Your rebuttal of this "pseudo science" is that you perceive that you personally need 8.5 hours sleep - now that smacks of pseudo science to me.
People are very different. Just because 1 person in a 1000 (or 100 or million or whatever) benefits from 8.5 hours sleep does not necessarily mean that in general one might get more benefit from less than 8.5 hours sleep.
This is not hard science, I doubt it could ever be, but that does not mean it is pseudo science and certainly should not be dismissed out of hand because it does not fit into the model of the world that you have personally.
> people who sleep between 6.5 hr. and 7.5 hr. a night, live the longest, are happier and most productive
O RLY? Time for another basic primer on causation vs. correlation.
Note that I am not saying that the result is fact, just that there is science to indicate that things are not as simple as they may appear to people that dismiss the whole thing as "pseudo science".
I'm afraid "science" is quite a bit more complicated than you seem to believe.
One of its most basic tenets is that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. One study is not enough to prove the assertion that people who sleep for 6.5 to 7.5 hours a night are the happiest.
It is not at all something I can experiment with directly, unless you believe that sleep under the effects of sleep-inducing drugs is equivalent to natural sleep (it isn't, in my experience).
You can't really lengthen your natural sleep cycle without conflating things with drugs, but I've found that personally I can sleep up to 11 hours if I let myself (although there may be another conflating factor as I tend to sleep more when I'm learning something hard).
"The sleep deprived person can in fact deliver the exact same results as someone who isn’t sleep deprived in any exercise. That is, given it is a non repeated exercise and they give it their best shot."
This phenomenon is called neuron tiring and he makes it sound like someone only carries out wrong judgements sparingly whereas it is more like when person is exhausted from running. The person's legs don't turn off, they are tired. They are still useable and could probably sprint for a very short distance but will eventually start shaking. If the person tries to sprint again, he can but still not for long. This is what being tired or sleep deprived does. You can go for very short sprints but you fail at endurance.
And the 8 hours thing is a mean and it is not pseudo science. Google actual medical sources and see for yourself.
On another note, even when we're talking about mortality, I don't think that sleeping 8.5 hours might be worse than 5. That seems to be an off-hand remark during the interview, to me.
[1] I don't recall any study looking specifically at task performance after oversleeping. The link to the study in the OP's post (http://www.sfn.org/index.aspx?pagename=news_052008&print...) is broken. [2] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-2869.2008....
What perplexes me is this notion that a person's optimum amount of sleep stays constant whatever they're doing (confounding factors like alcohol, illness and recent sleep-deprivation aside). Surely I'm not the only person in the world whose sleep requirement varies considerably according to the level of physical and mental exertion of the day before, climate, diet, ambient stress level etc.?
And whilst I believe naps probably are a good idea, I'm a bit perplexed to how one times a nap so it ends up being at least 20 mins and no more than 30 mins. Often it takes me that long simply to fall asleep, especially if it's a sunny mid-afternoon and I have plans for the rest of the day to be thinking about...
My own experiences seem to fall in line, but it may just be a placebo effect.
If I sleep for 5 hrs, I'm completely fine. I can do that for days on end. If I sleep for 9 hrs, I'm completely fine as well.
The reality, and from what I've read by cognitive scientists (there are a few), there is no set number of hours of sleep a person needs. For the right person 5 hours is great. For others it isn't. Which is a whole lot better than the crap "common wisdom" of EVERYONE NEED 8 HOURS OF SLEEP that is thrown out for days on end.
Also, never take personal anecdote seriously. Anecdotes will only lead to worse science, not better.
If I sleep 9 to 10 hours, I do feel groggy/sleepy for several hours—it's not pleasant, but mellow grogginess/sleepiness is wonderful compared to the demoralizing mental and physical exhaustion I feel when I've not slept enough.
How can people even take this kind of pseudo-science seriously?
If I sleep for 5 hrs, I'm a complete zombie during the day, unproductive and depressed.
If I sleep for 8.5 hrs (which is how long I sleep naturally), I feel great, productive, and happy. I get way more done.
There are all sorts of studies showing all the negative effects of not getting enough sleep -- that sleep-deprived doctors, for instance, are basically acting under an impairment equal to a few drinks of alcohol.
The idea that people in general are getting too much sleep is really quite preposterous.