News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by flankk2 on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @07:12AM (#552545)
It has been minutes and I've already found several new songs I absolutely adore.

For me, this is groundbreaking. It's like last.fm done right. I feel the same elation as when I first used Napster.

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by berntb on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @08:10AM (#552582)
I was going to write the same thing.

Quick check. Lots of metal and folk. Some local stuff (Scandinavian). Seems to be little jazz and world (balkan folk, arabic, etc. Had e.g. Natacha Atlas and Susheela Raman.) Problems with Unicode.

Really really good start. Now just needs to add lots more esoteric stuff I can find! (Unicode would be nice.)

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by ashleyw on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @08:13AM (#552586)
http://www.spotify.com/en/

Since using that, iTunes: "Last opened: Thursday, 26 February 2009 11:27"

It just feels like I'm browsing for music on iTunes, and listening to the previews....except the previews are the full songs! It rocks! :)

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by rs on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @10:47AM (#552762)
The problem with spotify is that its only supported on Windows and Mac, and the only way to run it in Linux is via Wine. This is miles better and it just embeds into the browser which is nice.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by jrnkntl on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:04AM (#552785)
And that it is "not available in your country"
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by ropiku on Thursday April 09, 2009 @10:10AM (#554377)
They have released a library (can be used by premium users): http://www.spotify.com/blog/archives/2009/04/07/spotify-open...
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by halo on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @10:54AM (#552772)
If you pay for premium you could also use despotify: http://despotify.se/
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by jpendry on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:06AM (#552790)
for what it's worth, i've been using http://www.lala.com/ more and more, and have come to really enjoy it.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by FalconNL on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @07:30AM (#552552)
Very nice site, thanks.

In case anyone from Grooveshark is reading this, here are two minor UI suggestions:

- It's rather easy to miss the volume control since it's so far removed from the other play controls. Perhaps it would be an idea to move it over there.

- A button to queue up all the songs in a search result. If it exists already I'm not seeing it.

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by josefresco on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @01:59PM (#553102)
Also the "delete from queue" button is tough to get to (being on the right of that pop up div), I'd consider adding it either to the middle of that div, or on the main thumbnail in the queue.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by pavel_lishin on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:23AM (#552814)
It would also be nice to list the song duration in the search results.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by jaytee_clone on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @07:32PM (#553615)
Also, the animation transition going for one tab to the other is cool, but it's too much, it will soon get on people's nerve.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by birdman on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @10:40AM (#552754)
I agree. I had assumed there wasn't a volume control until I read this.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by jrnkntl on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @07:28AM (#552550)
So, how long will this last? :)
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by andreyf on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:10AM (#552796)
http://thefeelgood.com seems to have been around for awhile, and it's full of user-uploaded copyrighted content... so while they'll probably have trouble raising money from VC's, as long as the ad revenue is sustainable, I'd venture to guess "awhile"
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by endtime on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @09:22PM (#553727)
http://playlist.com seems similar, but even links to (external) mp3 downloads, and has also been around a while.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by mapleoin on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @08:16AM (#552589)
Wow, so no one knows about http://deezer.com ? It's been around for years. It's lack of popularity probably stems from the fact that it's French, same as http://jamendo.com (Creative Commons music)
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by vjt on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @08:49AM (#552626)
Jamendo is quite a different beast, because it's a CC label, not a music sharing/streaming medium.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by czstrong on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @07:44AM (#552560)
I like the design and ease of use and it is definitely a site I would use.

The only problem for me, and the thing that it lacks that YouTube doesn't, is music that isn't mainstream and hasn't been released by a label. Songs that make it on mixtapes and other singles that artists use to promote themselves and their future albums don't seem to be available from the searches that I've run. But they are available on YouTube.

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by slackenerny on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @07:51AM (#552566)
You may register an account then, and upload what you see missing.

Just like with YouTube. But with an Java app that would upload folders in batches.

I did so back in september. At the time there was even some scheme in which uploader would get money for uploading popular stuff, but I don't remember any details.

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by samueladam on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @10:59AM (#552778)
EMG ( http://escapemg.com/ , makers of grooveshark) has other nice services like http://tinysong.com/
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by joss82 on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @01:50PM (#553084)
This is, by far, the best music site I've been to. Mostly because of the perfect UI, autoplay and no DRM. deezer.com, musicme.com pale in comparison No flaw detected so far, have you found any ?
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by jhatcom on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:59AM (#552883)
Just curious, isn't that site violating music copyright laws? I would be afraid to use it for fear of getting sued by the labels.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by josefresco on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @01:58PM (#553098)
They only people that would run afoul of the law would be the good folks at Grooveshark. Use it (without worry) while it lasts.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by Markus on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:42AM (#552851)
I'm really impressed by this site. Huge selection of music and a very friendly UI. I like how when you add a song for immediate playback, it prepends it to your queue instead of overwriting your queue.

Facebook Connect / OpenID would be nice. Also, when I signed up with a taken username it gave me an "unexpected error" message, a bit sloppy.

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by redss on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @01:09PM (#553002)
No way to fast forward. :(
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by dc2k08 on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @09:43AM (#552686)
http://www.playlist.com/ which was announced on HN a while back provides this service too. It's worked quite well for me so far and their UI has drastically improved since it launched.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by Markus on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:36AM (#552840)
And it works in Canada!
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by pj on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @12:20PM (#552909)
Man, that sucks almost nothing works in Canada. Hulu doesn't work in Canada. Netflix. But you have some good content on CBC.ca.

Dragon's Den is fun to watch.

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by dhughes on Thursday April 09, 2009 @01:40AM (#553995)
...no Pandora either, guess her box is closed for us in Canada.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by ilamont on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @09:31AM (#552680)
Neat site. I got it to work in IE6 but like an earlier poster think that the volume control should be in a more logical/visible place.

Some of the metadata appears to be messed up, as well. I clicked on what I thought was a Lemonheads album and got Presidents of the United States of America covering "Video Killed The Radio Star" instead.

And the billion-dollar question: How can this possibly be a sustainable business model? Ads for Verizon surely won't cover the development, licensing, and operating expenses for this site, will it?

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by Raphael_Amiard on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @07:58AM (#552574)
I just wonder, what on this site is done in flash that couldn't be done with plain AJAX/Html, appart from the obvious streaming part ?

Just wondering, they may have some reasons

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by vjt on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @08:47AM (#552624)
Actually it uses the flex framework (as you can see by looking at the scrollbars and the tooltips) that then produces an edible binary .swf for the flash player :).

Back to the topic, as a music site developer myself, I can assure you that everything (except streaming[1]) you see on grooveshark can be implemented using XHTML, a JS framework (I love jQuery über alles) and an HTTP backend. Wheter or not do it depends mainly from the target of your audience and the browsers they use, because to achieve 100% browser compatibility, especially when dealing with older IE versions, imposes a bit of headbanging over their quirks and issues. Another point is performance: on older machines, animating big elements on the page (like grooveshark does) causes flicker and a clumsy experience for the user. The last point is maintainability and integration: after all, flash software is another piece of the stack you have to coordinate, implement, integrate and deploy.

So, it's a bit controversial which path to choose; on our project we're following a mix of the two, by reducing the flash implementation to the bare minimum to accomplish streaming, upload (ajax upload via iframe is a bit of a mess) and a set of JS interfaces to implement the rest of the interface via XHTML. Similar to http://playlist.com 's approach.

The last consideration that comes to my mind is purely ethical/political: I prefer to use open standards and contribute back to open projects via source code, and not be forced to use closed technologies and tools and contribute back via cash, having to read clumsy documentation, little opportunity to improve anything, and the list could go on and on.. :).

[1] Luckily this is gonna change with HTML5!

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by Raphael_Amiard on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @01:25PM (#553034)
Thanks for the complete answer !

I found the moving elements on grooveshark to be quite a bit annoying anyway.

Also the database is much less complete than the one of www.deezer.com as of now.

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by ujal on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @07:43AM (#552558)
Use fizy.com as a lightweight/mobile alternative.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by defied on Saturday April 11, 2009 @01:06PM (#557605)
I actually prefer using http://www.hypem.com

Been using that site for months, all the other ones (even grooveshark) lack certain alternative songs which you can find on hypem.

The list with popular songs on hypem is also better, but that might just be my personal taste.

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by ComputerGuru on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @03:39PM (#553290)
I like.

Surprised to find some nice international selections on there; usually have a hard time locating some non-Western music so it's refreshing to find some good World genres out there especially in such high quality and with such a nice, clean interface.

(Y)

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by jonas_b on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @06:52AM (#552531)
Wow, this is amazing stuff. On par with Spotify in ease of use.

After a while it gets a bit too "flashy" though.

Would like to see some social/discussion functionalities.

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by Silentio on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:34PM (#553875)
http://www.seeqpod.com does something similar, though it isn't as well designed.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by dforbin on Thursday April 09, 2009 @12:08AM (#553908)
Rachel likes bacon. I like Rachel. http://grooveshark.com/about
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by xiaoma on Thursday April 09, 2009 @12:49PM (#554674)
Yeah. I've been on Grooveshark for over a year and I love it! The clean interface really makes a difference.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by kp212 on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:10AM (#552797)
Sick, sick, I got some of my lesser known progressive house songs queued up while I work...thanks!
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by cool-RR on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @06:35AM (#552520)
I get an empty page.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by cubicle67 on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @06:44AM (#552529)
Are you using a flash blocker (like I am)? The entire page is flash
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by paul7986 on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @07:30AM (#552551)
May I ask when you run flash blocker what benefits it provides you? Are you able to enjoy Youtube, Hulu and other flash video sites without configuring the plug-in?
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by jws on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @09:34AM (#552681)
I use clicktoflash...

1) It protects me from any security, privacy, and correctness flaws that might exist in the Flash implementation on my computer.

2) It makes my computer snappier by not letting poorly written Flash ads eat my CPU, RAM, and battery.

3) It keeps the blinky flashy ads to a minimum while I read content.

It is one click on the content area to load and run a flash, so if I go to a web site and really want to see the flash content that isn't too high a price to pay. (modifier click to white list).

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by ciupicri on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @08:38AM (#552614)
I think that those sites are in a white list.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by CalmQuiet on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @07:06AM (#552539)
Thank you for the explanation.

Life is too short for Flash pages (without graceful alt's degrading to html).

Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by randallsquared on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @09:34AM (#552683)
Alternatively, perhaps your bandwidth is too low. :) If "takes too long" is your actual objection, then a music streaming site is probably not something your connection could handle easily anyway.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by CalmQuiet on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @10:51AM (#552770)
Well, slowness is part of my issue. But both flash and slowness are fundamental usability issues. Anyone ought to be able to visit a landing page and quickly see some indication of what the site is about - and at least be informed in the case that disabling of flash or of javascript is preventing proper functioning.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by randallsquared on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:21AM (#552807)
I agree that that would be ideal, but I don't know whether it's worth doing the extra work for people who have flash disabled but who could possibly be convinced to turn it on. I think that they might assume that all seven of you together aren't worth the additional advertising revenue. :) I haven't even visited the site yet, so I dunno if they actually have ads.
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by cool-RR on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @08:37AM (#552613)
No I'm not
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by randomtask on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @07:22AM (#552546)
I was. Thanks!
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by Oxryly on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @08:01PM (#553661)
Awesome!
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by keltecp11 on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @09:53AM (#552704)
Kinda reminds me of Mixturtle... but this is AWESOME!
Re:Just in case anyone is still using YouTube for music by josefresco on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @01:57PM (#553096)
Blog link doesn't work, just opens a new window and loads the main GS page.