I took a huge topic and reduced it to bite sized pieces, and likely did make a few mistakes in the process. And for those mistakes, I want to apologize, and would love some feedback so I can improve this discussion in the future.
But I think it's important to distinguish factual errors from economic opinions. Economics IMHO, like psychology, is fundamentally a behavioral science (there are a lot of people that even disagree on this topic!), so it can be hard to model it. That's one of the reasons why economists (like psychologists) can differ so radically in their views.
But feel free to disagree with my opinions of course! Vigorous debate is very important to understanding what's going on here, and I'm very comfortable with changing my mind. My goal is to get people to start thinking about the ideas of economic exchange, so that they can have a framework to truly understand what Bitcoin is trying to accomplish. If you demystify how every other currency in the world works, then you can compare them to how Bitcoin works, and make up your own mind if Bitcoin is a crazy idea, or the real thing.
The part that gets weird is when people describe the USD through the lens of the Bitcoin story, which is really common in the Bitcoin and Gold communities but I don't think actually helps people understand the USD and how it works. If people are going to make an informed decision, they should be looking at Bitcoin through the lens of the claims of Bitcoin Economics, and USD through the lens of Fed Economics, and decide which if any are credible.
Sorry if the tone in the grandparent post came across as a little harsh, I know it's always easier to criticize than to create something yourself.
Q1. We can differentiate between fiat currencies by looking at the qualities of the issuing authority, and thus determine that it's better to have savings in Swiss Francs rather than Zimbabwean Dollars. With Bitcoin, Litecoin and other forks, how do we differentiate apart from popularity of the network?
Q2. I've heard the argument that Bitcoin is valuable because there is scarcity in the system, a limit to the number of coins, thus it is similar to gold. However, if tomorrow somebody discovered vast amounts of pink gold, with exactly the same chemical and physical properties as gold, except for the colour, it's likely the price of gold would fall. As Bitcoin is facing this exact scenario via forking, what are the potential consequences, and does it even matter?
[1] http://litecoin.org (changed the hashing algorithm from SHA256 to Scrypt)
As for Freicoin, it might be silly, but it just puts the Bernanke-ist inflation into the protocol and makes its purpose explicit: namely to break up long-term holdings of wealth, force spending, and discourage saving. The part that isn't silly about it is that said destruction of long-term wealth is distributed rather than centralized, and the wealth redistribution essentially provides increased transaction fees and thereby a reason for more people to validate transactions.
Bernanke-nomics or "monetary policy" constitutes the redistribution of wealth via inflation from the people to the banks. Hard to say that's crazier than Freicoin.
That money exists to serve as an improved barter good, rather than barter being a degenerate form of trade that exists mostly in the rare cases when credit is impractical.
That quantity fixation or durability are particularly important properties of money.
That gold is particularly important, versus anything else that is pretty and value-dense.
That the only forms of money are commodity-backed and pure fiat.
That the USD switched from the first camp to the other in 1971.
Describing the USD without reference to the Federal Reserve at all.
The assumption that the debasement of coins over a 300 year period had any harmful effects other than making the coins less pretty 1700 years later.
That +200% wage and price inflation over 130 years is any kind of serious problem.
That hyperinflation and regular inflation are the same thing except in degree.
That Bitcoin limiting supply controls inflation.
That the problems with deflation are somehow non-obvious or not happening observably in Bitcoin right now.
That flat-rate Demurrage fixes Bitcoin inflation.
That money exists to serve as an improved barter good,
rather than barter being a degenerate form of trade that
exists mostly in the rare cases when credit is
impractical.
Not sure about your disagreement here - are you saying that credit is more fundamental than barter? Money as an improved replacement for barter is hardly controversial. Credit is a third layer on top of money, which only comes into play when there are actual goods to be traded. That quantity fixation or durability are
particularly important properties of money.
If you care about money as a long-term store of value, these are important characteristics. Paper notes from most countries that existed in the 1800s don't hold their value today. Gold coins do. That gold is particularly important, versus
anything else that is pretty and value-dense.
Gold is important because it can't be mined as easily as paper is printed, and because it's an element and thereby difficult to truly counterfeit without an atom smasher. As such it limits the spending power of governments. It's also important for the same reason any network effect is important, namely other people use it (and have used it since historical times). That the only forms of money are commodity-backed and pure
fiat.
This is possibly a factual disagreement. But either a paper note is exchangeable for a fixed quantity of a commodity like gold or it isn't. I suppose you can have some limits on redemption on a daily basis, but otherwise it seems like a reasonable boolean distinction. Please do elaborate on what you have in mind. That the USD switched from the first camp to the other in
1971.
This also seems to be a factual claim. The US under Nixon did indeed abandon the gold standard fully in 1971, removing the $35 dollars per ounce peg (http://www.theatlanticwire.com/politics/2011/08/nixon-gold-s...). Most people both pro- and con- would refer to this as "going off the gold standard". Describing the USD without reference to the Federal
Reserve at all.
I think that's implicit. Not sure this is a "common error". The assumption that the debasement of coins over a 300
year period had any harmful effects other than making the
coins less pretty 1700 years later.
This is not an assumption but is explicitly argued. The underlying thesis is that governments that debase their currency by printing money eventually find their ability to compel obedience waning, as their official scrip is rendered useless. That +200% wage and price inflation over 130 years is any
kind of serious problem.
Given that this period coincides with the decline and ultimate fall of the Roman Empire, I wouldn't call this a "common error" either. That hyperinflation and regular inflation are the same
thing except in degree.
This claim is not made in the slides. But both of them do have the property in common that one's currency becomes less valuable. "Normal" inflation has devalued the US dollar 23.45X since 1913 (roughly $1 in 1913 buys $23.45 today; see usinflationcalculator.com). If that happened in one year we'd call it extremely strong inflation, if not hyperinflation. That Bitcoin limiting supply controls inflation.
Please give a counterargument here. How can you inflate a currency if the supply is fundamentally limited? That the problems with deflation are somehow non-obvious
or not happening observably in Bitcoin right now.
What are the problems? A rise in market cap to $1B over four years from nothing and adoption by millions in the face of government opposition looks like a smashing success. Fluctuations aren't unilateral seizures; everyone in Bitcoin has chosen to be in Bitcoin. That flat-rate Demurrage fixes Bitcoin inflation.
I suppose you mean "fixed Bitcoin deflation"? Freicoin may not "fix" deflation but it's a currency which has regular inflation built into it. Because Kyle supports deflation he certainly did not claim that Freicoin is a "fix", but rather a technical embodiment of an alternate philosophy.In short, I think most of the points you raise are not "common errors" but rather (at best) disagreements of opinion. Would appreciate any elaboration on the points of seeming factual disagreement.
It's not controversial -- it's wholly wrong. Credit did not come after money, credit came before money. The IOU was the first form of credit and became the first form of money.
http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2011/08/what-is-debt-%E2%80%9...
So really, rather than the standard story – first there’s
barter, then money, then finally credit comes out of that
– if anything its precisely the other way around.
So he knows he's pushing something counterintuitive here. Where's the evidence he's marshalled? He also identifies the "standard story" with "free market economists" and tacitly identifies himself as a chartalist. Now, I don't want to throw the baby out with the bathwater - there is something interesting about the idea of a general sense of indebtedness as important to the origins of economics - but it does seem like we've parachuted in two different modes of behavior from central casting. On the one hand, the chartalists/Graeber types who are in favor of consumption, debt, inflation, and the state. On the other the Austrians/Nakamoto types who are in favor of production, savings, deflation, and the individual.I really just want the people in favor of infinite debt and bailouts to hold their own currency and transact amongst themselves, while we do the converse. I don't want to be part of a group of people who think of debt as more fundamental than production, and/or who favor (and historically stress) vaguer gift/debt economies over more quantifiable barter/money economies.
What are you trying to say that I'm missing?
http://money.cnn.com/2010/12/01/news/economy/fed_reserve_dat...
The Federal Reserve made $9 trillion in overnight loans
to major banks and Wall Street firms during the financial
crisis, according to newly revealed data released
Wednesday. ...
The amount of cash being pumped out to the financial
giants was not previously disclosed. All the loans were
backed by collateral and all were paid back with a very
low interest rate to the Fed -- an annual rate of between
0.5% to 3.5%. ...
Sen. Bernie Sanders, the Vermont independent who had
authored the provision of the financial reform law that
required Wednesday's disclosure, called the data that was
released incredible and jaw-dropping.
"The $700 billion Wall Street bailout turned out to be
pocket change compared to trillions and trillions of
dollars in near zero interest loans and other financial
arrangements that the Federal Reserve doled out to every
major financial institution," Sanders said.1. The Fed/govt does not simply deposit money "in the accounts of banks." Under TARP and quantitative easing, the Treasury purchased securities or shares from the banks. Under quantitative easing, the Fed purchased Treasury securities and mortgage-backed securities from the banks. Yes, the Fed printed the money to buy those securities, but it't not like they just printed the money and gave the banks free money.
2. Overnight loans are almost irrelevant to your point because they're overnight. They have to be paid back within 24 hours. The $9 trillion dollar figure sounds impressive but that's just the value of all the overnight loans added up. If you make $8.2 billion in loans every day for 3 years (with the 8.2 billion paid back the next day and then another 8.2 billion loaned out again), you get $9 trillion.
Yes, the Fed printed the money to buy those securities,
but it's not like they just printed the money and gave
the banks free money.
That is exactly what they did, because otherwise those securities would not have had the same price on an open market. The Fed paid for worthless holdings and propped up banks by printing trillions, thereby devaluing everyone else's dollars. And they are still doing it, now printing $85B per month ($1T/year) to buy mortgage-backed securities and reinflate the housing bubble. Printing $100 to buy $1 of MBS toxic waste from the banks is direct depositing $99 into their pockets (and causing commensurate dilution of all other dollar holders). Overnight loans are almost irrelevant to your point
because they're overnight.
Without printing $9 trillion to "inject liquidity" the banks would have gone bust when the capital call came. It was this overnight loan that allowed the banks to socialize the losses while privatizing the gains.Inflation has the important role of decreasing the value of debt, which is something demurrage does not provide. Neither does a constant rate of 'inflation' via demurrage allow any kind of countercyclical policy.
"[inflationary monetary policy] constitutes the redistribution of wealth via inflation from the people to the banks"
Do you have any evidence for that claim?
I did not dismiss deflation as an economic risk, it certainly could be. But I'm saying that deflation is toxic to our current economic structure, simply because we are inflation biased, and so everything is designed with that in mind. Switching from an inflationary economy to a deflationary one would certainly be devastating.. but in the long run, once the correction had happened, what would it be like? That's a question we actually don't have a lot of evidence on.
My thoughts on this came right out of this book: http://www.amazon.com/Deflation-Current-Historical-Perspecti...
I think that the salient issue with Bitcoin is that it is going to deflationary at a set time and while people may hoard it, its divisibility 1/(10^8) should allow it to be used for exchange for a very long time.
I'm eager to see what happens. As far as I know, this is an unprecedented experiment in absolute scarcity psychology. Real Estate is still being developed, gold and other precious metals can be mined, but past a point, Bitcoin won't be. Imagine the economies around irreplaceable fine art along with divisibility. My suspicion is that Bitcoin has been given sociological imprinteur as a store of value, and it is hard for that to be erased entirely. In curious whether later virtual currencies can compete in a way which devalues Bitcoin.
In terms of true free market currencies what you usually found were tally sticks and cheques; debt based money with no gold backing. But these currencies had personal history to them and would only be honored within webs of social trust. The issuing name on the cheque and the chain of endorsements were considered when accepting payment.
For just one example of how this presentation is
misleading, gold has never really been selected by free
markets as a currency.
"Never"? Quite the opposite. Gold was seized by Roosevelt with Executive Order 6102 to prevent people from using gold as a currency. Nixon pulled the dollar off the gold standard in 1971 as the US Treasury didn't have enough gold to finance the war in Vietnam, and he feared a run on the banks. On both those occasions, people wanted to get into gold, but the government prevented them from doing so. And today physical gold has been bought by millions of people as a hedge against the world financial crisis.On these occasions and more people would use gold as a currency if they weren't prevented by law (= men with guns) from doing so; this is the opposite of the claim that "gold has never really been selected by free markets".
imperial governments with big war machines minted gold
and silver coins, paid soldiers and military contractors
with them, and then required the coins back from the
general population in payment of taxes. This fostered
markets to service the war machine.
Speaking of counterfactual claims, the war machine is actually powered by printing money. The reason Nixon got the US off the gold standard was to print money to finance the Vietnam War. Every major war in the US (Civil War, WW1, WW2) has involved increases in US debt, inflation, and printing of money to facilitate the massive/rapid seizures of wealth that governments use to fight and win wars.That is not accurate. People were hoarding gold at the time, which was harming the economy. Gold currency was taken out of circulation by the government and replaced by a currency less prone to hoarding. Hoarding stopped because people were given money that was not worth hoarding -- which is a good thing for the economy.
"today physical gold has been bought by millions of people as a hedge against the world financial crisis"
Which is not a currency, any more than a building, a field, or a gun is currency.
"On these occasions and more people would use gold as a currency if they weren't prevented by law"
Nobody in this century is prevented from using gold as a currency, just like nobody is prevented from using Bitcoin as a currency. The only difference is that gold is not legal tender. People tend to gravitate towards legal tender as a currency, probably because people live in a society governed by laws and need to legally repay their debts (taxes and others).
The problem, of course, is that it only works when you have a small number of trustable people (I'll leave Dunbar's number out of this, pick your favorite). When you get into the realm of billions of people, it's a system that just doesn't work. And there's plenty of romanticism out there from people that would love to go back to such a system. But -that- to me is ideologically driven economics. I'm not saying that Bitcoin is morally superior, or that gold is better than paper money, I'm trying to relay the verdict that large numbers of decentralized people have arrived at. Which could be a worse system in many ways.
But I'm not so sure, for the reasons you bring up. I do agree with you that governments capture these systems and control them. And the principal reason for this has been to wage war. War is so closely attached to control and devaluation of money, that you can almost predict monetary instability based on it, as these governments use it as a form of taxation. We've had quite a few currency devaluations in our own history, beginning with the colonies during the Revolutionary War (printing money to pay the soldiers, that they would take home and discover was essentially worthless).
This is where Bitcoin becomes interesting: It becomes a form of gold that is so liquid, that it is arguable if a government could even take control of it. You certainly can't stop someone from going through customs at the airport with it (or are we going to require a scan of all computers before leaving the country now?). If Bitcoin prevents/disrupts governments from amassing war chests, I see that as a potentially very positive development. Time will tell, as with all things.
David Graeber, on that quote:
"The endlessly cited Apple quote was not supposed to be about Apple. Actually it was about a whole of series of other tiny start-ups created by people who’d dropped out of IBM, Apple, and similar behemoths. (Of them it’s perfectly true.) The passage got horribly garbled at some point into something incoherent, I still can’t completely figure out how, was patched back together by the copyeditor into something that made logical sense but was obviously factually wrong. I should have caught it at the proofreading stage but I didn’t. I did catch it when the book first came out, tried to get the publisher to take it out, and have been continually trying since July. All to no avail. I have absolutely no idea why a book can go through eight editions and it’s impossible to pull out a couple lines of obviously incorrect text but they just keep telling me, no, I have to wait until July. Allow me to reassure the reader: You have absolutely no idea how frustrating this is, especially as the stupid line has been held out, reproduced, sent around in every conceivable way to suggest that nothing else in the book is likely to be factually accurate To which all I can reply is: well, notice how this is the only quote in the book that happens with. That one sentence gets repeated a thousand times. No other one does. That’s because it’s the only sentence flagrantly wrong like that. In fact, I’ve communicated with, or read reviews by, scholars of Greece, Mesopotamia, and Islam, Medievalists, Africanists, historians of Buddhism, and a wide variety of economists, etc, etc, and none have noticed any glaring errors—in fact, the most frequent reaction is that it’s remarkable that someone who is not an area specialist actually more or less gets it right (remember, these are scholars often loathe to admit even their own colleagues in the field get it more or less right.) The book is pretty meticulously researched and has stood up to scholarly review. The problem is I haven’t been able to get the one idiotic garbled sentence out despite my utmost endeavors. But it will be. They promise. Soon."
And while you're at it, go easy on the "downvote = agree disagreement" habit.
For context: Graeber got into a spat with some dude at the Mises Institute, which kicked up a hornets nest of people who never read the book to go nuclear on it, posting nasty reviews on Amazon etc.
SilasX, have you read the book? If not, why are you commenting on it?
Do you want to tackle the problem of why the "temple units" happened to be silver?
Also, even if my post was genuinely deserving of a downvote, I hope you recognize that you should leave that job to someone else, as you have too much invested in this topic to be objective (as does anyone replying in a similar position).
It opens with a story about how currency came from barter, but barter is a way of exchanging goods with outsiders, which is not the main way of trading in a functioning society. Money didn't arise as a way of making barter systems practical, it arose as a way of memorializing debt obligations that eventually got securitized into something you could exchange for stuff directly.
The parts about how the USD works and the suggestion that Demurrage would do anything at all to fix the deflation issue are also particularly weak.
It also doesn't do any favors to Bitcoin by suggesting Freicoin alongside it; It's possible to imagine a world where the advantages of Bitcoin economics outweigh the disadvantages, but Freicoin is outright kookery.