News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Professor Tells Student to “get your shit together” by lutusp on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @06:49PM (#5521968)
> In the U.S., it's arguably a FERPA violation to do so.

Not if, as in this case, the student's identity is concealed. In such a case, it becomes as valid an instructional element as a psychological case history (where the subject's identity is always concealed).

Re:Professor Tells Student to “get your shit together” by mjn on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @06:56PM (#5522017)
It's true that psychological case histories are published, but much more carefully. You need to make a formal proposal to an independent review board, which will assess your proposed anonymization protocol and the circumstances of data collection and disclosure. The bar is particularly high if you're asking to release a case study where you don't have documentation of the subject's consent (even for anonymized case studies).
Re:Professor Tells Student to “get your shit together” by lutusp on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @07:22PM (#5522141)
> It's true that psychological case histories are published, but much more carefully.

Yes, that's increasingly true as time passes. Freud's case histories were marked with the subject's real initials, and this practice continued up to the 1950s. I'm not excusing, just explaining.

Even in modern times, very detailed case histories are published as long as there's no credible risk of associating the study with a particular individual, or consent is obtained from someone able to give informed consent.

Re:Professor Tells Student to “get your shit together” by FireBeyond on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @12:58PM (#5526405)
While I agree with the subject of the response, I disagree with your interpretation of FERPA. Any student who was in that class would have a clear, unambiguous knowledge of the student's identity, and mere 'xxx'ing of the name is a cursory, even illusory attempt at maintaining privacy.
Re:Professor Tells Student to “get your shit together” by lutusp on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:40PM (#5528006)
Yes, true but from the standpoint of the public, the professor's action was well-advised. A claim of libel would require that the student's identity become public knowledge, something the obfuscation prevented.

I'm speaking about the general issue of a potential libel action and invasion of privacy, not specifically about FERPA.