Re:Bitcoin Is Fundamentally Flawed
by Houshalter on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:34AM
(#5516459)
>Now as currencies are supposed to be used as a medium of exchange to facilitate transactions, spending is really important because it’s how the market participants interact with one and other (and considering Bitcoin isn’t backed by a commodity this is important). Once people are reluctant to spend then, the economy will stay depressed because, people expect deflation AND deflation will continue because the economy remains depressed.
People not spending money is generally a good thing. There are more resources to go around for everyone else and other people can afford more things with the same amount of money. Most people who save money invest it, which benefits the economy in the long term.
>In order for an economy to get out of the deflationary trap and to counter deflation, fiat currencies can use monetary policy to increase the money supply and deliberately induce rising prices, causing inflation.
This hurts everyone though. Everyone has the same amount of money they did before, but suddenly everything costs more. No wealth is actually created by doing this, the same amount of goods are in the economy. But the person who gets the printed money buys a bunch of them, and then has a larger share of the pie, leaving everyone else with less.
Yes bitcoin has a mechanism for creating new currency, but this was a necessary evil in order to distribute the first bitcoins relatively fairly. It doesn't actually benefit anyone to give free bitcoins to some people just for running their computers a lot.
People not spending money is generally a good thing. There are more resources to go around for everyone else and other people can afford more things with the same amount of money. Most people who save money invest it, which benefits the economy in the long term.
>In order for an economy to get out of the deflationary trap and to counter deflation, fiat currencies can use monetary policy to increase the money supply and deliberately induce rising prices, causing inflation.
This hurts everyone though. Everyone has the same amount of money they did before, but suddenly everything costs more. No wealth is actually created by doing this, the same amount of goods are in the economy. But the person who gets the printed money buys a bunch of them, and then has a larger share of the pie, leaving everyone else with less.
Yes bitcoin has a mechanism for creating new currency, but this was a necessary evil in order to distribute the first bitcoins relatively fairly. It doesn't actually benefit anyone to give free bitcoins to some people just for running their computers a lot.