Those who by and large run the world right now sit on their laurels letting their money (albeit, in "risky" investments rather than a box growing in value) make them even richer. While their money might be productive, they more or less aren't contributing anything else, and they do it in self-interest.
I'm not trying to argue for deflation, and I do think the design of BTC as a finite monetary supply is fundamentally flawed, but deflation and inflation respectively benefit someone - deflation those who hoard, and inflation economic growth. But both depend on people who have the money in the first place.
Yeah, but you can't. BTC is deflationary because of built-in supply constraints. Its trivially obvious that you can't expect a fixed salary in it unless you have a shrinking pool of employed people.
> If the employer adjusts down, your net buying power doesn't decrease if prices adjust to increased value of money.
If the employer adjust down at or slower than the pace of deflation, your buying power doesn't decrease, just as it doesn't with an inflationary currency if your employer adjusts up at or above the pace of inflation.
Of course, if your employer is paying you in Bitcoins, they need to get them from somewhere, and with a deflationary currency which encourages hoarding and discourages both spending and investment, good luck with your employer having much success with that.
> Those who by and large run the world right now sit on their laurels letting their money (albeit, in "risky" investments rather than a box growing in value) make them even richer.
Investments aren't money, they are things purchased with money.
> While their money might be productive, they more or less aren't contributing anything else, and they do it in self-interest.
Right, currencies managed to be mildly inflationary harness the self-interest of the rich to produce diffuse benefits (which, unfortunately, are often counteracted by things outside the currency system itself, but that's a different issue), while currencies designed to be deflationary harness the self-interest of the rich to produce diffuse harms (which, unfortunately, are often aggravated by the same things outside of the currency system that mitigate the benefits of inflationary currencies.)
I find it very common even here on HN that many people fall for this fallacy that money == value.
As a result anyone with enough old money can parasitise on productive society forever, to the nth generation. And instead of doing so by (at the very least) stimulating the economy through investment, they can do it just by sitting on their mattress full of cash.
Again, why would I participate in an economy where my hard work is of direct benefit to people just sitting on cash?
It's only when money are invested then you have a surplus of things in the economy which deflates the money. By investing, hoarders allow others not-yet-rich people access to capital. Thus, if hoarders want to become richer they will have to make rich others too.
Does it though? I thought we were all addicted to growth? If we continue to have any growth then with a limited cash supply, each unit becomes worth more (deflation).
"By investing, hoarders allow others not-yet-rich people access to capital."
I'm not clear on how you think this works, because (AFAICT) hoarding BTC is just holding on to currency, not any sort of investment?
" Thus, if hoarders want to become richer they will have to make rich others too."
Or they can just sit on it while others do the work and achieve much the same with no risk...
It's a tricky circle, but once you understand it, it all becomes clear.
Every day I would have to work harder or be paid less, all the while my economic output would be increasing the wealth of those who are unproductive but happen to possess currency. No thanks.