing this (making music) because I love doing this.

It is part of the artist mentality, but it's also great marketing. If you go to Soundcloud or similar sites, loads of artists are giving music away for free (not least to conduct musical conversations with their peers and get feedback etc.), but that doesn't mean they're all getting gigs out of it. The artists you mention are all already famous and can write off the time spent on doing free mixtapes as a promotional expense.

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by hello_newman on Thursday April 11, 2013 @09:10PM (#5535944)
"The artists you mention are all already famous and can write off the time spent on doing free mixtapes as a promotional expense."

True, they are famous now, but all of them used mixtapes to become famous. Wiz came up as a rapper through mixtapes. Lil Wayne released "I'm Me" as a mixtape, which was supposed to be "The Carter 3" but it was leaked so he released it for free. Not to mention, he pretty much invented the "free mixtape to use a marketing tool" which I think he did by accident. His music sucks now, but The Carter 2 is a great CD and I don't think I would have found out about him at 16 unless it had been for his mixtape work.

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by anigbrowl on Friday April 12, 2013 @02:18AM (#5536943)
he pretty much invented the "free mixtape to use a marketing tool"

I find this assertion hilarious, but that's probably because you're 24 and I'm 42. People have been doing this sort of thing for ages.

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by PavlovsCat on Friday April 12, 2013 @02:36AM (#5536982)
What about music that can only be crafted, but not played live? What about music that works best with headphones? What about music that doesn't lend itself to the consumption of alcohol? What about those who want to make music, not T-Shirts or mugs or what-the-fuck-ever? Congrats, you just restricted musicians to live entertainers, just because that's all you care about.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by eli on Thursday April 11, 2013 @06:02PM (#5535060)
Sort of a bummer though in some ways. What if you make great records but suck live? What if you make great records and just don't want to have to relentlessly tour to get paid?
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by dublinben on Thursday April 11, 2013 @06:08PM (#5535089)
Then get a real job! There is no rule that musicians have to make a living plying their craft. Alternatively, get a sponsor. If it was good enough for Mozart and Beethoven, it's good enough for you. Art has never really (nor should necessarily) be commercially viable.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by anigbrowl on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:11PM (#5535734)
Oh, those artists, expecting to get paid for having fun. Here, this song is for you: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lAD6Obi7Cag
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by vacri on Friday April 12, 2013 @01:09AM (#5536755)
"This video contains content from UMG. It is not available in your country. Sorry about that." :)
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by anigbrowl on Friday April 12, 2013 @02:23AM (#5536950)
Dire Straits/Money for Nothing.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by eli on Thursday April 11, 2013 @07:37PM (#5535593)
Harsh! I'm not saying the situation you propose is inhumane or immoral... it's just a bummer.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by pyre on Thursday April 11, 2013 @06:12PM (#5535115)
There is a lot of software that would be "nice to write," but wouldn't necessarily pay the bills. You don't see me turning to the law to make a business model.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by eli on Thursday April 11, 2013 @07:40PM (#5535605)
Hey, don't make me into some protectionist, anti-copyright reform strawman.

If there's cool software that doesn't exist because the universe lacks an equitable way to compensate you for its creation, then that sucks.

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by flyinRyan on Friday April 12, 2013 @06:27AM (#5537628)
>fuck getting paid; I'm doing this (making music) because I love doing this. It shows passion, commitment to their craft, and a true level of artistry.

And it also shows that they're either already successful, already rich, or somehow able to avoid any kind of steady expenses. I'd love to do research in software. I don't care about making CRUD apps over and over, there are tons of things I'd like to experiment on and I bet at least one of them would end up benefiting others. But I'll likely never get to do any of this stuff because work demands the monopoly of my time and my wife and kids fight over what's left.

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by swang on Thursday April 11, 2013 @06:44PM (#5535320)
Any artist in Asia has been doing this for years. CD is promotion, live performances are the moneymakers.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by anigbrowl on Friday April 12, 2013 @04:44PM (#5540889)
Yes, and look at how dire the asian music scene is, in general.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by antidaily on Thursday April 11, 2013 @11:15PM (#5536401)
Junior Senior rules.