News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mtgox stops trading for 12 hours by gigavps on Thursday April 11, 2013 @10:50AM (#5532284)
I do believe that the bitcoin payment network adds a great deal of value. As for the price of bitcoin, it is still mostly driven by speculation.

As a business owner, there is nothing better than being able to transact with anyone, anywhere in the world instantly. You certainly can't do that with credit cards or paypal.

Re:Mtgox stops trading for 12 hours by Nursie on Thursday April 11, 2013 @10:54AM (#5532307)
I'm not sure it's such a great network, when you look at the ability of one service (SatoshiDice) to effectively overload it to the point some people started leaving their transactions out of their blockchain calculations.

As a consumer I also actually like the chargeback and other protections afforded to me by paypal and credit cards.

--edit-- I'll add that technically I think it's a fantastic achievement, and as an amateur crypto-geek it's fascinating. The people who came up with the scheme and have coded it have done a great job (though there are the aforementioned scalability problems), but I disagree with almost all the design decisions that went into the vision of the thing.

Re:Mtgox stops trading for 12 hours by kiba on Thursday April 11, 2013 @11:06AM (#5532388)
As a consumer I also actually like the chargeback and other protections afforded to me by paypal and credit cards.

The flip side is higher price charged by merchants due to higher processing fees. Not to mention that paypal will close down your accounts whenever they feel that you are too suspicious.

Of course, with bitcoin, merchants will charge lower fees since they no longer have to worry about chargebacks. Nobody also can't prevent you from spending bitcoin as you like(as long it's your personal wallet).

Re:Mtgox stops trading for 12 hours by Nursie on Thursday April 11, 2013 @11:10AM (#5532412)
As I said, I actually like these features of paypal and CCs, even if prices are slightly higher as a result. I definitely agree that competition in this space would be good, but I don't think throwing out consumer-friendly features is the answer.

To me, "no longer have to worry about chargebacks" is the same thing as "can take your money and run, and there's nothing you can do about it".

Re:Mtgox stops trading for 12 hours by kansface on Thursday April 11, 2013 @11:25AM (#5532531)
Credit cards are a completely different model. When you hand someone your CC, you say, "please take exactly the amount of money I'd like you to and no more. Oh, and don't take any money out in the future, either." Only stolen bitcoins have this problem.
Re:Mtgox stops trading for 12 hours by Nursie on Thursday April 11, 2013 @11:29AM (#5532563)
Not really. You're saying "I authorise exactly this amount of money and no more", and if they then take any more or don't deliver the service it's fraud, and you're protected from that by consumer credit law (at least you are here in the UK).
Re:Mtgox stops trading for 12 hours by nwh on Thursday April 11, 2013 @12:04PM (#5532796)
Same. It empowers me as the consumer to get exactly what I paid for.
Re:Mtgox stops trading for 12 hours by Retric on Thursday April 11, 2013 @01:29PM (#5533409)
Raw bit-coins can't do fast transactions without risking double spends. Which limits you to a ~20 min checkout process or using 3rd party services then you deal with whatever their rules are.
Re:Mtgox stops trading for 12 hours by gergles on Thursday April 11, 2013 @12:56PM (#5533180)
You also can't "instantly" transact with Bitcoin, unless you're willing to risk a double-spend. You have to wait for confirmations through the blockchain which involve fees AND waiting (or really really long waiting) -- if you're going to pay a fee, why not just use the CC network and get it done instantly? At least when you get an auth from the CC network, you know you're guaranteed the money. When a transaction completes on the blockchain, it's still up in the air until the next block is produced by enough people.
Re:Mtgox stops trading for 12 hours by wmf on Thursday April 11, 2013 @01:31PM (#5533423)
At least when you get an auth from the CC network, you know you're guaranteed the money.

Unless there's a chargeback 59 days later. These kinds of arguments can go either way.

Re:Mtgox stops trading for 12 hours by Cushman on Thursday April 11, 2013 @11:25AM (#5532537)
> As a business owner, there is nothing better than being able to transact with anyone, anywhere in the world instantly. You certainly can't do that with credit cards or paypal.

How about being able to transact with 99% of your customer base in a reliable, fraud-proof manner?