News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by nasalgoat on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @05:01PM (#5482054)
I'm sorry, but the talent shortage is a real thing.

We don't have any HR filtering in place - resumes come directly to managers - but we still have a really difficult time filling our open positions.

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by ditonal on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @05:21PM (#5482184)
*Shortage of talent at the price you are willing to pay.

There are all sorts of legal work and questions I would love to have done if I could get a top-notch lawyer for $10/hr. That doesn't mean there is a shortage of top-notch lawyers, it means that I am priced out by the rest of the market who are offering them better wages. Sounds like you are priced out of the market, if you offer market wages, you will find people by definition of market wage i.e. the price that it costs to successfully hire people, not the price off of salary.com.

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by hkmurakami on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @05:35PM (#5482269)
One caveat is that "market wages" most likely will need to offer a risk premium depending on what kind of environment, stability, convenience, etc. you offer. It probably isn't going to be "the industry average for all companies (including the big boys) is $X, so I should need to just offer $X". X could be lower or higher, depending on who you manage to find and who you are.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by ditonal on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @05:44PM (#5482333)
I think there's actually a lot of caveats, all jobs are not equal, there isn't perfect information about all available jobs (hence the need for recruiting), etc.

But on the other hand, this 'shortage' is being used as a political tool to depress engineering salaries, even though if you applied the same logic to other professions you would find there are worse shortages there. Clearly it would be useful from a healthcare cost perspective if we had more doctors but we aren't expanding visa quotas there. Salary is a huge issue and most jobs want to pay engineers as little as possible. Of course they will rant about how competitive their pay is but if it was so competitive they would probably advertise it, instead of trying to use information asymmetry so they can negotiate them down lower. Then of course, they only hire the best, but salary negotiations inevitably revert to 'market wages', then after all this they can't hire people so they need more immigrants who get deported if they fire them.

For some reason, if you can't afford an accountant, you don't get an accountant, if you can't afford a private lawyer, you don't get a private lawyer, but if you can't afford a programmer, there is a talent shortage and we need more skilled immigrants and to subsidize more STEM graduates.

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by hkmurakami on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @06:36PM (#5482666)
Not to mention the H1B hire -> underpay -> keep them underpaid and shackled with the H1B/Greencard combo.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by ktsmith on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @01:24AM (#5484396)
H-1B holders can transfer jobs even after applying for permanent residency. American Competitiveness in the 21st Century Act allows for this specifically. There are provisions:

   New Employment must be the "same or similar" classification
   Form I-140 has been approved or is approvable when filed with I-485
   Form I-485 has been pending for at least 180 days
   
The employee needs to file a Form I-129 and will need to provide their new employer their original I-94, passport, and Form I-129 filing receipt to properly document work authorization.

Most HR departments fuck this up and many immigration attorneys fuck this up but it's completely possible.

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @09:01PM (#5483447)
You would quickly find yourself in trouble with the INS.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by mjmahone17 on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @09:33PM (#5483602)
Sort of. Unless you can show that they make higher than the prevailing wage. This being regardless of what the H1B applicant could make if they transferred companies (something that's not typically in their best interest until they have a green card, at least from those I've talked to. Being a US citizen, I may be wrong). The prevailing wage, for many people, is not a competitive wage.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by RougeFemme on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @10:17PM (#5483778)
Even if/when they aren't underpaid, they are still shackled by the H1B visa.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by ktsmith on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @01:27AM (#5484408)
I posted this above but that's not true at all. If you can find another employer to hire you at a competitive wage with a similar job classification you are free to transfer your H-1B. H-1B holders can even transfer jobs after applying for permanent residency if they follow a few basic guidelines thanks to AC21.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by purplelobster on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @09:52PM (#5483676)
The difference is that many occupations basically are zero sum games. No matter how many doctors you have, there won't be more sick patients. But, the more engineers you have, the bigger the pie becomes, unless there are no more innovations to be made. Many of the people behind SV success stories are immigrants.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by ditonal on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @11:06AM (#5486497)
No, this is totally wrong. Doctors create wealth too, contributing more healthcare to society is in no way zero sum. There are already plenty of sick patients left over, not everybody gets world class healthcare at affordable costs. If you had more of them healthcare costs would go down and so the capital saved could go to other endeavours. Secondly, you heal people who contribute more to the pie. Finally, healthiness IS the pie, it is itself a type of wealth, arguably one of the most important.

And yes, skilled immigrants create wealth. But the same reasonable arguments that can be made for bringing in skilled tech immigigrants (NOT on indebtured servant visas) could be made for bringing in skilled healthcare immigrants. The reason the former happens a lot more than the latter is because of political representation. Doctors have the AMA carefully controlling the supply of doctors, tech workers have Google and Microsoft doing the opposite.

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by droithomme on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @05:11PM (#5482117)
If you want this claim of yours honestly evaluated, state your company, location, job requirements, and how much the compensation package is.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by polymatter on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @07:24PM (#5482917)
Where do you advertise? How do you portray your company? Do you get involved in local meetups? Do you contribute to Open Source? Why do the employees that do decide to leave you, leave? What do they say about you? Do you know the going rate for your open positions? How do you know thats the going rate and how are you confident that that is a rate your potential candidates are likely to accept? Is there a big-brand competitor nearby that sucks up your potential candidates? Is your office hard to get to? Is there a local tech scene or is it a tech desert? Is your company in a non-sexy industry that has a common perception of being particularly boring (eg. Enterprise Java billing middleware) or evil (eg. recording industry, patent troll, oil industry)?

And thats before we get to how you are filtering resumes. It can very well be the case that there is a talent shortage in your area/domain. But I think its very hard to conclusively say so on the basis of a lack of qualified candidates flooding through every open opportunity.

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by vonmoltke on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @05:15PM (#5482142)
Counter anecdote:

We don't really have an HR department at all, and we don't have much trouble finding people when we need them. Sure, we get our fair share of chaff like everyone else. Still only takes a month or two to find someone worth hiring. I do not consider that an unreasonable amount of time. For the record, every engineer we have hired since I started, and including me, has been a cold application off a web posting.

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by jjtheblunt on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @05:25PM (#5482203)
If you're in California, it's because no American from outside California improves her/his economic outlook by coming to California, where cost of living is easily several times higher than in many other thriving parts of the country.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by scarmig on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @06:00PM (#5482433)
Moving to California from the East Coast nearly doubled my salary. Cost of living went up, but by around a factor of 15-20%.

Of course, since lots of people are really fucking rich in the Bay Area, it's easy to get caught in the conspicuous consumption game (the biggest part of which is probably housing and location). But if you can avoid that, moving to California can easily mean a whole lot more money, even with taxes + cost of living.

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @10:06PM (#5483736)
I'm an infrastructure guy. I interviewed with a fairly well known startup in Mountain View. I was making $120K in Chicago, and was offered $110K to move to Mountain View/San Jose.

In what world is that an intelligent choice, when you can make $ITMONIES somewhere where the cost of living isn't going to eat you alive.

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by lern_too_spel on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @10:15PM (#5483772)
$110k plus equity, right? If you got an offer from an established public company, the salary portion of the compensation package would likely be much higher.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @10:18PM (#5483782)
Very little equity. Not worth the salary differential.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by ktsmith on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @01:32AM (#5484425)
You should assume that any equity you are offerred by a startup has a value of $0 because the odds are that's what you are going to see from it.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @09:02PM (#5483454)
> cost of living is easily several times higher than in many other thriving parts of the country.

Citation required. I doubt its even up to 2X, let alone several times higher.

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by saryant on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @09:17PM (#5483519)
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by potatolicious on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @11:41PM (#5484089)
That website isn't worth the electrons it's made of. I've used it in three moves now, and its indices have never been anywhere close to reality.

I just looked up their latest indices for Seattle, San Francisco, and NYC (143, 199, 169, respectively) - all cities I've lived in before, and these numbers bear no semblance to reality.

According to this, living in NYC is ~18% more expensive than Seattle - which is an absolutely laughable statement if you've ever lived in both places - 80-100% would be more like it. Similarly, it claims that SF is ~18% more expensive than New York, which a pretty absurd claim itself. There are places in SF more expensive than NYC, but overall it's still substantially cheaper.

Measuring a bunch of medians that sound like they relate to cost of living, and then throwing them in a blender for a weighted average... turns out the number that pops out the other end is more or less meaningless.

If you're being paid California-level salaries in, say, Chicago or Austin - stay put, the money is better where you are. If you're being paid the standard Chicago-area salary, moving to California may be an overall gain even accounting for cost of living adjustment.

Not to mention that some cities have more scalable living costs than others. There are more than a few software folks here in NYC who are cutting their costs to the bone and exploiting the salary gap to put a lot of money in the bank (for eventual startups, or moving to a cheaper part of the country, whatever). The problem with a median measure in a world with irregular distributions is that it ends up describing no one individual in the set very well.

[deleted]
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by potatolicious on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @12:05AM (#5484159)
I was living in SF until less than a year ago - the housing market is insane, no doubt, and it will probably hit NYC-levels at some point in the near future.

But that isn't right now, I do not believe. There are corners (particularly SOMA) where cost of living far outstrips even the glitziest corners of Manhattan, but those are few and far between. In general, living in SF is still cheaper than living in Manhattan or the "near" neighborhoods of Brooklyn and Queens (i.e., not a 45-minute train ride from everything).

And therein lies the problem with these cost of living calculators - they have no awareness of equivalencies and idiosyncracies of these places. Why are we rolling Staten Island into this calculation when comparing SI to anywhere in SF is plain lunacy?

Similarly, the lifestyle between the Outer Richmond and North Beach are very different - as are rent prices. But yet these websites essentially add them up and divide by two, as if that number represents something meaningful.

If you want to evaluate cost of living differences between two cities, indices are probably the worst way to do it.

[deleted]
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by potatolicious on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @12:23AM (#5484226)
$1850 (or even $2K) is a pretty tough task in Chelsea nowadays, and Chelsea is still one of the cheaper neighborhoods. The UES is also fairly inexpensive by Manhattan standards, but a studio under $2K is still pretty unrealistic.

They exist, but they are few and far between. If you offered me a $1850 studio in Chelsea my first thought would be "what's under the floorboards". If you told me it's a $1850 1BR I'd check your temperature. The only places you'd reliably find studios < $2K would be Chinatown and the LES in general - and there are many reasons why those places are inexpensive.

I'm not sure if Manhattan is as cheap as you remember...

Hell, even Brooklyn is ridiculous now. Williamsburg is more expensive than most of Manhattan, Park Slope slightly cheaper but not by much. DUMBO, get outta here, DUMBO is giving TriBeCa a run for its money. $1850 for a studio is unrealistic in all of the above places, though if you're looking in the winter and have luck on your side, possibly doable in not-Park-Slope-but-lets-pretend areas.

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @09:25PM (#5483559)
Funny. The chart shows an overall rating of 199, but the break down is at parity or less than 100. They don't break out housing, which is the only real killer in San Francisco, yet not everyone really needs to be buy a house there to be happy (many can and do with less housing to economize).

Also, the parent post compared SF to other thriving cities in the US, not the US in general. Would love to see how SF is twice as expensive as some place like Atlanta or Dallas (assuming they are thriving, of course).

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by saryant on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @11:13PM (#5483993)
Real estate—whether renting or buying—is the killer. I moved from the Bay Area to Texas (Houston then San Antonio) and it's dirt cheap here. I pay $500/month for a great apartment in a nice part of town with hardwood floors, air conditioning and a covered parking space. Around 700 sq.ft.

Fuel is cheaper, taxes are lower (when I left CA car registration was over $400/year I recall, mine is $50 here) and housing is much cheaper.

Not sure if this link will still work for you:

http://bestplaces.net/col/?salary=80000&city1=54865000&#...

According to their stats I would need 2.3x the salary I make here for a comparable lifestyle in SF. Now, I'll grant you that could be mitigated by not living in SF but one of the cheaper suburbs. Mess with the numbers and see what it looks like.

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @11:28PM (#5484055)
I would say SF costs are higher but, not very much, on everything than Texas until housing is considered. I don't think that is a very controversial assumption; even gas might be $4 in SF and only about a $1 cheaper in Texas.

Equivlalent lifestyle is always fuzzy: do I need a car if I live in SF? Maybe but many do well without. If you are into urban living...you wouldn't be very happy in San Antonio. In NYC, this is magnified obviously. You can also move out of SF, and unfortunately, many jobs are in the bay area and not the city anyways (so live in Mountain View vs. SF and work at Google).

For the record, I still think SF is too expensive and would prefer Seattle or Portland for quality of life reasons (but I'm a native PNW). I wouldn't dream of moving to Texas, I didn't even find Austin to be very nice; I don't like driving and haven't owned a car in over 7 years (when I lived in the Bay Area ironically).

Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by saryant on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @11:38PM (#5484082)
That's how I felt. I'm a California native and I thought I'd hate Texas but after living here for seven years I very much doubt I'll ever go back.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @03:25AM (#5484753)
I've been out of the states for 7 years. Sometimes I wonder if I'll ever bother going back.
Re:The Talent Shortage Myth and Why HR Should Get Out of the... by lightup88 on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @05:15PM (#5482140)
Absolutely it is. Furthermore, the concept that an applicant should dictate whether he/she speaks to a manager is impractical. Just as dismissing screeners as largely incompetent is silly.

To be clear-he's absolutely correct that automated screening of applications isn't up to snuff.