News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why innovators get better with age by rayiner on Saturday March 30, 2013 @07:24PM (#5467026)
I think the idea that the "true innovators" are a bunch of kids with no experience is massively counter-productive. If you look at the real innovators in computing (not Zuck) over the last 50 years, you'll see that the ripest period seems to be 30-40. Larry Ellison was 33 when he founded what became Oracle. Bradeen was 39 and Brattain 45 when they invented the transistor. Bill Hewlett and David Packard were 26 and 27 when they founded HP, but the company achieved its real successes during the war when they were in their 30's.

The reason I say it's counter-productive is that it tends to upend a very fruitful social structure: younger people learning how to innovate under the direction older, experienced people. Ken Thompson and Dennis Ritchie didn't invent Unix one day between their college classes. They joined Bell Labs after getting advanced degrees, worked on a system (Multics) implemented by older, more experienced people, and gained the expertise they needed to innovate. You can't really develop expertise as a young kid, and expertise is usually a pre-requisite for real innovation.

And to tie in to the organizational management angle in the article: who would you rather have in your organization? John Carmack circa 1991 (when he founded id software), or John Carmack circa 2013?

If this seems counter-intuitive in the context of the current Silicon Valley youth worship, ask yourself: what are the young kids at Twitter, Facebook, etc, really building? The answer is: lifestyle and entertainment products. Without demeaning the value of those products, I'll say it's not a contentious assertion that young people have some significant insight into lifestyle and entertainment as an industry, but that doesn't mean they're particularly innovative.

Re:Why innovators get better with age by marquis on Sunday March 31, 2013 @06:44AM (#5468321)
This is also true for women - in my life many of my friends who are over 40 are getting their PhDs and doing incredible research. Also see composers and painters: so much of our great works in history are done by older people. Perhaps because I studied classics, I always assumed that I would only start doing my 'real' work after the age of 40 and I'm personally really enjoying building my career with the next 30-40 years in mind.
Re:Why innovators get better with age by mitmads on Saturday March 30, 2013 @07:32PM (#5467048)
"expertise is usually a pre-requisite for real innovation". May Be. But many a times, being naive (and inexperienced) may make one to see and think differently.
Re:Why innovators get better with age by rayiner on Saturday March 30, 2013 @07:40PM (#5467064)
You rarely get serious innovation out of people who are naive and simply "think differently." As pointed out in the article, while Dirac and Einstein were outliers and making substantial contributions to science at 26, they both had persued extensive education leading up to that point.

Are there people who innovate out of whole cloth? Maybe. I can't think of any offhand but I'm sure they exist. But they're not representative. Representative are people like Larry Ellison, who build an innovative company like Oracle (it was cutting edge in its time) by leveraging substantial industry experience and theoretical developments.

Re:Why innovators get better with age by goldfeld on Saturday March 30, 2013 @07:57PM (#5467105)
Cutting edge can be mildly innovative. Facebook is somewhat innovative in my scale; as far as I know they came up with the timeline and tagging people. But for me really innovative are Kickstarter, Twitter, StackOverflow. Companies that went blue ocean and literally created a new thing or changed culture in a significant way, because of a fundamental idea, and not simply critical mass (like Facebook.)
Re:Why innovators get better with age by Retric on Saturday March 30, 2013 @10:05PM (#5467398)
StackOverflow was a slightly bettor implementation of an old idea. GPS was innovative and game changing.
Re:Why innovators get better with age by RougeFemme on Sunday March 31, 2013 @01:09AM (#5467787)
And GPS was based on work funded by the DoD - an organization not known to be a worshipper of youth, at least in their R&D corners.
Re:Why innovators get better with age by nitrogen on Saturday March 30, 2013 @08:49PM (#5467213)
"Representative" is a dangerous term to use when you're already talking about distant outliers.
Re:Why innovators get better with age by Retric on Saturday March 30, 2013 @10:02PM (#5467384)
Making lot's of money is not the same thing as innovation. Apple started as a somewhat naive computer kit company who's sales took off, but was far from a stable company. NeXT and Pixar where both more innovative, not to mention how much better run Apple was after Job's return.
Re:Why innovators get better with age by sliverstorm on Saturday March 30, 2013 @08:01PM (#5467114)
I've read some articles in the past that argue the people who see and think differently (and create something new and great) are the people who enter the field with a background in another typically unrelated field. Like, I don't know, professional fly fishing and network security.
Re:Why innovators get better with age by waterlesscloud on Saturday March 30, 2013 @08:21PM (#5467161)
Or it might cause you to see the same things everyone before you saw, and not know the difference.
Re:Why innovators get better with age by shadowrunner on Saturday March 30, 2013 @08:06PM (#5467128)
At the age of 25 I was a long-haired pot smoking rocker dude who drank Budweiser and played Sega Saturn when I wasn't working night shift at the factory.

I didn't hit my stride until the age of 35, when I self-published my first book after four agonizing years of writing it. I'm 42 now and kicking out better, more innovative stuff than ever before. My latest project is INDOCTRINATOR: http://indoctrinator.com but I've developed other successful products.

So yeah, as my own experience would suggest, people do get more creative with age. It has to do with mastery of skills, an accumulation of knowledge, and the alchemist's ability to convert these elements into amazing things to offer the world.

Re:Why innovators get better with age by OGC on Sunday March 31, 2013 @09:26AM (#5468582)
> My latest project is INDOCTRINATOR: http://indoctrinator.com but I've developed other successful products.

"INDOCTRINATOR is an email program that reveals the secrets to becoming obsessed over anything, even something you hate."

Pass.