News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by gav on Sunday April 07, 2013 @10:32PM (#5509698)
Patent 7,620,565 is a good example of everything that's wrong with the patent system; it's vague and generic, nothing novel, and seemingly far reaching.

They are using claim 15 to sue over interactive chat: "A method, comprising: monitoring a product for an occurrence in the product of a trigger event of a predefined plurality of trigger events; incrementing a counter corresponding to the trigger event upon detection of the occurrence of the trigger event in the product; displaying a user interface, configured to probe for information regarding a use of the product, if the counter exceeds a threshold; storing an input received from the user interface on a device; and transmitting the input to a server. "

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by melling on Sunday April 07, 2013 @10:56PM (#5509753)
I think there are tens of thousands of examples like this, with thousands more being added every year.

Now everyone wants to know how to solve the problem. If every developer needs to get a patent lawyer, it's going to be a big problem.

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by bdavisx on Sunday April 07, 2013 @11:17PM (#5509821)
Not for the patent lawyers.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by Wingman4l7 on Sunday April 07, 2013 @11:16PM (#5509814)
"[...] incrementing a counter corresponding to the trigger event upon detection of the occurrence of the trigger event in the product [...]"? Sounds like a website hit counter from the '90s.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by sageikosa on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:35AM (#5511548)
Sounds like a trip odometer or a turnstile.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by fpp on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:55AM (#5510831)
In former times (when patents mostly covered only machinery) you had to present a working prototype or product that demonstrated your invention.

My suggested solution to the current software patent disaster:

Inventors have to demonstrate a solution (in source code and running) that covers "ALL" the claims. Earlier inventions, e.g. those from the last 17 years, that have not provided this by means of ending up in a product during this period are automatically revoked / declared invalid. Inventors can appeal against this (at cost increasing the older the patent is). Demonstrations within appeals are only possible with technology available at the date of filing.

This will automatically revoke all the fantasy patents (I call them Jules Verne Patents), bring sense back into patent filing - particularly when "pure front-end" patents are disqualified, and will help to protect us from the 1999/2000 patent litigation tsunami some are already expecting.

(Reg: 1999/2000 patent litigation tsunami - this could be caused by all those start-up companies that filed patents within the 1999/2000 bubble and then went belly-up - many of those patents might soon end up in patent troll litigation portfolios.)

Update: And patents should only be enforceable by practising entities vs. PAEs along the lines / to mitigate the issues that Google, Blackberry, Red Hat and Earthlink have outlined in their letter to the DOJ last Friday ( https://docs.google.com/file/d/0BwxyRPFduTN2VTE4TXlNcW9MR2s/... )

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by solarexplorer on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:18AM (#5510883)
This won't help against overly generic patents. And those cause most damage...
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by fpp on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:30AM (#5510917)
Why not?
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by solarexplorer on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:37AM (#5510932)
Well, a troll can present a prototype and still make overly broad claims.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by kunai on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:15AM (#5510516)
Just like Wikipedia has notability guidelines, there's no reason patents should not.

Problem is, the legislation to cover vague and broad patents may very well end up being vague and broad itself, unfortunately.

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by podperson on Monday April 08, 2013 @08:30AM (#5511271)
Yes and there are no ridiculous articles in Wikipedia.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by shmerl on Sunday April 07, 2013 @11:23PM (#5509837)
Can't a prior art be found for this?
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by Tuna-Fish on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:15AM (#5510090)
Yes. However, invalidating patents via prior art takes long, and is quite expensive. Which is precisely why Lodsys is targeting the people they are -- if they tried to go after any of the big guys, they'd lose their patents. The small guys can't fight back.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by fakeer on Monday April 08, 2013 @02:26AM (#5510257)
Even the big guys can't fight back with prior-art pitch. History says this.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by shmerl on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:18AM (#5510383)
Can't or don't want to? Newegg fought and won. It's surprising that many of those who actually have enough resources to fight chicken out.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by talmand on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:52AM (#5512011)
It's not that they always chicken out, sometimes it's just cheaper to not fight. Which often is the strategy in these types of lawsuits, make an offer to settle that's less than the cost of litigation. This has gotten so bad lately that many letters are simply bold, in-your-face threats of extortion that for some unknown reason the courts have done little to address.

Plus, for some of the bigger companies you say chicken out, this is a potential winning strategy for them to stifle competition. The big companies have the funds to just settle and move on while the small companies that might pose a threat in the future may have a harder time dealing with even just a simple settlement.

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by shmerl on Monday April 08, 2013 @11:37AM (#5512349)
> for some of the bigger companies you say chicken out, this is a potential winning strategy for them to stifle competition.

I'd guess those must be the same sort of companies who engage in patent aggression themselves.

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by thomholwerda on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:05AM (#5510692)
The cold and harsh truth nobody is willing to put out there: if Apple and Microsoft may abuse vague software patents, why shouldn't Lodsys?

Monkey see, monkey do. You are either against software patents, or you're not. You can't cherry-pick the companies you like and excuse them for abusing software patents. Lodsys is nothing but an exponent of a broken system large companies themselves created and are now sustaining.

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by raganwald on Monday April 08, 2013 @07:35AM (#5511084)
I think you're making an interesting argument about bias amongst us, but the support you give is unpersuasive.

It comes down to a difference between a non-performing entity and a business. Apple and Microsoft employ people to attempt to develop novel solutions to real problems for the purposes of creating products. Trolls do not.

Now, this does not excuse Apple or Microsoft for BS patents. And that's a good discussion to have. But it isn't "monkey see, monkey do."

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by ScottBurson on Monday April 08, 2013 @02:05PM (#5513396)
I think the non-performing entity argument is a red herring. As long as patents exist at all, patent rights will be salable.

Rather, I think the problem is that the vast majority of these patents fail to cross the obviousness bar and should never have been granted at all. I mean, seriously, a patent on sending a fax by email, when lots of things are already being sent by email? Give me a fucking break!

I think the fundamental problem is this. A patent is a deal we, the people of the US, make with an inventor: add significantly to the sum total of our technical knowledge, and in exchange, we'll give you a time-limited monopoly on the technique you invented. The problem is that there isn't anyone unambiguously charged with making sure this is a good deal for us: that the knowledge we're getting is worth the price we're paying. It's technically the PTO's responsibility, and they do make some effort, but the incentives given patent examiners don't encourage them to be hard-nosed about it.

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by reader5000 on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:10AM (#5511422)
Apple and Microsoft do not try to extort petty cash from small developers (at least not by way of patents, amirite?). Outside of that, I don't think HN has ever been congratulatory of their patent shenanigans either (perhaps except when they have to eat their own BS).
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by talmand on Monday April 08, 2013 @10:46AM (#5511964)
So, it's not the behavior but the target?
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by reader5000 on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:35AM (#5509994)
Here's a basic solution to this general problem:

To succeed on a patent infringement claim, the plaintiff must prove a causal link between his patent and the defendant's technology. That is, the plaintiff must prove that the defendant either (1) reverse engineered technology covered by the patent or (2) directly relied on the patent itself in creating the infringing technology.

In other words, independent invention should be protected. If I get a vague patent that could arguably be construed as covering in-app purchasing, and ten years later you, in no way directly or indirectly relying on my patent, implement an in-app purchasing system, I should not be able to recover any money from you, since I in no way assisted your technology. I just happened to have gotten lucky in that I secured a patent with vague language that could be construed to cover a basic piece of tech that 10 years later became popular.

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by Wingman4l7 on Monday April 08, 2013 @02:33AM (#5510268)
"[...] I secured a patent with vague language that could be construed to cover a basic piece of tech that 10 years later became popular."

The simpler version of this is "make/do something with the tech your patent is for within X years, or you lose it."

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by beedogs on Monday April 08, 2013 @12:08AM (#5509939)
Would the world really lose anything of value if a daisy-cutter were to be dropped right above Lodsys headquarters?
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by nickolai on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:53AM (#5510465)
a daisy-cutter. they're 30k a pop.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by neya on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:18AM (#5510524)
Asses who run companies like Lodsys who survive upon the blood of hard working developers sucking them like a leech should be humiliated in public and sent to prison for the rest of their lives. I really feel sorry for these developers..First, they owe the government their blood (taxes) and now these bastards. God saveth this country!
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by PAULHANNA84 on Sunday April 07, 2013 @11:16PM (#5509815)
Patenting inevitable software functionality is just soo odd to me. It's awful that companies like Soverain software who obtained shopping cart patents were able to go after companies such as Amazon and settle because the cost of battling simply wasn't worth it. To say one cannot have an online shopping cart is as crazy as saying "You can't have a cash register in your brick and mortar store."
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by shmerl on Sunday April 07, 2013 @11:25PM (#5509840)
Be glad they didn't claim they own a patent on wheels.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by PAULHANNA84 on Sunday April 07, 2013 @11:32PM (#5509855)
lol, what's funny is as I was commenting I thought the same thing "An APPARATUS that contains no more than 18 wheels and no less than 2." and at the gas pump we would see fuel tax and a patent tax! lol

Quote frankly I'm getting sick of the work apparatus!

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by TallboyOne on Sunday April 07, 2013 @11:50PM (#5509897)
Theres a new post about patent trolls every other day. This makes me so fucking mad, can't they do anything about this??

Couldn't they pass some kind of legislation that says you can't have a shit shell company thats 40 companies deep or.. anything...

Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by coldcode on Sunday April 07, 2013 @10:39PM (#5509710)
It's about time that someone prendalyzes these folks. Surely there is something about them that can be counter-trolled until these vanish.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by fnayr on Sunday April 07, 2013 @10:17PM (#5509666)
Oh boy. Glad to dodge them so far. Hoping to continue.
Re:Patent troll Lodsys sues 10 mobile game makers, despite A... by fnayr on Sunday April 07, 2013 @10:40PM (#5509714)
Lodsys now downvote trolling.