Re:Redesigning the Save Symbol
by krapp on Friday April 05, 2013 @07:51PM
(#5501781)
Icons representing 'obsolete' technology work as ideograms because the form factor of that old technology was unique enough to express a concept in a few pixels, whereas everything now is just some form of a nondescript box which chances are does multiple things. I ran into this problem a couple of years ago when I had to design a television graphic for my company... you know how difficult it is to convey "television" without rabbit ears? I wanted to add them just because that said "this is a tv."
Icons don't have to keep up with the actual technology whose function they represent... they just have to be immediately recognizable.
Re:Redesigning the Save Symbol
by TrevorJ on Friday April 05, 2013 @11:27PM
(#5502519)
This is a good point - we've moved to a place where function no longer needs to dictate form to the same extent that it once did. A cassette tape was shaped the way it was in order to fulfill specific mechanical requirements.
Icons don't have to keep up with the actual technology whose function they represent... they just have to be immediately recognizable.