Hoodie is more of a tool for applications, with user authentication etc, so SEO is not relevant here. I wouldn't build a public website with Hoodie.
> Also, something else that really trouble me with javascript client-side is that, often, when something bugs, everything just stop working
Yes. That's something we have to handle if we want dynamic web apps build on web technologies. But there are great tools today that help you 1. prevent JavaScript by automated testing in all the browsers / OS 2. track JavaScript errors, e.g. with errorception. And 3. todays browsers are more relaxed about errors, they try to continue running the app, even if one function errored out.
> Is there a better solution than a hard-refresh? Would a first-level try/catch solve this problem
If you can keep the state of an app and store user's data immediately, there is no big problem to reload the page, I do that in several occasions at minutes.io, the user usually doesn't realize, it's very fast.
the web is no longer just text. if you need to consume text then you need a text-api client, which is what web browsers used to be.
"the web is no longer just text"
Although I can't deny that statement,I find it hard to convince myself that browsers can't read your page because no JS engines are running. I see it a little bit like emails.. yes, more recent clients give you a better interface or better features, but if I'm emailing someone who has a very old phone with very basic email support, I'm hoping that this person would still be able to read my message.
I'd love to see what would happen if HN turned JS-enabled only for a day.
I kinda resent being expected to run your pile of arbitrary code just to render static text and images on my screen—something that worked just fine without JS twenty years ago.
The SEO issue is a stronger argument but Googlebot now seems to be executing javascript in some cases so even that might cease to be an issue.
Also, something else that really trouble me with javascript client-side is that, often, when something bugs, everything just stop working. I.e. links don't work anymore, button obviously don't.. Is there a better solution than a hard-refresh? Would a first-level try/catch solve this problem?
Thanks!