News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:O'Reilly on Morozov by danso on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @07:58PM (#5490097)
> Also, what Morozov fears is quite reasonable, if you look at the history of government regimes that have murdered and forcibly relocated their citizens in the name of productivity and (yes) openness.

Really? What regimes have murdered in the name of openness? And let's not mistake what regimes claim to do with what they actually do. China's Great Leap Forward waved equality as a banner, yet I don't see the resulting horrific famine as being a reason to roll back civic rights in America

Edit:

I read this passage a couple but cannot figure out what it means -- the OP is describing how open source arose from the free software movement:

> The problem was that companies could sell free software, but they weren't always happy about the public mucking around in their code and changing it. So O'Reilly helped a group of entrepreneurs come up with the alternative term "open source" software, which described a bunch of different licenses that people could use to release software in ways that free software would not allow. You might say that open source allowed companies to release code that was partly open, but partly closed.

O'Reilly already weighed in pretty effectively...but the OP must be referring to something that happened in reality...right? Was there a company that got into open-source because it was tired of how the public could just go "mucking" about in their code base without reservation? What does that even mean?

Re:O'Reilly on Morozov by molecule on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @09:08PM (#5490353)
> Was there a company that got into open-source because it was tired of how the public could just go "mucking" about in their code base without reservation? What does that even mean?

Well, there's Red Hat w/ their Enterprise Linux distributions, and Apple w/ the FreeBSD-derived iOS and OSX. You can't fork and distribute either of those products without incurring the wrath of their respective owners' very diligent lawyers.

Re:O'Reilly on Morozov by leohutson on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @09:55PM (#5490500)
Really? I have seen plenty of RHEL "forks", CentOS, Scientific Linux to name a few.

Apple's OSX isn't open source in any sense, sure it has components based on liberally licensed open source code, but so does almost every other proprietary software product.

Re:O'Reilly on Morozov by semisight on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @10:01PM (#5490509)
Why can't you distribute them? Apple's Darwin is mostly under the APSL, which you can edit and distribute, just not under a different license. Likewise, RHEL is open--the trademark is not.
Re:O'Reilly on Morozov by brown9-2 on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @10:18PM (#5490571)
And let's not mistake what regimes claim to do with what they actually do.

This seems like a very hard criteria to meet - separating claimed intentions from "actual" causes (which are never objective).

Besides, the original quote is "in the name of".

Re:O'Reilly on Morozov by icebraining on Thursday April 04, 2013 @08:19AM (#5492170)
I would love to know what licenses are those. Almost all Open Source licenses are also Free Software, and MIT/BSD - which allow partially open code - existed a decade before Open Source was coined.