Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by sp332 on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:21PM
(#5526556)
BTCguild got the lion's share of ASIC miners (so far, anyway). There's actually been some worry since that pool is approaching 51% of the network's power! That means with a malicious server, the admins could (theoretically, not saying they would) take over the entire network. They have taken some steps to reduce the number of miners in the guild, and have pledged to raise their fees if their control goes over 40%, to force miners to other pools. https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=168108.0
(The way they could take over the network is by crafting a new blockchain, forging fake transactions or even claiming that they own all bitcoins. If they solve blocks faster than the rest of the network, soon their malicious chain would become longer and therefore accepted by all clients! Clients always trust the longest chain because it takes the most work to make, so you would have to control most of the mining power to fake anything for long.)
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by lgeek on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:26PM
(#5527020)
> The way they could take over the network is by crafting a new blockchain, forging fake transactions or even claiming that they own all bitcoins. If they solve blocks faster than the rest of the network, soon their malicious chain would become longer and therefore accepted by all clients! Clients always trust the longest chain because it takes the most work to make, so you would have to control most of the mining power to fake anything for long.
This is incorrect. Having 51% or more of the computing power of the network doesn't allow you to replace the whole blockchain (there are checkpoints, and it gets more difficult as you want to replace a bigger part of it). You also can't forge new transactions, since transactions need to be signed by the sender.
Basically the only practical attack (assuming no serious bugs in the clients) is a double spend: they could pay out of their own wallet a sum X to a third party, the third party checks that the transaction has Y confirmations (remember, as Y grows, it gets more difficult to pull this off), they receive whatever they've bough from the third party, and then they start pushing a different and longer block not including the transaction.
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by apalmer on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:14PM
(#5527367)
Legality is an interesting question. I would guess it would not be illegal to manipulate the bitcoin protocol for personal gains, however any fraud committed would probably be illegal on its own merits.
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by mheathr on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @11:05PM
(#5529737)
ASIC is an implementation of a circuit. They will be the fastest implementation of the logic, however they are the most expensive implementation of that logic by far.
Unlike FPGAs once logic is implemented in an ASIC the implementation is set in stone, so if there is a bug in the hardware fixing it will require producing an additional run and incur the expensive cost again.
The high cost is why FPGAs are popular for both prototyping and production units when possible as it is much cheaper for smaller quantities.
ASIC having exactly the logic necessary to target a task is why they are the most efficient at the task compared to general purpose hardware.
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by makomk on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @12:50PM
(#5526335)
Normally, Bitcoin mining has fairly high variance - you only get paid when you find a block, and because blocks are relatively rare and found at random intervals your income varies a lot too. MtRed were what's known as a PPS pool, which meant they basically ate the variance and paid miners based on the amount of mining work they did.
The trouble is that running a PPS pool requires a huge buffer of your own funds to cover payouts during periods of bad luck, and if the buffer isn't big enough the pool will inevitably go bankrupt. It appears this has now happened to MtRed and it sounds like they only have enough funds to pay out half the money they already owe miners. (Technically, over a long enough period of time PPS pools will go bankrupt with 100% certainty no matter how big the pool buffer.)
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by adamgravitis on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:13PM
(#5526497)
As I've rapidly discovered, trying to calculate aggregate stats over the basis of Poisson arrivals... is a pain. To work out anything interesting, you end up studying piecewise-deterministic markov processes in more detail than you'd wish.
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by makomk on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:01PM
(#5526852)
Adding a fee might have helped if they'd done it from the start, but it's too late now. Sticking with PPS but only paying out when a block was found also wouldn't help; Eligius tried that and as soon as they hit a long period of negative luck everyone stopped mining there and the pool had to be restarted with a different payout method, screwing everyone who'd mined there previously in the process. (That issue with Eligius's payout method was actually predicted well before it actually happened.)
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by palebluedot on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:53PM
(#5526785)
I'm not sure this is true. For example, consider the following scenario at $200 USD per bitcoin: 5 people pooled mining capabilities, and mined a single bitcoin. They could then split that, and effectively pocket $40/ea (or 0.20 bitcoins each). If you mine solo, is it possible to mine a partial bitcoin, rather than increments of a whole bitcoin?
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by jes5199 on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:57PM
(#5527247)
Right: mining produces whole bitcoins, and does it infrequently. That's why pools exist; people weren't willing to wait months to randomly win the bitcoin lottery. (Maybe that's a design flaw!)
Most pools pay proportions of their actual winnings, not their predicted ones.
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by yebyen on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @12:26PM
(#5526146)
A mining pool collects work from miners who are too small to mine on their own. In Bitcoin today, this is basically every miner (other than the bigtime dudes who already got ASICs). Time to complete a block is in the years for GPU miners. Put together hundreds of miners at varying rates and collect their work into a pool, now you can afford to pay small miners something even if their work would not approach a single block in the amount of time that you see them.
A negative buffer means they've been paying per share the going rate per share (however they've calculated that), and not some other way of calculating that avoids negative buffers (say, dynamically calculating the value of the shares based on how many buffers they touched and how much is in the buffer.)
They have missed their projections for too long and they are closing their doors to avoid paying out of pocket, rather than change to a scheme that does not depend so much on the pool's luck.
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by gibybo on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:16PM
(#5526528)
This depends on a lot of factors that change rapidly and are hard to predict. Essentially it will take until 2130 to mine all Bitcoins, regardless of how much electricity/computational power is thrown at it (there are some technical exceptions to this, but they are unlikely).
Current mining is probably using on the order of ~30-50 MW. At 10 cents kw/h (low estimate), that's ~$100k/day. It also grows with the price of Bitcoin, so it has been growing rapidly recently.
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by mikeash on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:24PM
(#5526571)
The difficulty of mining is dynamically adjusted based on the currently available mining capacity so that bitcoins are produced at a constant rate over time no matter what.
In other words, you could mine the full set of bitcoins for virtually no electricity whatsoever if you could convince the world to abandon bitcoin mining completely, then just let a single old, slow, cheap miner run in the corner for the next 100+ years. Or you could use as much electricity as you wanted on the project by throwing more and more computational resources at it.
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by mkr-hn on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:33PM
(#5526638)
So if someone set off a series of EMPs across the planet leaving only a handful of computers functional, the difficulty would adjust downward to account for it?
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by jes5199 on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:03PM
(#5527299)
Sometimes electricity is essentially free. My home is heated by electricity (I live in California) - any watts that I spend mining bitcoins produces the same amount of heat as my electric heater, but has the advantageous side-effect of maybe making money.
(I don't actually do this because I don't have a desktop computer, and it's unclear if building one at this point will pay for itself before custom integrated circuits push the bitcoin difficulty so high that GPUs become worthless)
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by shpxnvz on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:54PM
(#5527660)
Does your home have a heat pump? If so, your house heat pump is 3 to 4 times more efficient than the waste heat produced by your computer, and you are using 3 to 4 times more electricity compared to the same heat output from a heat pump.
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by mikeash on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:25PM
(#5527907)
As the name implies, a heat pump moves heat around. When you heat your house with a heat pump, you're not (just) converting electricity into heat. The electricity is being used to move heat from outside your house into the house. You make the interior of the house warmer while making the exterior (very slightly) colder. It's exactly the same as an air conditioner or refrigerator, just pointed the other way.
Of course, energy has to be expended to move heat around, and there are inefficiencies. But with real-world equipment and common cold-but-not-too-cold temperatures, a single unit of electricity can be used to move several times as much heat as it would produce if you just converted it to heat directly.
A computer is as efficient as anything when it comes to converting electricity to heat. Heat pumps win because they're ultimately playing a different game.
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by shpxnvz on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @10:08PM
(#5529516)
When I lived in Santa Barbara we had a gas furnace. I'm surprised that, given the cost of electricity out there and the moderate temperatures which are nearly ideal for heat pump efficiency, that the financial incentive isn't there to convert even for moderate use.
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by gibybo on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:17PM
(#5526533)
In the average, general case, it is slightly less than the cost of one Bitcoin. Due to the recent volatility it has been a lot less, probably about half at the moment (expect this to increase though).
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by gibybo on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:46PM
(#5526736)
No, it is good evidence that the price is volatile. The cost to mine follows the price of a Bitcoin with a built in 2 week delay. It's just how it was designed.
Re:MtRed Bitcoin mining pool will be shutting down
by gibybo on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:26PM
(#5526583)
On top of the already mentioned fact of indivudal miners switching easily, MtRed was also a comparitively small pool so it had little impact on the network as a whole.
It's sad to see, and a big worry for the future security of the blockchain.
(The way they could take over the network is by crafting a new blockchain, forging fake transactions or even claiming that they own all bitcoins. If they solve blocks faster than the rest of the network, soon their malicious chain would become longer and therefore accepted by all clients! Clients always trust the longest chain because it takes the most work to make, so you would have to control most of the mining power to fake anything for long.)
This is incorrect. Having 51% or more of the computing power of the network doesn't allow you to replace the whole blockchain (there are checkpoints, and it gets more difficult as you want to replace a bigger part of it). You also can't forge new transactions, since transactions need to be signed by the sender.
Basically the only practical attack (assuming no serious bugs in the clients) is a double spend: they could pay out of their own wallet a sum X to a third party, the third party checks that the transaction has Y confirmations (remember, as Y grows, it gets more difficult to pull this off), they receive whatever they've bough from the third party, and then they start pushing a different and longer block not including the transaction.
in the bitcoin context they chips created for the specific purpose of hashing, allowing you to mine for bitcoins quickly and effficiently.
http://cryptojunky.com/blog/2013/02/17/bitcoin-asic-roundup/
Unlike FPGAs once logic is implemented in an ASIC the implementation is set in stone, so if there is a bug in the hardware fixing it will require producing an additional run and incur the expensive cost again.
The high cost is why FPGAs are popular for both prototyping and production units when possible as it is much cheaper for smaller quantities.
ASIC having exactly the logic necessary to target a task is why they are the most efficient at the task compared to general purpose hardware.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Application-specific_integrate...
The trouble is that running a PPS pool requires a huge buffer of your own funds to cover payouts during periods of bad luck, and if the buffer isn't big enough the pool will inevitably go bankrupt. It appears this has now happened to MtRed and it sounds like they only have enough funds to pay out half the money they already owe miners. (Technically, over a long enough period of time PPS pools will go bankrupt with 100% certainty no matter how big the pool buffer.)
What if they only paid out when a block was found?
Then the miners would have no impetus to help them and would instead mine for themselves
A negative buffer means they've been paying per share the going rate per share (however they've calculated that), and not some other way of calculating that avoids negative buffers (say, dynamically calculating the value of the shares based on how many buffers they touched and how much is in the buffer.)
They have missed their projections for too long and they are closing their doors to avoid paying out of pocket, rather than change to a scheme that does not depend so much on the pool's luck.
All profitable miners would be using the most efficient hardware, in a location where electricity is cheapest.
Current mining is probably using on the order of ~30-50 MW. At 10 cents kw/h (low estimate), that's ~$100k/day. It also grows with the price of Bitcoin, so it has been growing rapidly recently.
In other words, you could mine the full set of bitcoins for virtually no electricity whatsoever if you could convince the world to abandon bitcoin mining completely, then just let a single old, slow, cheap miner run in the corner for the next 100+ years. Or you could use as much electricity as you wanted on the project by throwing more and more computational resources at it.
(I don't actually do this because I don't have a desktop computer, and it's unclear if building one at this point will pay for itself before custom integrated circuits push the bitcoin difficulty so high that GPUs become worthless)
Of course, energy has to be expended to move heat around, and there are inefficiencies. But with real-world equipment and common cold-but-not-too-cold temperatures, a single unit of electricity can be used to move several times as much heat as it would produce if you just converted it to heat directly.
A computer is as efficient as anything when it comes to converting electricity to heat. Heat pumps win because they're ultimately playing a different game.
But, thanks for clarifying.