News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by lutusp on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:25AM (#5524250)
> I guess the point is less about the fusion method being efficient (and getting past break-even) but more about propulsion.

But "break-even" means yielding more energy than is required to start the reaction. Obviously anything less than break-even is not worth having -- a chemical rocket would be more efficient.

> Their aim is to move a heavy object with as little fuel as possible not necessarily produce perfect fusion.

This misses the point that present laboratory fusion reactions require more power than they release. It's not a question of "perfect fusion" but any fusion that has a net positive energy yield.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by rbanffy on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @08:32AM (#5524671)
> Obviously anything less than break-even is not worth having

No. Not at all. We are talking propulsion, using fusion reactions to pass on energy to the propellant and convert that into thrust. Although it would be desirable, it's not required to make it a net-positive reaction - just giving the propellant more energy than a chemical reaction is enough to be more efficient than a chemical rocket.

As the article mentioned, you can power this rocket with an ISS worth of solar panels (which is quite a lot of mass). Or, as it didn't mention, a very small fission reactor (provided you could negotiate putting a 200 KW reactor in space).

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by lutusp on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @12:00PM (#5525934)
>> Obviously anything less than break-even is not worth having

> No. Not at all.

Yes -- if the fusion reactor didn't achieve break-even, the designers would be better off using an ion thruster. Also, the NASA documents that describe the project assume that break-even must be achieved:

http://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/niac/2012_phaseII...

Quote: "an in-depth analysis of the rocket design and spacecraft integration as well as mission architectures enabled by the FDR need to be performed. Fulfilling these three elements form the major tasks to be completed in the proposed Phase II study. A subscale, laboratory liner compression test facility will be assembled with sufficient liner kinetic energy (~ 0.5 MJ) to reach fusion breakeven conditions."

They are talking about doing away with the present lines of fusion research, which haven't achieved break-even, and using a different method. But they don't suggest that this, or some variation, might be used for conventional power generation.

> Although it would be desirable, it's not required to make it a net-positive reaction

Yes, it is -- that is required. Were this not true, the designers would be better off using an ion thruster, which already exists and is quite efficient.

> As the article mentioned, you can power this rocket with an ISS worth of solar panels ...

Yes, that's in the description, but the power available (200KW near earth, 100KW near Mars) is not enough to propel the relatively heavy craft to the mission profile (i.e. 30 days to Mars) without some other source of energy, like from a net fusion power gain > 1.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by schiffern on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:17PM (#5526957)
A rocket only needs to achieve thermal break-even. A power plant needs to achieve electrical break-even, which includes the unavoidable loss from converting the heat to electricity in a heat engine.

In this way a system can be simultaneously useful for space travel but useless for power generation.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by lutusp on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:30PM (#5527938)
> A rocket only needs to achieve thermal break-even. A power plant needs to achieve electrical break-even ...

Yes, all true. But if a fusion reactor ever achieved break-even, that would be such a breakthrough that the specifics would be reduced to footnotes, and both thermal and electrical applications would soon follow.

> In this way a system can be simultaneously useful for space travel but useless for power generation.

My point is that if break-even were to be achieved, it would be break-even for both applications. The reason is that the plasma conditions for fusion break-even would have much more in common in the two cases than the differences.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by mchouza on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @09:54AM (#5525128)
If fusion doesn't provide a substantial energy gain, it's not worth the effort. Existing ion thrusters are quite efficient (60+%) at translating electrical power to exhaust kinetic energy.
Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by rbanffy on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @11:40AM (#5525785)
Indeed, but they offer very low thrust. For manned space travel, you may need something that can give you a higher acceleration, even if at the expense of efficiency.

Also, fusion reactors designed for power generation have very different goals than fusion rockets. With power generation, particles leaving the reactor may be considered wasted energy. With rockets, the whole idea is to have particles leaving the reactor in a certain direction taking as much energy as possible with them. You just point the jet at the direction opposite to the one you want to go.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by mchouza on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @12:27PM (#5526156)
Well, controlled fusion hasn't reached energy breakeven at all, even taking into account the kinetic energy of the reaction products. But the low thrust of current ion engines is mostly due to power restrictions (https://groups.google.com/group/sci.space.science/msg/0cb332...). If your spaceship has a mass of one ton and you want an acceleration of 1 centigee with an exhaust velocity of 30 km/s, you will need at least:

0.5 * thrust * velocity = 0.5 * (0.1 m/s^2 * 1000 kg) * 30 km/s = 0.5 * 100 N * 3E4 m/s = 150E4 W = 1.5 MW

of power.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by skew on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @11:57AM (#5525913)
"kinetic energy" means nothing alone, thrust and specific impulse are better metrics to look at. Doing a lot better than ion thrusters at either without being too much worse in the other and energy efficiency would be interesting.

However, the article quotes an exhaust velocity of 30km/s (or ISP of 3000s), and using 200kW doesn't leave much room to beat http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiPEP on thrust without counting on net energy gain. The linked slides also claim net energy gain.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by mchouza on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @12:44PM (#5526279)
Yes, I agree. My point was that you cannot do substantially better than ion engines without having energy gain and, in fact, you are probably going to do much worse due to the weight of the "fusion hardware".

I'm quite optimistic about magnetized inertial fusion. But the idea of doing the job much better than the Z-machine, with something lightweight enough to carry into space and in less than 10 years seems to me... unlikely, to put it mildly.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by schiffern on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:21PM (#5526979)
>in fact, you are probably going to do much worse due to the weight of the "fusion hardware".

Ion engines have weight, too. What leads you to believe that the fusion hardware will be heavier?

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by mchouza on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:25PM (#5527466)
In the short run:

- Ion thrusters are way simpler and they are trying to do something that is much easier.

- Ion thrusters are relatively mature, working "fusors" don't exist.

- Existing machines that are trying to get fusion breakeven are building-sized.

- Trying to start a fusion reaction is hard, it only makes sense if you get a commensurate result (energy gain).

In the long run, I'm very optimistic about fusion.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by outworlder on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @11:58AM (#5525916)
Ion drives are highly efficient, but have ridiculously low thrust. Which doesn't help at all when you are trying to reach some point quickly.

If you can construct an ion drive with enough thrust to match this proposed fusion drive (or even a NERVA: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_thermal_rocket), talk to NASA, I am sure they will be interested in buying several from you.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by ars on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:02PM (#5526429)
> Which doesn't help at all when you are trying to reach some point quickly.

Sure it does. You just leave it turned on. This thruster assumes 6 days of thrust then 24 days of coasting. With an ion thruster you leave it on for all 30 days.

There are no high thrust systems that can just be left on - even nuclear ones are used for a short period then turned off. The idea of an ion thruster is that you leave them on, and achieve the same total thrust, over the same time.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by vectorjohn on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @11:33PM (#5529820)
> With an ion thruster you leave it on for all 30 days.

With a thrust of - at best - 5 newtons, you won't achieve the goal of getting to Mars faster. You may get there cheaper and using less fuel, but for pure speed you lose. Ion thrusters are good for very long trips when you're going to leave the engine on for months, or for trips where the total time doesn't matter much, only fuel economy (e.g. for cargo shipments or probes).

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by ars on Thursday April 11, 2013 @12:25AM (#5529983)
5 newtons won't get you there in 1 month, but according to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VASIMR it will in 5 months which is still pretty good, and much better than a standard rocket.
Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by Filligree on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @11:44AM (#5525814)
If you don't mind waiting a year.

Existing ion thrusters don't give enough thrust to get to Mars in 30 days.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by emp_zealoth on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @09:27AM (#5524964)
You are completely missing a point of this. It is a propulsion system, not a power generating one. Chemical rocket engine doesn't generate any electrical power either. Main factors in propulsion is specific impulse and reaction mass and this idea promises a huge impulse - basically once in orbit, it could ferry between Earth and anywhere-where-solar-power-is-sufficient because it doesn't need tonnes of fuel, only relatively small load of pellets would get the job done. Of course there is the issue of getting it and it's payload into orbit, but I'd say Skylon will take care of that
Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by lutusp on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @12:05PM (#5525971)
> You are completely missing a point of this. It is a propulsion system, not a power generating one.

To represent an advantage over an ion thruster, it must be both. And the NASA documents that describe the project specify a fusion power gain > 1:

http://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/niac/2012_phaseII...

Quote: "an in-depth analysis of the rocket design and spacecraft integration as well as mission architectures enabled by the FDR need to be performed. Fulfilling these three elements form the major tasks to be completed in the proposed Phase II study. A subscale, laboratory liner compression test facility will be assembled with sufficient liner kinetic energy (~ 0.5 MJ) to reach fusion breakeven conditions."

The phrase "fusion breakeven conditions" means the reaction must produce more power than is requires to start it. This is a requirement to justify the project over other approaches.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by emp_zealoth on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @12:53PM (#5526355)
It is not even supposed to be used to generate electrical power. Citing from the site itself: "Virtually all of the radiant, neutron and particle energy from the plasma is absorbed by the encapsulating, metal blanket thereby isolating the spacecraft from the fusion process and eliminating the need for large radiator mass"

No radiators implicitly mean no electricity generation, because it creates waste heat that has to be utilised.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusion_rocket

Proposed concept is a direct drive, and it actually claims they fixed the problem with neutrons (they are caught by the compressing metal)

As for breakeven conditions they merely state that the power that the fusion generates must be at least equal to power used to start/sustain it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusion_energy_gain_factor Theoretical limits of efficiency of heat engine is around 70-80% (roughly) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_efficiency and you have to use those to convert heat generated in controlled fusion into electricity. To actually achieve net power generation in a power plant, you have to generate a lot more heat that electricity, while for propulsion you merely care about actual raw (so to speak) power.

Ion thrusters have their own issues, while their ISP is considerably better than chemical rockets, maximum thrust is abysmal, but it is hard to argue about that due to the lack of data on FDR. However, with ion thrusters there are other issues (for example:wear, charge imbalance)

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by lutusp on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:40PM (#5527556)
> As for breakeven conditions they merely state that the power that the fusion generates must be at least equal to power used to start/sustain it.

Yes, but (apart from stars and weapons) this has never been achieved anywhere, ever. This is a big issue, bigger than most people realize.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusion_power

Quote: "As of July 2010, the largest experiment by means of magnetic confinement has been the Joint European Torus (JET). In 1997, JET produced a peak of 16.1 megawatts (21,600 hp) of fusion power (65% of input power) ... Fusion powered electricity generation was initially believed to be readily achievable, as fission power had been. However, the extreme requirements for continuous reactions and plasma containment led to projections being extended by several decades. In 2010, more than 60 years after the first attempts, commercial power production was still believed to be unlikely before 2050."

My point is if this project creates a net gain > 1, it will address a lot more than the problem of getting to Mars.

Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by acomar on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @12:47PM (#5526306)
As other posters have noted, ion thrusters don't generate very much thrust.
Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by schiffern on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:26PM (#5527018)
s/Skylon/SpaceX/
Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by vectorjohn on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @11:41PM (#5529844)
That's what I was thinking. They're actually already doing something. On the other hand, their not-yet-developed Falcon Heavy can "only" lift 53 tons, about a third of the weight of FDR. Hopefully they can come up with a way to lift it in stages, or we still need a bigger rocket.
Re:NASA-backed fusion engine could cut Mars trip down to 30 ... by ceejayoz on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:14AM (#5524401)
> Obviously anything less than break-even is not worth having -- a chemical rocket would be more efficient.

Why not? The energy to start the reactor comes from solar power, so they didn't have to carry it up with them.