News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by davidroberts on Sunday March 31, 2013 @11:08AM (#5468825)
The amazing thing is that excellent students from poor schools really should apply to the elite private universities, because the private schools will pretty much pay for their education through their huge endowments. It's a much better path than going through state universities, where even the poorest have a huge loan debt by the time they graduate.

The OP is right about the recruiting efforts of the private universities. It's not just the rural schools they skip. My son went to a high school near San Diego that straddles the border between an middle class area built in the 50s and a low income area. The student body is about 40% suburban white, 25% Hispanic, 10% recently moved from Iraq (Chaldean), and the rest African American, Native American and other minorities. It has a 7 out of 10 California high school rating, so it's not that bad.

There were no recruiters from "elite" private schools. The best students typically go to University of California, either USCD, UCLA, or Berkeley. The next level goes to the other UCs, especially Irvine or Riverside. Many go to San Diego State University, and the rest who continue their education go to community college.

My son loves economics, and got it early in his head that he really wanted to go to University of Chicago. We were pretty poor at the time, as I was changing my career and working my way up in from the total bottom in a new field doing mainly freelance work.

My son worked really hard to get to UChicago. He attended a recruiting event in a downtown hotel he found out about on the internet. I borrowed money and we flew to Chicago for an interview, staying in a sketchy hotel on the South Side. He applied for early admission and got accepted last year, the first student ever from his high school. They offered a financial package that pays almost everything.

His friends who are still at the school said that this year, for the first time, a recruiter from UChicago showed up. It is like my son put the school on their radar.

One thing we noticed as part of the process is that taking the PSAT is really important. It only costs about $20 and it's free in some schools. There might be something similar for the ACT.

My son did well on the PSAT and he got multiple letters from Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Columbia, and other Ivies trying to lure him in. Also from elite private four-year colleges. So there is an outreach by those schools in this way. Often those letters would mention the possibility of almost full support for students that needed it.

I think the Ivies are trying to reach out to poorer students. It's just that it's hard for them to think out of the box created by their own privileged backgrounds and understand how to reach that demographic. But our experience is that they are sincerely trying, and if a student makes the effort, he can definitely get in.

I think one of the biggest barriers is that counselors in schools like my son's or the OP's don't even consider these schools for qualified students (are they uninformed? lazy? incompetent? complacent?). If they pushed harder, both to the Ivies and in guiding the students, it would help a lot.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by rgarcia on Sunday March 31, 2013 @12:31PM (#5469126)
100x this. I went to a high school in a suburb of Chicago that essentially was a feeder school into local/state colleges. The idea of leaving the state or even the surrounding area did not even cross the mind of most people in my class. I ended up applying to most of the same "safe"/surrounding schools that my friends did, but also reached and sent applications to a few very selective schools. When I got accepted into Harvard I thought, great, how is my family going to pay for this? We submitted our financial aid paperwork, and it ended up being cheaper for me to go Harvard than any of the state schools in Illinois.

It seems generally true that as the quality of the university increases, the financial resources it has at its disposal also increase. Many schools seem to be investing this into financial aid, but I wonder if that's generally true across the board. Also, I think no matter what it will take time to shed the stereotype that elite schools are for the economically elite. This is a major reason I think there isn't as much awareness about the vast amounts of aid that these schools give to students.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by RegEx on Sunday March 31, 2013 @11:25AM (#5468877)
I was part of a poor family growing up. I received many letters and packages from upper tier schools after my PSAT. I got top 5% in the nation for math, so that may be why. I didn't take them seriously, though. Now I'm at University of Texas (at Tyler), where the idea of computer science education is a series of publisher-distributed PowerPoint slides.

I want to move to a different school with passionate teachers and students, but now I have financial obligations(unemployed mom can't find work so I'm taking over her bills while she goes to school). I'm currently looking for a python remote job or job near Dallas. Until I can find something, I have to stay at this job so I can support my mom, thus UT Tyler is my only option.

I wish I would have done more research on scholarship opportunities back in high school. Maybe I'd be somewhere great right now. Oh well.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by aptimpropriety on Sunday March 31, 2013 @11:32AM (#5468906)
It's never too late to transfer - and being a transfer doesn't make you ineligible for financial aid!

I went to a major public university my freshman year and transferred to an Ivy League school once I decided I wasn't satisfied with my experience at the public university. It ended up actually being significantly cheaper for me to go to the Ivy League, and opened up a world of opportunity and support I would have never found at my original school.

Since then, my sister has also attended the same Ivy League (you see a lot of families/siblings at such schools) almost free of charge. I could also go on about how the resources and individual support from a private school (effective tuition of 50-60k) far exceed that of a public school - even a top UC.

Feel free to email me if you'd like to chat.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by Crake on Monday April 01, 2013 @06:57PM (#5476475)
I'm at a community college (because I have no money, not because I'm stupid) and am presently trying to transfer to two "elite" schools. One says pretty explicitly that they don't guarantee that they meet full need for transfers, even though they brag about it for their 18 year old freshman applicants. The other seems more welcoming, but I'm still nervous. I don't know if I've gotten into them or not, either. I can barely afford $3500/year tuition for a community college, much less something way above that while also paying to move and live in another state. (Luckily I got 2 science scholarships to cover my CC tuition for the 2012-2013 year, but I still have to worry about food and rent. The maximum amount of stafford loan I can take out is barely enough to live on, even as an independent student.)

Is it all right to ask what Ivy you went to? Is it the same as the school associated e-mail in your profile?

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by Amadou on Sunday March 31, 2013 @11:46AM (#5468961)
> and being a transfer doesn't make you ineligible for financial aid!

That isn't necessarily the case. A close friend of mine attended a school (Bradley University, admittedly not ivy league) that gave a full ride to national merit scholars and finalists, but only if they had never enrolled anywhere else. She was a finalist, but she attended a state school for her freshman year. Bradley gave her nothing, but she still enrolled because money wasn't her biggest concern. She got her degree, but has said on numerous occasions that she'll never give a dime to any of their alumni fund-raisers since she paid the full load up front.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by ryguytilidie on Sunday March 31, 2013 @11:59AM (#5469000)
With the way most schools treat their students as cattle they need to get through the mill as quickly as possible, it amazes me that anyone donates to alumni organizations.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by onedognight on Sunday March 31, 2013 @10:17PM (#5471095)
> It's never too late to transfer - and being a transfer doesn't make you ineligible for financial aid!

This is definitely the case. I went to a state school that was cheap. Transfering to a top school that usually costs 10x but with financial aid ended up being cheaper still.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by techsupporter on Sunday March 31, 2013 @10:35PM (#5471136)
You're already in the UT system so, unless you're just terrible, you can move to any other school that's part of UT. If you're looking for north Texas, go for UT Arlington; they're more technology-focused than UT Dallas. Also, for a reasonably well-paying job, look at datacenter operations stuff. People who are skilled at Unix and scripting and who might want to work odd hours--great for a student--are in demand. SoftLayer and companies in the Infomart are always looking for folks.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by ijk on Monday April 01, 2013 @04:50PM (#5475844)
I'm curious as to why you'd rate UT Arlington ahead of UT Dallas on technology, since I'd put them the other way around.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by RegEx on Sunday March 31, 2013 @11:37PM (#5471282)
This is really good information, thank you very much.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by wh-uws on Sunday March 31, 2013 @03:10PM (#5469785)
If you can, transfer to UT Austin they have one of the best CS programs in the country.

Arguably up there with Stanford.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by tstactplsignore on Sunday March 31, 2013 @12:18PM (#5469075)
>My son did well on the PSAT and he got multiple letters from Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Columbia, and other Ivies trying to lure him in.

It's worth noting here that colleges do make an effort to recruit kids from lower socio-economic backgrounds.

I know more than one affluent middle-upper class white kids who swept perfect PSATs, SATs, and SAT II's and who were rejected or waitlisted across the board at these four schools. From this kind of background, getting letters from top schools before applying is absolutely unheard of, and perfect/near perfect SATs are simply expected on their applications and mean nothing.

I mean, I support the decisions of most colleges to put considerable effort into recruiting kids from diverse backgrounds, but the point is, they definitely already do.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by rayiner on Sunday March 31, 2013 @11:25AM (#5468878)
OT, but congratulations to your son! U Chicago is an amazing school in an amazing city. I went to school cross-town so I have a lot of friends who went to U Chicago, and from what they say, it's uniquely supportive of focused young people who know what they want to study.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by socalnate1 on Sunday March 31, 2013 @12:23PM (#5469096)
Was this El Camino High School in Oceanside, CA by chance? I came here to say something basically identical - but realized you stole my thunder, since your son had a near identical experience. :)

All the smartest kids in my high school (including 1500+ SAT types) all went to UCSD/UCLA/Berekly. It wasn't until I was in grad school years later, and hung around lots of Stanford/Harvard/MIT grads that I realized they weren't really much smarter or harder working than all the kids in my high school, they just grew up with the expectation of going to a Ivy school ingrained in their experience.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by davidroberts on Sunday March 31, 2013 @05:05PM (#5470185)
It was Grossmont High School on the border between La Mesa and El Cajon, CA. It was the same with my son. He hung out with a group that included all the 10 best students by GPA in his class. Except for him, they all went to state schools.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by VLM on Monday April 01, 2013 @01:17PM (#5474441)
"If they pushed harder, both to the Ivies and in guiding the students, it would help a lot."

Can't afford it. My local district annual report shows the counselors only achievement metric is percentage of HS seniors who go to non-votech school after graduation. Helping one kid get into an ivy at the cost of helping 3 kids attend the local CC could quite literally cost their job.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by bane on Sunday March 31, 2013 @12:20PM (#5469082)
It's a much better path than going through state universities, where even the poorest have a huge loan debt by the time they graduate.

I can't speak for every state, but at least the ones I know about, the tuition for in-state students attending a state school are pretty reasonable.

Here's an old post I wrote up on it.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3753975

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by Crake on Monday April 01, 2013 @07:07PM (#5476536)
For a lot of people, it's not just tuition though. You'd probably double or triple your calculated cost there if you included cost of living, which is something a lot of disadvantaged students have to worry about. Plus, if you have crappy parents, you'll only get $3500-5,500/year or so in stafford student loans, if you are even lucky enough to have access to their financial info (which many parents will refuse to give). That's enough for a community college, but not anywhere close to enough to afford even the cheapest state school.

It's also incredibly hard to qualify for a pell grant. I wasn't able to work for health reasons last year, and the best I could get even while unemployed was $900/semester.

I didn't qualify for anything during the six years I was a dependent student. (Which is a huge part of why I wasn't able to be a student at all during that time.)

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by bane on Monday April 01, 2013 @10:57PM (#5477421)
I don't disagree that it's a serious pain in the butt, and that sometimes the stars have to align the right way for it to work. But the only point I was trying to make was that it's possible, even on 100% loans, to graduate state school with merely a "big debt" than the kind of "massive over-the-top debt" that you would incur going to a private school.

In the end the starting salary will probably not be all that different, but the amount that has to be paid back will be much less, allowing those state school grads to reach the benefits of their career much faster if they try and pay the loans off quickly.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by flexie on Sunday March 31, 2013 @11:40AM (#5468939)
"excellent students from poor schools really should apply to the elite private universities, because the private schools will pretty much pay for their education through their huge endowments"

How long would the Ivy-league schools maintain those huge endowments if most spots were taken by students from poor background?

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by davidroberts on Sunday March 31, 2013 @11:48AM (#5468965)
Harvard's endowment is $32 billion. They can fund many students at $50,000 a year from the interest without touching the principle, and it's a major goal of theirs to do so. Yale, Princeton, and Columbia also have multi-billion dollar endowments and are aiming to do the same. They can afford it.

This is how the University of Chicago does it (from their website):

Thanks to an extremely generous gift of $100 million from an anonymous alumnus, we are now able to offer an even more competitive financial aid package to many of our students. The Odyssey program has allowed more students from modest backgrounds the ability to pursue all that the University has to offer without the worries of working to pay off loan debt. For students with family incomes below $75,000 a year, all expected federal student loans are replaced with Odyssey Scholarships. For students with family incomes between $75,000 and $90,000, half of their expected federal student loan obligation is replaced with Odyssey Scholarships. You must apply for need based financial aid in order to be considered for this need-based University funded scholarship.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by mjmahone17 on Sunday March 31, 2013 @12:27PM (#5469107)
Right, even Brown, one of the poorest Ivies, has more than $2 billion in endowments. And one of the methods they do to afford it is charging higher tuition: Christina Paxson, Brown's president, has (maybe not officially, but at least in private) has said that she wants tuition to work similar to a graduated-income tax. This would mean even children of rich ($150-200k/yr) parents would be eligible for some amount of financial aid (because $150k/yr isn't enough to be able to afford $60k/yr tuition), but they may end up paying the same tuition as everyone would normally, if there were no financial aid.

This is also a large part of the logic top-tier schools have used to justify their increased tuition to the federal government.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by flexie on Sunday March 31, 2013 @12:35PM (#5469143)
If Harvard really wanted that they could offer their education for free to all 21,000 students right now, cover the tuition with a 4 percent interest on their endowment and still have more than $5B left for other expenses.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by mjmahone17 on Sunday March 31, 2013 @01:40PM (#5469412)
Right, but why would you have everyone going for free, when you can get a guarunteed $60k/yr of revenue from ~30%+ of your students, without it presenting any hardship to them? Also, I'd be unsurprised if another reason for raising tuition was to raise the perceived value of the university. Which would help contribute to even higher donations.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by Havoc on Sunday March 31, 2013 @12:22PM (#5469092)
>How long would the Ivy-league schools maintain those huge endowments if most spots were taken by students from poor background?

This logic is flawed imo. Yes the students are poor at the moment, but the endowments don't come from what students are now. They come from what they will be. "excellent students" plus excellent education strikes me as a pretty good recipe on that front.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by stephencanon on Monday April 01, 2013 @07:18AM (#5472391)
> How long would the Ivy-league schools maintain those huge endowments if most spots were taken by students from poor background?

Pretty long, I’d wager. The endowments weren’t built on tuition, they were built on alumni giving. One might hope that formerly poor students would be more likely to give generously as wealthy alumni.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by socillion on Monday April 01, 2013 @12:29AM (#5471441)
Sure glad I happened across this thread.

I'm almost 1 year into taking community college classes, was thinking of transferring to state college mostly because nobody ever bothered to tell me it would actually be cheaper to get into an Ivy League college.

Now, just have to figure out how to get accepted with a GED!