News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are Bitcoins The Future? by dragonwriter on Friday April 05, 2013 @11:07AM (#5498849)
> You may think that deflation and hoarding is bad. However people are drawn to it.

People are drawn to lots of things which are destructive. (Theft, rape, etc.) So what?

> Fortunately, you can't tell people what to do and where to store their money.

You actually can, and, more usefully, you can adopt a social convention in which the generally accepted "money" isn't particularly attractive to hoard.

> Thus, a currency that allows hoarding will always be more attractive to people than the one which doesn't.

Well, to people who are ignorant of its harms or who maliciously seek to cause them, sure.

> Soon enough people will learn that there is no deflationary spiral. They will also learn that currency can be both deflationary and move around.

A deflationary currency (if it was the only one around) might still move around in exchange, especially for necessary consumables, but it creates a disincentive for investment, because the appreciation of the value of the currency makes it compete with investment vehicles, which encourages hoarding over investment -- and the more hoarding that occurs, the faster the money supply shrinks and the faster the exchange value of the currency rises, increasing the incentive to hoard. Its a classical positive feedback loop, which inevitably lasts until the currency is reformed in such a way that removes the deflationary features (impossible with BTC), external social/legal factors are imposed which limit hoarding, or until it is displaced as a currency and reverts to its commodity value (which, for BTC, is zero.)

There are no comments on this comment yet.