Re:Amazon Coins Launching
by codex on Thursday April 11, 2013 @03:31PM
(#5534216)
Amazon can't really avoid doing stuff like this, because their business model (retail) sucks, and makes very little money due to razor thin margins. So they trot out every trick in the book.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
> Walmart can't really avoid doing stuff like this, because their business model (retail) sucks, and makes very little money due to razor thin margins. So they trot out every trick in the book.
Wait, no, Walmart avoids things like loyalty card discounts, etc. They also seem to have a decent business model. You're going to have to elaborate a little more.
>Walmart avoids things like loyalty card discounts
Walmart has "walmart cards" and while they don't give you a discount, what you will notice is that if you return something they might resist if you ask for cash back but saying "put it back on my walmart card" will result in a near instant refund in almost any situation.
I always thought it worked for Walmart because they have disgustingly high volume? (And therefore could have razor thin margins.)
Re:Amazon Coins Launching
by itistoday2 on Thursday April 11, 2013 @05:14PM
(#5534864)
And Amazon doesn't have a "disgustingly high volume"...??
I've heard there was some other trick involved in Amazon's profits, that worked precisely because of high volume, and wouldn't work for middle / small size circulation. Something with reinvesting temporary resources during some time slot and etc. But I'm not sure how valid such claim is.
What profits?
Something like this. Let's say Amazon sells 1000 items from some manufacturer. Amazon pays manufacturer with delay (let's say 20 days after they get the merchandise). But Amazon manages to sell this 1000 in 10 days (because they have massive sales scale). In result Amazon has spare money for 10 days until they need to pay. So they have a potential to use them for 10 days. That's what I've heard, I'm not sure how valid this is.
This seems very pertinent to the current thread. Amazon Coins means Amazon gets Customer's money before it is actually used.
In this case, the vendor should just increase their prices to reflect the interest on the credit that they're extending Amazon for those twenty days. This is equivalent to Amazon borrowing from a bank for those 20 days, but perhaps for some reason the creditor's interest rate is lower than the bank's.
Yes, it's equivalent to a loan with no interest rate. Whether vendor has to increase prices or not - that's up to the vendor. I just described how Amazon has a potential to profit from lower than common prices and fast shipping - it increases this loan time window.
Well, Walmart doesn't have razor thin margins. On some things they do (on some things they even lose money) but e.g. toys have a markup of over 40%, for example. That's probably not even the highest margin.