News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Redesigning the Save Symbol by bitwize on Friday April 05, 2013 @07:10PM (#5501618)
A "phone" these days is usually, more or less, a small box with one glowy side. Yet these self-same devices, to represent "phone", use the silhouette of the handset from an old Bell Telephone landline model, thirty years after those phones went out of fashion. To even the younger generation, that shape means "phone", even if it doesn't look like a phone.

Similarly, the D-pad from a NES controller -- or worse, an Atari 2600 joystick -- is often used to represent or signify "video games".

"Home" is based on tract housing from the 1950s; yet even if home to you is an apartment, condo unit, palace, or boat, that icon still means "home".

There's another example. I just recently bought a Moleskine with an abstract graphic image of an audiocassette on it. There's no real reason for this; it's very hipster. It's sort of "celebrating the audiocassette" because to an entire generation of people, the cassette -- and its shape -- meant music (especially music on the go, like in a Walkman). Youngsters connect to it too, in a "retro" way. The same will be true of the floppy disk icon. No one uses it now, but it was ubiquitous that -- like the audiocassette or the distinctively shaped horn of a Victrola phonograph -- its shape has become semi-permanently associated in our culture with its intended use.

Re:Redesigning the Save Symbol by krapp on Friday April 05, 2013 @07:51PM (#5501781)
Icons representing 'obsolete' technology work as ideograms because the form factor of that old technology was unique enough to express a concept in a few pixels, whereas everything now is just some form of a nondescript box which chances are does multiple things. I ran into this problem a couple of years ago when I had to design a television graphic for my company... you know how difficult it is to convey "television" without rabbit ears? I wanted to add them just because that said "this is a tv."

Icons don't have to keep up with the actual technology whose function they represent... they just have to be immediately recognizable.

Re:Redesigning the Save Symbol by TrevorJ on Friday April 05, 2013 @11:27PM (#5502519)
This is a good point - we've moved to a place where function no longer needs to dictate form to the same extent that it once did. A cassette tape was shaped the way it was in order to fulfill specific mechanical requirements.
Re:Redesigning the Save Symbol by apendleton on Friday April 05, 2013 @07:45PM (#5501756)
Yes, I completely agree. Having the icon be a floppy disk is only weird during this transitional period when there are software users that regularly used floppy disks and now recognize them as antiquated. Most of the youngest generation of current computer users have probably never seen a floppy disk, so for them, that symbol (like the phone) just means "save," rather than being a representation of an actual thing. Eventually it will probably become more stylized and less recognizable, as people forget what it originally meant.
Re:Redesigning the Save Symbol by nfg on Friday April 05, 2013 @07:29PM (#5501684)
Even the word “phone” is interesting, I have a feeling people will continue to apply it to increasingly advanced portable personal technologies far into the future.
Re:Redesigning the Save Symbol by thatthatis on Friday April 05, 2013 @07:56PM (#5501798)
Last week on the front page of reddit: "I was cleaning up my office today and I found a bunch of 'Save' buttons" -- http://i.imgur.com/0R9EUmx.jpg

http://sl.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/1b22bl/i_was_cleaning_...