News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Filing taxes: It shouldn't be so hard by rayiner on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @07:48PM (#5490061)
Here's the basic problem with tax code simplification: the thing you're trying to compute (income = net change in wealth) is inherently complicated to compute. Sure, the special giveaways and whatnot don't help, but a lot of the special giveaways are also related to the theoretical understanding of what should be taxed.

Consider complications like calculating depreciation for capital equipment. All the schedules aren't there because of kicks--they're there because allowing an immediate deduction for an expense that creates a capital asset usable for years is just a mathematically incorrect way to measure "net change in wealth" when considering the time value of money. Other complexity comes from using discrete sampling periods (yearly tax returns) for what is a continuous phenomenon (changes in wealth). That's where things like net loss carry-forwards comes from. Other complexity comes from the intricacies of the "net" (versus gross) part of the equation. You can think of things like childcare deductions as a sop to the fact that childcare is something people buy so they can work, and thus not consumption.

The software analogy is really apropos. I'm pretty sure Windows is over 50 million lines of code at this point, and Linux is over 15 million. That's a million printed pages for Windows, and 300,000 printed pages for Linux. In comparison, the entire U.S. federal tax code is 73,000 pages: http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-3zoNtmhcQmE/T41zkm0VE6I/AAAAAAAAFM....

Are Linux and Windows unnecessarily complex? Or is there just inherent complexity in creating an operating system that runs on everything from supercomputers to cell phones (Linux), or is bug-for-bug compatible back to the 80's (Windows)?

Don't get me wrong, the tax code should be simplified in every way possible. But when people say stuff like it only exists because "we haven't stopped to consider what might be better" that sounds a lot to me like the guy on every engineering team who wants to scrap the big, time-tested system and do a rewrite. Go to Microsoft, tell them that their system is just "patch after patch" and then volunteer to rewrite the whole thing. See what they say.

Re:Filing taxes: It shouldn't be so hard by danielweber on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @09:56PM (#5490502)
What do you think about setting the corporate tax to 0% and making up for it by taking capital gains and dividends like normal income?

We could get rid of most of the corporate tax code that way -- and corporate taxes, as you point out, are always gonna be complex.

Re:Filing taxes: It shouldn't be so hard by rayiner on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @11:00PM (#5490716)
I think it's theoretically inelegant but may be what is most practical, especially in a race to the bottom global economy. More than one company has reincorporated in high-tax countries like the UK and Switzerland, because of favorable corporate taxes. The executives pay more, but it gooses earnings which is what the analysts want to see. We don't get much revenue from them anyway and it'd be better to keep the companies and the capital here.