News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by argumentum on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:18PM (#5528255)
I don't understand .. why would you purchase a home without the land it rests on? In a free market, perhaps there is some lower price where you would do this, but there is also a higher price where you could purchase the land as well.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by enjo on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:35PM (#5528681)
People buy Condo's all the time. Also, in the United States, you very often give up mineral rights. So you may own the "ground" your home is on, but you don't own whatever comes out of it.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by joezydeco on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @09:26PM (#5529359)
Condominium owners usually own a proportional share of the land that the building rests upon and the common areas of the property.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by rdtsc on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @10:28PM (#5529601)
That seems almost like a scam. Kind of like time shares.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by mh- on Thursday April 11, 2013 @03:07AM (#5530398)
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by joezydeco on Thursday April 11, 2013 @09:13AM (#5531694)
Condos differ from time shares. In a condominium, you own 100% of a unit and everything inside the boundaries of that unit is your responsibility (repairs, damage, upgrades, etc). You also have exclusive access to that unit (nobody else can use it, unlike a time-share).

You own a fraction of the land that the building sits on, and a fraction of the "common areas" (lobby, swimming pool, parking lot, etc). You are responsible for contributing for the maintenance of those areas, or paying assessment fees to a management company that will take care of those areas.

Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by joezydeco on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @11:09PM (#5529754)
Why would that be a scam? If anything, it protects the unit owners from things like the landlord selling the building and forcing everyone to move. You can't sell an entire condo building and land without clear title from every single unit owner.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by bcgraham on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:20PM (#5528270)
Because that's the only type of home on the market!
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by aetherson on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:36PM (#5528368)
Well, argumentum's point is that presumably there is some cost at which the ground holder would sell the land.

Like, if the ground rental brings in $10,000 per year to the owner of the title, and I came along and said, "I will pay your $1,000,000 for the title," well... I'm offering you one century's worth of ground-use fees up-front. Presumably all but the most irrational actors would sell their ground.

Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by rhizome on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:48PM (#5529019)
I'm not sure adding £1,000,000 to the price of houses is a rational solution to ground rent.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by vacri on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:25PM (#5528893)
Of course, but that's nitpicking. The point is that the price is well out of reach of the average Tom.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by aetherson on Thursday April 11, 2013 @11:40AM (#5532656)
Well, but why is it out of reach?

I mean, the same guy ("Tom") is going to be giving you money one way or the other. Either in bits and pieces as ground lease, or in lump-sum as purchase.

If you simply want more money than Tom can pay, well, you're out of luck. You don't get any money if you price your tenants out of the market.

If there is an amount of money that Tom can afford to pay in ground leases, then why can't he get a bank loan and make you an attractive offer on the purchase? My earlier example of 100 years rent was extreme to make a point. What if Tom offered you 20 years land rent in an up-front lump sum? Maybe not every land-owner would consider that a good deal, but it's hard to imagine that none of them would. The land-owner gets a present value that exceeds the future value of the rent to them, the bank gets interest, Tom gets synergistic value from now owning not just the house but the land.

Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by makomk on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @08:15PM (#5529098)
I suspect you'll find the economics are such that most home owners wouldn't be able to afford to buy the land their house is on.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by rdtsc on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @10:34PM (#5529621)
So what happens. Presumably there is a completely parallel market for land. Land owning elites presumably buy and sell land all the time and homes are bought and sold all the time as well. The two rarely intersect? Or maybe those that can buy land can easily buy the house as well? Very confusing. In US effectively the local government and the state "own" and you are just leasing it. There is not parallel land market unless jurisdiction lines get redrawn for some reason or a states secedes from the Union or something like that (you can imagine some negotiations then where the city say, this land with homes brings in $45M in property taxes/year, we wish to sell it for $1.3B cash...) of course this is all hypothetical...just to make a parallel.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by desas on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:31AM (#5531469)
Usually it's not a house, but a block of apartments, each of which are owned individually. It's usually cost prohibitive for someone who owns one apartment in a block of twenty to buy out the land for all twenty.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by ksherlock on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @10:15PM (#5529551)
I used to live in a city with a community land trust. You can buy the house and get a long-term lease on the land but the land trust (a non-profit organization) retains ownership of the land. They also have a right to buy the house back when you sell it, limiting you to 25% appreciation.

The intention is to keep house prices affordable. (Sort of an upscale trailer park, now that I think about it). If you had the means to buy elsewhere, you probably would.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Community_land_trust

Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by PeterisP on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:38PM (#5528385)
Once there are separate owners (for whatever reason it happened), it's not that easy to arrange that - since the land owner usually does not want to sell.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by rdtsc on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @10:36PM (#5529627)
What if they do sell? Can land owners do whatever they like to the home owners? Like kick them out? Start drilling tunnels through the land, extract oil in the back yard?
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by desas on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:35AM (#5531489)
Usually the home owner will have a lease that lasts for 99 years (or at least the person who first built the home had a lease for 99 years...).

Mortgage providers won't give you a mortgage term that ends after the lease does.

Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by analog on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @10:58PM (#5529712)
Unscrupulous landlords will increase the rent.
Re:The Tyranny of Taxi Medallions by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:20PM (#5528876)
Well, what if most houses in an economy were what we called apartments?

Also, in China, the people (gov) owns the land. We are only entitled to a 70 year lease on it. Oddly enough, this is applied to housing (apartments) also. But China also lacks a property tax and so has all the bad speculation behavior and rent-seeking that goes along with that.