News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by justin_vanw on Thursday April 04, 2013 @10:04PM (#5496453)
Well, if the author kindof hasn't seen it, I guess I should ignore this stuff:

Boehm, Barry W., and Philip N. Papaccio. 1988. "Understanding and Controlling Software Costs." IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering SE-14, no. 10 (October): 1462-77.

Boehm, Barry, 1981. Software Engineering Economics, Boston, Mass.: Addison Wesley, 1981.

Boehm, Barry, et al, 2000. Software Cost Estimation with Cocomo II, Boston, Mass.: Addison Wesley, 2000.

Boehm, Barry W., T. E. Gray, and T. Seewaldt. 1984. "Prototyping Versus Specifying: A Multiproject Experiment." IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering SE-10, no. 3 (May): 290-303. Also in Jones 1986b.

Card, David N. 1987. "A Software Technology Evaluation Program." Information and Software Technology 29, no. 6 (July/August): 291-300.

Curtis, Bill. 1981. "Substantiating Programmer Variability." Proceedings of the IEEE 69, no. 7: 846.

Curtis, Bill, et al. 1986. "Software Psychology: The Need for an Interdisciplinary Program." Proceedings of the IEEE 74, no. 8: 1092-1106.

DeMarco, Tom, and Timothy Lister. 1985. "Programmer Performance and the Effects of the Workplace." Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Software Engineering. Washington, D.C.: IEEE Computer Society Press, 268-72.

DeMarco, Tom and Timothy Lister, 1999. Peopleware: Productive Projects and Teams, 2d Ed. New York: Dorset House, 1999.

Mills, Harlan D. 1983. Software Productivity. Boston, Mass.: Little, Brown.

Sackman, H., W.J. Erikson, and E. E. Grant. 1968. "Exploratory Experimental Studies Comparing Online and Offline Programming Performance." Communications of the ACM 11, no. 1 (January): 3-11.

Sheil, B. A. 1981. “The Psychological Study of Programming,” Computing Surveys, Vol. 13. No. 1, March 1981.

Valett, J., and F. E. McGarry. 1989. "A Summary of Software Measurement Experiences in the Software Engineering Laboratory." Journal of Systems and Software 9, no. 2 (February): 137-48.

(References from http://www.construx.com/10x_Software_Development/Origins_of_...)

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by jdlshore on Friday April 05, 2013 @03:57AM (#5497234)
Have you read those references? Or are you just quoting them blindly?

Laurent Bossavit has read them, and he reports that they are, for the most part, reporting on each other and on anecdotes. There is no actual, scientific evidence for the "10x programmer." He writes up his search for the evidence in his book "The Leprechauns of Software Development." It's a fascinating look at how a supposedly-rational group of people has taken a myth and blown up into well-known "fact."

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by igouy on Friday April 05, 2013 @10:40AM (#5498677)
Have you read those references? Or are you just quoting Laurent Bossavit blindly?
Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by jdlshore on Friday April 05, 2013 @04:46PM (#5500946)
I've read and understood the reference I've provided (Bossavit), and I've also read and understood the reference justin_vanw provided (McConnell), so no, I'm not quoting Bossavit blindly.

After reading both, I found Bossavit much more convincing. In addition to meticulously following the chains of references back to the original research, Bossavit also examines how science is done and what is required in order for a claim to become established scientific fact. His conclusion is that the evidence for the 10x claim is "quite weak."

Here's my summary of his material from the last time this came up ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4118034 ). There's much more to Bossavit's research than my quotes here, so if you disagree, please read and rebut his work directly, not just these quotes.

"How strong is the support conferred to the 10x claim by the best-reputed list of references, for a reader persistent enough to follow the chain of citations back to primary sources?

"Based on our close reading of the “10x files”, we can now answer: quite weak.

"Not a single one of the references is to a replication, in the scientific sense of the term, of the original exploratory experiment.

"The empirical data is in general quite old, most if not all of it predating widespread use of the Internet - which we can safely expect to have wrought major changes in programming practice.

"None of the studies address the question of construct validity, that is, how meaningful it is to speak of an individual programmer’s productivity, and if it is meaningful, whether the experimental measurements line up adequately with that meaning." [1]

[1] The Leprechauns of Software Engineering explores what science is and how we distinguish between fact and folklore in software engineering. It specifically explores the 10x claim, and determines that it's folklore. http://leanpub.com/leprechauns

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by igouy on Saturday April 06, 2013 @08:12AM (#5503358)
> There's much more to Bossavit's research than my quotes here, so if you disagree, please read and rebut his work directly, not just these quotes.

Please provide a copy of Bossavit's research.

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by jdlshore on Sunday April 07, 2013 @02:16AM (#5506281)
I was using "research" in the colloquial sense, not in the "research paper" sense. Bossavit researched the 10x claims (thoroughly and meticulously) and wrote up his findings in the book I mentioned. You can find it here: http://leanpub.com/leprechauns

It's an impressive work of scholarship; many of the citations he followed were out of print, expensive, or referring to unnamed parts of 300-page books. Luckily for us, Bossavit's write-up is engaging and accessible.

It isn't free, but it's trivially inexpensive (US$5-10) if you care about this subject. Far cheaper than the source material.

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by igouy on Monday April 08, 2013 @01:13PM (#5513002)
> It isn't free

And isn't available in any of the linked libraries available to me.

And I already had a long email discussion with Laurent back in 2011, about his comments on Steve McConnell's blog.

If I may make a suggestion, when the source material is likely to be unavailable, it might be better to quote the reasons given rather than the conclusions -- then we can try to follow the reasoning rather than having to take someone's conclusions at face value.

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by jdlshore on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:52PM (#5514514)
I don't understand what you're getting at here. Laurent's book (written after McConnell's blog) is available at http://leanpub.com/leprechauns . If you're unable or unwilling to figure that out, I suspect you're not really trying.

You're engaging in an asymmetric attack here--posting trivial statements that avoid the substance of my comments, but require me to do a lot of work to satisfy you. I've replied to your comments in good faith. Now the onus is on you.

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by igouy on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:53PM (#5514889)
Unwilling to pay the $5.

> You're engaging in an asymmetric attack here <

I wasn't engaging in any kind-of attack, just making a suggestion.

You said -- "if you disagree, please read and rebut his work directly, not just these quotes" -- so, as I haven't read the book, I haven't tried to rebut those quotes.

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by igouy on Friday April 05, 2013 @08:45PM (#5502007)
> so no, I'm not quoting Bossavit blindly

As far as McConnell; as for the other references, aren't you taking Bossavit's claims on trust?

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by jqjester on Saturday April 06, 2013 @12:09PM (#5503983)
Steve McConnell himself doesn't dispute Bossavit's claims about the earlier studies (for the most part), he just disagrees about the significance of those claims. See McConnell's rebuttal in which he acknowledges the methodological weaknesses of the citations: http://www.construx.com/10x_Software_Development/Origins_of_... .
Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by igouy on Saturday April 06, 2013 @06:05PM (#5505223)
What specifically are you pointing to within that blog post and comment stream? (Let's make sure I look at exactly what you mean me to see.)
Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by jqjester on Sunday April 07, 2013 @07:04AM (#5506790)
Sure - I'm pointing to the section titled "A Deeper Dive into the Research Supporting '10x'".

I'm accepting one of Bossavit's claims on trust: he says that of McConnell's eight citations in support of the 10x claim, only two were original research based on empirical studies under controlled conditions (and of those two one only concerned debugging).

I'm willing to trust that because it looks like McConnell mostly agrees. For example, regarding the 1986 Curtis paper, McConnell writes "Bossavit states that, “the 1986 Curtis article does not report on an empirical study.” I never stated that Curtis 1986 was an 'empirical study.'" Regarding DeMarco and Lister, he says "Editorial insinuations aside, that is a correct description of what DeMarco and Lister reported, both in the paper I cited and in Peopleware. Their 1985 study had some of the methodological limitations Sheil’s discussed in 1981".

They disagree about what counts as evidence supporting the 10x claim, but apart from the Card 1987 citation (about which Bassavit was wrong), McConnell confirms Bossavit's claims about every citation.

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by igouy on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @01:20PM (#5519559)
> Regarding DeMarco and Lister...

After the words you quote, McConnell goes on to say -- "Having said that, their study supports the 10x claim in spades and is not subject to many of the more common methodological weaknesses present in other software engineering studies."

After the words you quote, McConnell goes on to say -- "Bossavit should have looked at the paper I cited, not the book. The paper shows a 5.6x difference between the best and worst programmers—among the programmers who finished the assignment. About 10% of the programmers weren’t able to complete the assignment at all."

I don't see how that can be described as McConnell mostly agrees?

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by jqjester on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:10PM (#5527333)
I was originally responding to the challenge "aren't you taking Bossavit's claims on trust?"

I'm differentiating between Bossavit's claims about the citations from Bossavit's analysis and arguments. I have to take his claims about the articles and books on trust, because I haven't read them. On the other hand, I don't have to trust his analysis and arguments - I can evaluate those on my own.

In the case of DeMarco and Lister, for example, Bossavit writes "the only 'studies' reported on therein are the programming contests organized by the authors, which took place under loosely controlled conditions (participants were to tackle the exercises at their workplace and concurrently with their work as professional programmers)"

That's the only claim that I have to trust here. Everything else is analysis. McConnell agrees with that description of the citation, but disagrees that it invalidates DeMarco and Lister's research. He thinks that a programming contest that took place under loosely controlled conditions is a legitimate research study.

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by igouy on Thursday April 11, 2013 @02:51PM (#5533929)
To check my understanding of your response, let me reduce it to caricature:

B claims the article is not printed on blue paper, and we have to take that claim on trust because we haven't seen it.

M agrees with that description of the article, but disagrees that not printed on blue paper invalidates its status as evidence.

We can decide for ourselves whether we think not printed on blue paper invalidates its status as evidence.

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by jqjester on Thursday April 11, 2013 @05:01PM (#5534767)
That sounds fair.
Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by igouy on Thursday April 11, 2013 @07:28PM (#5535560)
So presumably you'd characterise --

"I am claiming that for whatever reasons he is here dressing up, in the trappings of scientific discourse, what is in fact an unsupported assertion meshing well with his favored opinion. McConnell is abusing the mechanism of scientific citation to lend authority to a claim which derives it only from a couple studies which can be at best described as “exploratory” (and at worst, maybe, as “discredited”)."

-- as Bossavit's "analysis and arguments" which you can evaluate for yourself.

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by igouy on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:57PM (#5515270)
I've just read through the McConnell post and the comment stream, and your comment that "McConnell confirms Bossavit's claims about every citation" baffles me :-)

"Curtis 1986. ... Bossavit says the paper “offers no support for the ‘10x’ claim.” But the first paragraph in section II.A. of the paper (p. 1093) summarizes 4 studies with the overall gist of the studies being that there are very large differences in productivity among programmers. The specific numbers cited are 28:1 and 23:1 differences."

I don't see how that can be described as McConnell confirming Bossavit's claims?

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by jqjester on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:43PM (#5527581)
Again, McConnell isn't disagreeing with Bossavit's claims about the Curtis 1986 citation. He concurs! "I never stated that Curtis 1986 was an 'empirical study.' Curtis 1986 is a broad paper that touches on, among other things, differences in programmer productivity. "

The difference is that McConnell thinks that summarizing four studies "offers support for the 10x claim" and Bossavit does not. That's a matter of analysis & evidentiary standards.

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by papsosouid on Friday April 05, 2013 @11:46AM (#5499105)
What are you talking about? You should read those references. Just download peopleware for fuck's sake, rather than regurgitating bullshit. There is strong evidence that the most productive programmers are 10x as productive as the least productive programmers.
Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by jdlshore on Friday April 05, 2013 @01:28PM (#5499763)
I've read Peopleware. Your mention of it is another example of the uncritical citation of references that Bossavit talks about in his book.

Peopleware isn't a scientific study. It's a collection of essays and opinions by two authors I have a great deal of respect for. The closest it gets to science is an un-sourced discussion of DeMarco and Lister's "Coding War Games." In that discussion, it specifically says that differences in productivity (which were less than 10x) were likely due to workplace factors, not individual productivity.

People constantly say that there's "strong evidence" supporting the 10x productivity, but no one ever quotes a scientific study that provides this evidence. At best, people list references, often without reading or understanding them--as you did with Peopleware.

There could well be a 10x difference in productivity, but gut feel and testosterone-fueled claims aren't the same as science.

(It's no surprise that there's no science backing the claim. In order to show evidence for a 10x difference in programmer productivity, you'd first have to define "programmer productivity" and come up with an unbiased measure of it. And that's surprisingly difficult, as some of the discussions in this thread have shown.)

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by papsosouid on Friday April 05, 2013 @01:43PM (#5499857)
>Your reference of it is another example of the uncritical waving of references that Bossavit talks about in his book.

He says, while uncritically waving a single reference that has no backing evidence. You seriously don't see your hypocrisy here?

>Peopleware isn't a scientific study

Duh? That is why it contains citations, to the studies the authors conducted. You sure did a poor job of reading it if you are actually that ignorant.

>In that discussion, it specifically says that differences in productivity (which were less than 10x) were likely due to workplace factors, not individual productivity.

No, they were 10x. That is precisely what it says. And why do you suggest workplace factors being part of the difference makes the difference not exist? I don't even understand how you can say something that absurd and not realize it.

>There could well be a 10x difference in productivity, but gut feel and testosterone-fueled claims aren't the same as science.

Ok, I'll just take your ignorance-fueled gut feel claim as proof that all the scientific evidence doesn't exist.

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by gruseom on Saturday April 06, 2013 @05:13PM (#5505083)
Whoa there. You are being way too rude and aggressive about this. Please help keep HN civil; that's much more important than any argument.

Peopleware is a classic, or at least many software professionals regard it that way, but it is a classic of folklore rather than science. Here is an example that I asked one of the authors about years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/edit?id=1995716.

The research literature itself on these matters is extremely flimsy. There is not even any empirical evidence for the stuff we all agree on, such as that version control is good (http://www.neverworkintheory.org/?p=451) let alone on the controversial points such as productivity. Incidentally, how do you measure productivity?

I'd be happy to be wrong about this, though. Perhaps you could cite a study or two that really does hold up to scrutiny?

Re:There are no 10x developers, but there are 1/10 ones by papsosouid on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:23AM (#5511488)
Perhaps if you don't like the dozens of studies, you could offer a critical response to them rather than ignoring their existence no matter how often they are pointed to?