So what you compare when a language happens to have multiple implementations?
Which from 6g, gogcc, go express you pick for Go?
Which from OpenJDK, Oracle JVM, IBM J9, gcj, RoboVM, Aonix Perc ... you pick for Java?
Which from Sun Forte, IBM xlc, hpcc, gcc, clang, CINT, Visual C++, ... you pick for C or C++?
Which from CPython, IronPython, PyPy, JPython, ... you pick for Python?
Re:Playing with Go1.1beta2, it's much faster
by coldtea on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @11:20AM
(#5518684)
That's easy. Except for C++, which is a multi-vendor language.
For all others there is a definitive, used in the overwhelming majority of cases, implementation:
Go: 6g Java: Oracle JVM Python: CPython Ruby: Matz's Haskell: GHC ...
Except that in many cases, e.g. Python, the canonical implementation is not the fastest one.
So of course, the presenter will carefully select the best implementation to prove his arguments, even if there are others available that contradict him/her.
Ideally, yes. But in practice a language and its implementation (whichever one you choose) is a tool. If you're comparing tools, you've got to compare a language with its implementation.