News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Playing with Go1.1beta2, it's much faster by pjmlp on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @03:58AM (#5516935)
> I also find that HN in general is very quick to downvote comments critical of Go, even well reasoned ones with sources.

I am sure if Go wasn't being done at Google, most hackers would actually ignore it.

Just check how successful the Go like predecessors from the authors were, when working at other companies.

I think the language suffers from an hallo effect.

Re:Playing with Go1.1beta2, it's much faster by enneff on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @04:14AM (#5516968)
If anything, I think that Go has received a disproportionate amount of criticism and skepticism because it was developed at Google. Go is very mature these days - way more mature than most languages ever get - and that's the result of hard work by the contributors, not its pedigree.
Re:Playing with Go1.1beta2, it's much faster by trailfox on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @05:11AM (#5517080)
I've seen posts where "it's from Google" is cited as sufficient explanation for taking an interest in the language. If Go was a random project on GitHub there is very little chance that I would have given it a second look, let alone learning it (which I am presently doing). I have great respect for projects which start out as random GitHub projects and succeed without having the advantage of a name like Google to give them street cred.

Most of the negative Go posts I've seen are to do with limitations of the language and performance relative to JVM languages. As much as I think go has a lot going for it I'm not about to claim that it's anywhere near as expressive as Python or even Scala. There has also been some frustration about denials over the performance gap between Go and the JVM despite very clear data in favor of the JVM. I'm not as bothered by the performance gap as I am about the head-in-the-sand denials. The JVM's have been optimized for 15+ years, so it's ok to admit it may be a few more years before performance can match the JVM.

Re:Playing with Go1.1beta2, it's much faster by enneff on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @05:17AM (#5517097)
> I've seen posts where "it's from Google" is cited as sufficient explanation for taking an interest

That might be enough to draw interest, but what sustains that interest is the quality of the work and the utility of the environment.

> If Go was a random project on GitHub

Where it's hosted is irrelevant. It's about the work. Plenty of active, popular projects are hosted on GitHub. Some of them were just "random projects on GitHub" when they started. What distinguishes them is that there are motivated groups of people working on them.

Re:Playing with Go1.1beta2, it's much faster by sigzero on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @08:14AM (#5517564)
> That might be enough to draw interest

That is pretty much the zinger. If Google hadn't been involved, Go probably wouldn't be were it is at all.

Re:Playing with Go1.1beta2, it's much faster by pjmlp on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @04:38AM (#5517015)
And yet it throws out the window quite a few modern language features.
Re:Playing with Go1.1beta2, it's much faster by iand on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @04:49AM (#5517037)
Which is to be congratulated. If only more languages were as coherent rather than attempting to cater for every possible constituency.

Makes it easier to decide whether Go is the right language choice for the problem at hand. Quite often it won't be and that's fine.

Re:Playing with Go1.1beta2, it's much faster by enneff on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @05:16AM (#5517092)
Re:Playing with Go1.1beta2, it's much faster by ansible on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @03:08PM (#5520394)
I am sure if Go wasn't being done at Google, most hackers would actually ignore it.

I would hope that we hackers would pay at least some attention to any project involving Ken Thompson and Rob Pike though.