If something comes up in class, on the other hand, it's generally okay to address it in class, since it was already raised in that venue; you can scold a student who creates a disruption in class. But forwarding an email that was sent specifically to you (not to a class listserv) to the entire class is a bit different.
Not if, as in this case, the student's identity is concealed. In such a case, it becomes as valid an instructional element as a psychological case history (where the subject's identity is always concealed).
Yes, that's increasingly true as time passes. Freud's case histories were marked with the subject's real initials, and this practice continued up to the 1950s. I'm not excusing, just explaining.
Even in modern times, very detailed case histories are published as long as there's no credible risk of associating the study with a particular individual, or consent is obtained from someone able to give informed consent.
I'm speaking about the general issue of a potential libel action and invasion of privacy, not specifically about FERPA.
"Arriving Late, Leaving Early, Coming & Going
"Students are expected to arrive to class on time and stay to the end of the class period.
"Arriving late or leaving class early will have impact on the course grade.
"Students may enter class late only if given permission by the instructor and can do so without disrupting the class.
"(Note that instructors are not obliged to admit late students or readmit students who leave class or may choose to admit them only at specific times.)"
http://www.stern.nyu.edu/AcademicAffairs/Policies/GeneralPol...
Not at the beginning of the school semester, when what is and is not tolerated is more likely to create an indelible impression. The professor's behavior had a point -- to mark unacceptable behavior as such, in a way that everyone would get the message.
> Also, how likely is this to be BS?
That's always a risk in online postings. But even if it's fictional, it rings true.
Looks like people still contact him about it.
Presumably, it was a much ruder interruption to the class to stop everything and publicly humiliate a student whom he felt disrespected by. And it's extremely rude to take a personal email and forward it to the entire class (who presumably would be able to recognize the student).
Maybe the intent was to "smack some sense" into a student for their own benefit, but that's really presuming a lot about a person from a handful of data points.
Also, how likely is this to be BS?