News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by badgar on Thursday April 04, 2013 @06:36PM (#5495736)
I don't think we should be too surprised with how FB will use the new data. I'm just wondering who Facebook is going to share this data with.

I know a guy who works at one of Facebook's "partner companies" that pays gobs for FB user data. This partner company gets (as far as they can tell) fully-populated user data in Facebook's user dumps - way, way more information than they need or ask for. So the partner company puts this data through arduous preprocessing steps to filter out most of the details before any user data hits real systems. They're scared of the legal liability of holding onto all the personal details they receive don't need but Facebook shares anyway because Facebook genuinely doesn't care as long as they're monetizing.

So yeah, I'm scared of where this new data is going to go. Not what FB uses it for themselves.

Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by monkeynotes on Thursday April 04, 2013 @06:52PM (#5495810)
I deleted my FB account when they IPO'd as I could then plainly see that the only worth in the company was user data and it would certainly be monetised as much as possible.

But 'deleting' an account probably doesn't do much more than remove the data from the immediate web services. My data has probably been sold to multiple 3rd parties by now.

Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by HarrisonFisk on Thursday April 04, 2013 @11:32PM (#5496646)
When you delete your account, the data is actually removed. As part of the recent privacy audit, the Irish DPC reviewed the account deletion framework and verified that it does indeed work:

http://www.dataprotection.ie/docs/21-09-12--Facebook-Ireland... (section 2.10 - page 41)

Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by badgar on Thursday April 04, 2013 @06:59PM (#5495841)
> But 'deleting' an account probably doesn't do much more than remove the data from the immediate web services.

If you think they delete the data at all from anywhere you're out of your mind. Records are tombstoned, moved to cold(er) storage for efficiency and then not displayed. Certainly not deleted.

Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by HarrisonFisk on Thursday April 04, 2013 @11:17PM (#5496612)
Facebook does not sell user data regardless of what you may have heard.

See: https://www.facebook.com/help/152637448140583/

Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by zdrtx on Thursday April 04, 2013 @09:26PM (#5496336)
Facebook doesn't sell user data.
Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by badgar on Thursday April 04, 2013 @09:40PM (#5496373)
Yes, yes it does. You'll need to refine your brief assertion to make it correct. It's all anonymized of course, but Facebook absolutely has many commercial agreements to share its user data with partner companies. A common part of these agreements, for example, is for the partner companies to also share their user data with Facebook.
Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by kmavm on Thursday April 04, 2013 @11:30PM (#5496641)
I've worked at Facebook for four years. No, no we don't, no matter what the "guy you know" says. Harrison already provided you with our very strongly worded, official claims to that effect.

Since you're the one claiming otherwise, how about an actual, verifiable example? "Company X paid Facebook $Y for user data Z" doesn't sound like an unreasonably specific request.

Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by badgar on Friday April 05, 2013 @07:56PM (#5501797)
I see. Money must not be explicitly trading hands in these commercial data-sharing agreements, because you're very serious about that one detail (and nothing else). I obviously don't have insight into these commercial data-sharing contracts - actually, you do. So I'll assume I'm wrong about dollars being exchanged directly.

But I'm not wrong that data is shared liberally and unnecessarily in these data-sharing agreements, which was actually the point. And I'm not wrong that those agreements are commercial in nature with Facebook receiving something in return. Or are you saying Facebook's data-sharing agreement system is a giant charity program. So I'm still okay with calling commercial data-sharing agreements "selling user data."

Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by jetru on Thursday April 04, 2013 @07:54PM (#5496048)
> They're scared of the legal liability of holding onto all the personal details they receive don't need but Facebook shares anyway because Facebook genuinely doesn't care as long as they're monetizing.

I find it odd that Facebook isn't scared of the same legal liability. Infact, they should be more scared. I don't see any reason why Facebook would give away more information than they need to. They have the skill and resources to filter data themselves. I highly doubt that they would throw away personal and sensitive to other companies.

Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by badgar on Thursday April 04, 2013 @09:35PM (#5496357)
> I find it odd that Facebook isn't scared of the same legal liability. Infact, they should be more scared.

You don't understand how partnerships work in this case. Facebook is paid to provide data according to a contract between the two companies. That's it. They have many, many such contracts to fulfill with many partners. These contracts don't say "we provide exactly the data you ask for, no more, no less" because that is a lot, lot more work and at the end of the day the contracts still get signed and FB still gets paid. A lot. Where do you see legal liability for FB so far? Their terms of service fully permit this data sharing, and the contracts are just between FB and partner companies.

Meanwhile, the partner companies use the shared data to produce value-added products which they provide to their customers under existing contracts and policies. They can't violate their customer's privacy or rights under any of the existing such policies, which are not identical to FB's. In fact, depending on the industry of the partner company, these policies can be extremely different. It is up to the partner company - not Facebook - to comply with the partner company's contracts/policies.

> I don't see any reason why Facebook would give away more information than they need to.

Facebook doesn't see any reason why they should waste time withholding more data than they need to. They still get paid the same amount, and the partner companies just filter out what they don't want. What's the point? There isn't even a big long-term concern here for Facebook, since extra social data isn't exactly very useful years later.

> They have the skill and resources to filter data themselves.

You say that, but every large technology company has to prioritize what they use engineering manpower for. Not everything a company can do or wants to do ends up getting done. For example, you might say "Facebook has the skill and resources to delete data from their CDN. I highly doubt they would throw away money on byte stored in Akamai" and yet they didn't do so for years and probably still don't. And that's a far easier problem with real measurable costs. Compare that to filtering the same enormous data set differently for each partner company when there's no compelling business reason to do so. The contracts are still going to be signed and Facebook will still get paid. Why should anyone care?

> I highly doubt that they would throw away personal and sensitive to other companies.

This is something FB is doing and have been doing for years. So your doubts are baseless.

Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by trhtrsh on Friday April 05, 2013 @01:00AM (#5496869)
If this were true, you could make a fortune on a class action law suit against Facebook's breaches of their TOS.
Re:Facebook Home destroys any notion of privacy by duck on Thursday April 04, 2013 @09:19PM (#5496313)
I'm just wondering who Facebook is going to share this data with.

I think you answered your own question with: pays gobs