News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by untog on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @10:29AM (#5518251)
I agree with your sentiment but I'm actually kind of conflicted.

Inspecting into his marriage feels dirty and indeed, tabloid. But if we want to get the full picture of entrepreneurial life, we can't ignore personal life. If you want to be the next Elon Musk it is probably worth noting that his marriage failed- if nothing else, just to remind you that even when you're a billionaire it is very difficult to have it all.

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by travisp on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @10:44AM (#5518375)
But, relationships are very personal and private. It is very difficult to know enough details about the people involved and their relationship with one another to draw any real conclusions from the simple failure of a relationship.
Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by vanderZwan on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @10:49AM (#5518415)
> But, relationships are very personal and private.

I'm not going to disagree on this being a private issue, but if we're talking about why billionaires do not share Elon Musk's personality, doesn't it make perfect sense to discuss things like this?

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by travisp on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @10:59AM (#5518490)
I don't mean private in the sense that we shouldn't discuss them, I mean private in the sense that the actual details of the relationship occur in private and that we don't know them.

It is very hard to judge a relationship from the outside because a lot of what goes on in a relationship is private: private conversations and communication, the way a person expresses love or likes to be shown that they are loved, the way romantic conflicts are handled, what initially attracted a couple to each other, minor quirks and eccentricities, pet peeves, sexual compatibility, changes in personality and values, and so on.

I don't think we really know most of these things about Elon Musk's marriage, and I would be hesitant to draw broad conclusions without them.

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by jlgreco on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @11:23AM (#5518714)
A failed marriage is not exactly rare. You may as well attempt to "discuss" the fact that he married in the first place.
Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by lutusp on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @11:56AM (#5518973)
> Inspecting into his marriage feels dirty and indeed, tabloid. But if we want to get the full picture of entrepreneurial life, we can't ignore personal life.

On the contrary, you can, and you should. The era when a man or a woman is defined by his relationships and family is over, and good riddance. People shouldn't be pressured into a family lifestyle if they don't feel a motivation in that direction.

Can you tell me the names of Einstein's children? No? How about two-time Nobel Prizewinner Marie Curie? Ironically, on Curie's Wikipedia page, her children (two) are only mentioned in passing -- they just weren't important enough to include in her list of noteworthy lifetime accomplishments:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marie_Curie

And if we accept the idea that children are an option, not a requirement, guess who benefits the most? Children, of course. The children who are brought into existence without social pressure can feel assurance they they were planned, not mistakes.

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by jordan0day on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:52PM (#5519375)
> People shouldn't be pressured into a family lifestyle if they don't feel a motivation in that direction.

Agreed. But what does that have to do with this discussion? Are you saying that Elon Musk only got married/had children because he was pressured into it? And now that he is divorced and apparently doesn't see his kids much (as the article states, I really have no idea), well, all the better for him, because maybe he never wanted any of that to begin with?

If you don't want to get married, or if you don't want to have children, that's awesome. You'll be free to devote more of your time to your work or hobbies. If that's what you find most fulfilling in life, then that's what you should do.

Once you do have children, and to a lesser extent (in today's world, at least) get married, you've now made promises that you ought to keep. I'm not sure where your "children are an option, not a requirement" tangent is coming from -- surely not from anything I read in the article or comments here. Unless, again, you're arguing that somehow Elon Musk was required to have children?!

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by lutusp on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @01:05PM (#5519457)
> Are you saying that Elon Musk only got married/had children because he was pressured into it?

I have no idea. My only point is that's a common problem in modern times. It's unfortunate, it disproportionately hurts women in their careers, and it is slowly changing for the better.

> Unless, again, you're arguing that somehow Elon Musk was required to have children?!

To the young, something may seem a requirement that to a more mature person is obviously just a choice. And intelligence seems not to play a large part in that age distinction.

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by untog on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:29PM (#5519192)
I wouldn't dispute that Musk will go down in history as an entrepreneur and not a father. That's not the point.

The point is that when you show Musk as an inspiration for entrepreneurship, you should look at his whole life- because being a serial entrepreneur absolutely has an effect on your personal life.

The title of the story is "Why is there only one Elon Musk"- there are many, connected answers. His personal life is part of that. Just because it doesn't define him doesn't mean it isn't relevant.

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by lutusp on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @01:12PM (#5519507)
> The point is that when you show Musk as an inspiration for entrepreneurship, you should look at his whole life- because being a serial entrepreneur absolutely has an effect on your personal life.

Think about what you're saying. I hope by now you are aware that women rightly object to this kind of mixing of the personal and professional, and that to refer to a woman's personal and relationship choices in connection with her professional standing is an obvious and much-lamented kind of sexism.

> Just because it doesn't define him doesn't mean it isn't relevant.

Do avoid saying this about a woman, about, say, Marissa Mayer, present CEO at Yahoo. Her personal and professional lives are rightly evaluated separately.

When you listen to Musk's interviews, what strikes you is the degree to which his accomplishments and his value system are strongly connected -- that what he accomplishes has everything to do with his approach to problem solving, and nothing to do with his relationships.

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by untog on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @04:22PM (#5521056)
Do avoid saying this about a woman, about, say, Marissa Mayer, present CEO at Yahoo. Her personal and professional lives are rightly evaluated separately.

They aren't, though. When she announced the "no remote working rule" she was criticised for having babycare facilities next to her office, allowing her to care for her child at work. And it was a valid criticism- she was subjecting her employees to conditions that she insulated herself from.

If you are evaluating a person as a whole (which the article is), you can't ignore their personal life without also losing a lot of important context.

Think about what you're saying. I hope by now you are aware that women rightly object to this kind of mixing of the personal and professional

I think they object to being unfairly singled out on that basis, not that people shouldn't ever take someone's personal life into account in general.

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by sigzero on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:02PM (#5519017)
> he era when a man or a woman is defined by his relationships and family is over, and good riddance.

No it's not. Those things help to define a person. I don't think you entirely got the nuance that the OP was getting at.

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by lutusp on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:17PM (#5519132)
>> he era when a man or a woman is defined by his relationships and family is over, and good riddance.

> No it's not. Those things help to define a person.

When you try to refute someone's position, it's expected that you will offer a counterargument, not a different topic. Yes, relationships help define a person. No, that doesn't mean the era hasn't ended in which one's relationships are central to one's identity.

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by milkshakes on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:46PM (#5519327)
Sure, I'll bite. You argue that family is no longer important (or, 'optional', in your words) because Wikipedia does not elevate the status of, or obsess over the details of the family of a notable person in the same fashion. This is a ridiculous argument [1]. Who cares what Wikipedia thinks? Who cares what google thinks? Who cares what society thinks? A relationship is a very personal connection between two people. Perhaps it doesn't translate well to Wikipedia, but it's absurd to assert that they're not worth having just because they're not preserved for all eternity.

[1] https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/appeal-to-authority

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by Pwnguinz on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @01:09PM (#5519483)
> Who cares what society thinks?

You are making the same fallacy that your parent post accused another poster of making, you're failing to address to argument at hand.

Eras are defined by society at large (as much retroactively defined by future generations as defined by the present). Disregarding what society thinks refutes your entire argument. Two people caring about a certain thing is an anecdote, not an era.

Note that he never said "relationships are not worth having", merely that "The era when a man or a woman is defined by his relationships and family is over".

Your GGP's post's conclusion holds, even if what you are saying is true.

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by lutusp on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @01:17PM (#5519531)
> You argue that family is no longer important ...

I never said that. I recommend that you argue against my positions, not yours.

> This is a ridiculous argument ...

Yes, it is -- and it is your argument, not mine.

Your argument goes downhill from there, relying on the much-revered but meaningless "who cares?" meme.

> ... it's absurd to assert that they're not worth having just because they're not preserved for all eternity.

Yes -- good thing that I didn't make that argument, only you did.

My advice is to try to stick to the content of the other person's post, rather than make something up to conveniently argue against.

Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by joshuahedlund on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @10:47AM (#5518398)
True, but couldn't Bill Gates be a counterexample?
Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by untog on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @11:04AM (#5518529)
Perhaps. But I'd argue they are very different entrepreneurs- Bill Gates was successful young and stuck with his original success. Musk has darted all over the place looking for further successes. That must have an effect on your life stability.
Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by coob on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @11:12AM (#5518617)
Why stop at his personal life? Would you like to look at his medical records too?
Re:Why is there only one Elon Musk? by sigzero on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:01PM (#5519004)
Didn't people really really want to do that with Jobs?